List of SSDs certified to play nicely with a PERC H710P and have FDE managed by
LKM?
Does anyone happen to have a link or even first-hand experience with what SSDs I can purchase that will enable me to use the FDE capabilities and have all the SSDs in the array managed by the LKM of the PERC H710P controller? This has been an exceptionally challenging question to get answered authoritatively.
The SSD part numbers will possibly differ due to the server being used. To get you more accurate information, would you let me know the server model you are using?
DELL-Chris H
Social Media and Communities Professional
Dell Technologies | Enterprise Support Services
#IWork4Dell
Did I answer your query? Please click on ‘Mark as Accepted Answer’. ‘Thumbs up’ the posts you like!
Thank you for replying! Yes, these are going into a Dell R610. I am aware that the H710P isn't certified in an R610, but into one it goes nonetheless. :) Thank you.
I'd say a minimum of 100 GB each. 240 GB each would be the high side estimate. What are the options in that range?
But more to my point that may be applicable to future readers of this thread - what is the way to find out what Dell SSD offerings work with which RAID cards and have proper handling of the FDE capabilities? Is there not a document or configuration tool to which you can point me and others to find this information out ourselves? Don't get me wrong, I love that you are helping me here - truly!
I am not aware of a tool that would determain the SSD's to the controller. The SSD compatibility is generally based on the server, not by the controller. As the controllers compatibility is general to the server it is in. With crossing the generations with controllers, it isn't supported by Dell in most cast, which means it isn't tested. So determining the SSD based on the controller, outside of its normal use, would be hit and miss. Now that being said, a lot of the SSD's are going to be cross compatible with multiple server models.
Here are some of the supported SSD's for your server.
G5G38 or G613R - 100GB SSD-SATA, 2.5", Samsung SS805
VH27H- 160GB SSD, SATA, 2.5", Intel Wolfsville
24XV8 - 200GB SSD-SATA, 2.5", Samsung MLC
DELL-Chris H
Social Media and Communities Professional
Dell Technologies | Enterprise Support Services
#IWork4Dell
Did I answer your query? Please click on ‘Mark as Accepted Answer’. ‘Thumbs up’ the posts you like!
I will look into the Samsung drives. I've historically used Intel SSDs, but a couple of months ago tried with Intel DC S3700 drives and found that the H710P doesn't recognize them as being encryption capable. In fact, I posted on a Spiceworks forum and then on Intel's community forum. Intel came back and said that the raid controller "..uses a TCG-enterprise storage specification. At this time, Intel SSD's do not support this method of managing drive encryption." I even contacted LSI tech support to get an answer and they redirected me back to Dell for H710P-related questions, IIRC. (been a few months) At least a Micron rep has replied in the Spiceworks forum with a drive of their own that will work with the encryption, but I am unsure whether the H710P will come up with the amber light because the Micron drive came out after the RAID card and is not certified by Dell to work with that controller.
Given the DC S3500 (aka Wolfsville) that you were provided in a configuration guide, I am surprised. I am less conversant with the Samsung SSDs and will have to see if they have TCG-enterprise storage specification compliance.
The two other servers I've used with the H710P do have Intel DC S3700 and DC S3710 SSDs in them and the controller and server are working well with the drives. But in neither case was encryption required.
I have yet to actually hear or read from an end user or even reviewer who has used SSDs in an encrypted setup on one of these or LSI MegaRAID controllers. I figure that it *has* to have been done and that I'm just not putting the correct terms in a search engine.
Given at least the Samsung SS805 you list, I'll look that up and see what I can find. "Samsung MLC" isn't specific enough for me to really research. I've read plenty where people were using Samsung consumer-grade drives and the H710s throw up an amber light the entire time. My client is open to buying one of each for me to verify LKM operability with the SSD's built-in encryption abilities, but I just feel like there should be information available actually detailing such scenarios.
Again, thank you for your help. Again, I am shocked at how difficult this challenge has been to solve. It's hard to think I'm on the leading edge of any technology. I figure the big boys have HAD to be doing this years before I ever thought about it.
Chris, from what I've been able to absorb, the PERC H710P uses the Trusted Computing Group-Enterprise (TCG-E) specification for handling the encryption key for the SSDs attached to the RAID card. That means for any SSDs to have their SED capabilities interface with the controller (and thus be actually usable by the customer), the SSDs need to be TCG-E compliant.
From what I'm understanding, Micron has only just now come out with the first SATA TCG-E drives. Now, there may be SAS drives that are TCG-E compliant, but I'm just not in that league.
Intel's statement about none of their drives being TCG-E compliant also supports the information I'm gathering. So if I understand everything, then none of the SATA SSDs Dell lists as certified to work with the PERC H710P would actually have the encryption management functionality work. Certainly the Samsung SS805 which appears to have been out at least five years won't work.
Again, I completely understand that you're working with the tools provided you. I don't know if you have an internal mechanism for sending feedback into the organization to point out that this SED/TCG-E functionality with at least SATA SSDs should be investigated with drives and that functionality/certification should be documented and the system with which fine, helpful people such as yourself utilize should be updated to provide more accurate information.
What I do not know is whether the Micron drive, being so new, will have flashing amber lights because the H710P isn't certified to work with them. It looks like we'll order at least three of these for a RAID-5 array and I'll post my findings.
I hope this helps someone down the road. This has been a long, frustrating journey to do something that I was quite sure at least medical or military servers have been doing routinely for years now. Maybe they have - on SAS SSDs. :)
I have a R620 with PERC H710P Mini firmware 21.0.2-0001 driver 5.2.121.64 and a chassis with up to 8HD (can provide service tag if helpful).
Looking to speed up system, and maximized capacity with SSD, perferably hardware encrypted (currently using bitlocker on original seagate ST9500620SS drives).
DELL-Chris H
7 Practitioner
•
9682 Posts
•
48046 Points
11707
0
Posted October 12th, 2015 06:00
Ras5776,
The SSD part numbers will possibly differ due to the server being used. To get you more accurate information, would you let me know the server model you are using?
DELL-Chris H
Social Media and Communities Professional
Dell Technologies | Enterprise Support Services
#IWork4Dell
Did I answer your query? Please click on ‘Mark as Accepted Answer’. ‘Thumbs up’ the posts you like!