
UNSOLVED
Do I really need a 128 Mb video card?
Considering I use a PC for:
50 % internet (browsing, radio and TV)
20 % word processing
15 % 3D games (not very demanding and not action games)
10 % CD and DVD data burning
5 % photo editing (Photoshop and Corel)
...and the PC will be:
DESKTOP INSPIRON 530 UBUNTU (+XP Pro as 2nd OS)
Intel Core 2 Duo E4500
RAM: 2 GB DDR2 SDRAM 667 MHz
Monitor: digital 19” or 20”
Integrated Intel graphics media accelerator 3100
Will I need a 128 Mb video card?
What do you suggest?
Thanks.
Responses (5)
Solutions (0)
I somewhat agree with SR45, however it depends on exactly what you mean by photo editing. If you already have Photoshop and Corel and don't need to upgrade to a newer version any time soon, then you may be able to get by just fine without the extra video memory. It depends on the requirements for the programs you are using and also how you will be using them.
Since you mentioned photo editing is only 5%, that may mean you are doing very basic tasks like resizing, cropping, and some touchup work, likely on photos taken with a 5 megapixel or less camera. If this is the case, and you aren't using the newest version of Photoshop, for example, you may be fine with a 64mb video card. This is especially true if you will only be editing photos occasionally and speed is not a big concern of yours.
However, 128mb+ video cards aren't very expensive these days, and will offer you better performance and will more likely support your needs in the future.
@fladin wrote:
Hi. Considering the previous 2 answers I'm going to order the PC without video card. If in the future i will notice problems or slowdowns...then I will install it. Wise decision?
Just a last doubt. Does the video card improve image quality (in the digital LCD monitor) ?
Thanks again.
No not for basic viewing. The onboard will look fine, just set the Resolution to the optimal for your LCD.
The only thing you will really lose off the bat, is system RAM. Onboard uses a chunk of your System RAM. So if you order it with only 1GB ram, you may want a Video card then.
A better video card improves video quality on mainly 3D apps, esp at higher resolutions/colors, and can do it at a FASTER speed.
Hi. Considering the previous 2 answers I'm going to order the PC without video card. If in the future i will notice problems or slowdowns...then I will install it. Wise decision?
Just a last doubt. Does the video card improve image quality (in the digital LCD monitor) ?
Thanks again.
A dedicated (not onboard) video card might also help in some circumstances where viewing videos, to make them look smoother, and would also give you more options to calibrate your display for more accurate color reproduction, in case you were that serious about editing photos and such.
However, there is a very good chance you'll be fine without the video card. Maybe not. You'll see when you get it. However, it won't cost you any more (except maybe added shipping costs) to buy the card later on it's own. Also, video card prices are constantly falling, so by waiting to get one, you will most likely either save yourself some money or be able to get a better one for the same price.
Another option, since you aren't doing any real intensive gaming or 3D application work, is to just buy a used card from eBay or Craigslist or something.
I have a feeling you'll be fine without the card. Like was already mentioned, the one thing you'll want to do right away for best picture quality on your new computer is to set the display resolution to the native resolution of your LCD monitor. This will prevent unnecessary distortion of the image displayed on the monitor.

SR45
2 Intern
•
12138 Posts
259
0
Posted May 4th, 2008 21:00
Photo Editing, then you should get a dedicated video card with at least 256 mb of memory if not 512 mb. Do a Google Search on photo editing system requirements and you will find some of those programs recommend at least 256 if not more memory on the video card.
If you want to play games or even just a few really nice games that interest you now or later, then yes, its better to have a nice video card with at least 128 mb of onboard memory if not more depending on the game and the size monitor you have. We have heard from many that decide to play a new game later on and do not have the video card that can play it and complain about it. Get a dedicated card and have fewer worries later on.