Right now my XP pro is running perfectly on my inspiron. My question is what would be the best method to install vista. I plan on doing a clean install.
1) Should i just do a clean install from XP as it is right after removing all conflicting programs first?
2) Would it be beneficial to format my computer with XP, download only the Xp drivers, and then do a clean install?
3) Other suggestions?
I would just like for this vista install to be the least problematic as possible. Is there any main issue with vista that i should be know before installing? I mostly just use my comp for itunes, school work, and surfing the web.
Well the upgrade advisor would notify you about potential problems ahead of time so, if read the problems it finds you can take care of those problems before you install. Lets keep in mind that ITunes is still not completely Vista Compatible and corruption is possible using Ipods and Windows Vista.
Message Edited by andreychuk on 04-13-2007 10:47 AM
Well you can't do an upgrade from xp pro to vista, so you have to do a clean install!
Question 2, what???
I thought a clean install is, when everything is deleted and Vista installs itself, so what is the meaning to download only XP drivers, and then do a clean install???
But I'm not an expert, hopefully someone else will answer better!
Doing a clean install will remove all programs anyway, so it's not necassary to remove conflicting programs first. This is your only option in terms of going from XP Pro to Home Premium as you can see here:
In other words, there is no way to "upgrade" without losing all your current files and setting. Thus, your first step will be a thourough backup. I would also suggest doing a clean Vista install using the method found on the Windows Supersite:
This method eliminates the need to have XP installed when you upgrade. As such, there is no chance of old files messing with your shiny new OS. I used the above instructions and have had no problems at all so far.
If you have any more questions, feel free to drop another note.
Really? I've used this method several times on several different machines (and continue to recommend it) and in every case is produced an absolutely clean install. Could you please explain what you mean? Thanks.
You can do an upgrade from pro to Vista and it will save your old files in a directory called 'windows.old. Most find that this is more of a pain than its worth however because there are alot of conflicting drivers.
My advice....run a clean install as i have described several times on this site (try search) then download any drivers you need from dell.
Do not...I repeat do not.... use Paul Thurots Supersite. It does not give you a clean install and is very outdated. All you need to do is insert and boot from the windows Vista disk. Select clean installation and proceed. see here...
If you have used this system of upgrade several times, you have wasted alot of time. Its been very well known since the Dell Upgrade disks were released that the 'double upgrade' procedure is unnecessary.
Its also not a clean install as it does not wipe your partition. You are just installing over previous versions.
Why would you ever follow that method when you can just
1.Insert Disk
2. Boot from disk
3. Select clean install (not upgrade)
4. designate partition to be used
5. Install
6. Register
Further, here is the information from Thurrot
"If you try to activate Windows now, it will fail, because you've performed a clean install of Vista and you only have an Upgrade product key."
This is patently false and out of date. The upgrade key works just fine on a clean install. You dont need to double install
Oh and apologies. It gives you a clean install if you enter the reg number after the first installation. By upgrading/reinstalling again, this is not a new installation and is what I meant.
I did a clean install with the Express Upgrade discs and it worked and as flamenko said is it not necassery to use Paul Thurrot's way to do a clean install.
I think we're maybe getting hung up a bit with semantics and maybe some assumptions. I'm not trying to be argumentative, but I'd like to make a few points.
1) Maybe I've "wasted a lot of time", but being retired, I can afford the extra 20 minutes or so that Thurrott's procedure takes. Gives me an extra few minutes to grab another cup of coffee and a smoke (I know, I know - it's a bad habit).
2) It IS a clean install if you format the partition during the install, so it's not really installing over previous versions - except itself of course (I may be wrong, but I believe the method you advocate also formats the partition).
3) I guess that technically, the second install (installing over the first installation) could be called an "upgrade", but in essence, this procedure is simply replacing "file-x" with the same "file-x".
4) I think you're assuming that everyone is using the Dell Upgrade disks and the Dell OEM product keys. I have no doubt that your procedure will work "as advertised" with the Dell disks, but will it work with Retail Versions? There are many users with Vista compatible hardware who did not buy their systems during the "Express Upgrade" time frame and who will have to purchase upgrade retail copies of Vista.
I have not tried your method with retail versions, but I suspect that Thurrott may be correct in stating that the activation will fail in these situations because of the Upgrade product key being used. If you can verify that a Clean Install can be performed with Retail Upgrade Media using your procedure, then I'll certainly follow that procedure in the future. I'll just have to squeeze in that extra coffee and smoke another time.
I bought the Ultimate upgrade version for my primary system and decided to install the 64bit version, in order to install it I had to boot from the DVD as when I tried installing from windows, Windows would not run the install program (64bit) and told me to boot from the DVD, I entered the key when asked for and formatted my hard drive and it installed fine and has not given me any problems. Now I have not tried doing this using the 32bit version.
andreychuk
1 Rookie
•
527 Posts
245
0
Posted April 13th, 2007 14:00
Message Edited by andreychuk on 04-13-2007 10:47 AM