UNSOLVED

mtr123

updated

9 years ago

M

mtr123

3 Posts

0

66558

July 30th, 2015 06:00

Stacking S4048-ON switches with fiber?

I'm trying to stack two S4048-ON switches with fiber with no luck.

I can get link between switches with 1GBase-LR and 40G-LR4 optics but when I configure ports as stack-group theres no link anymore. I get link and stack working If I move switches closer and use direct attach cable.

So it looks like that stacking is not supported with fiber or is this just a bug? Switches are running software version 9.8(0.0P5).

  • mtr123

    3 Posts

    3924

    0

    Posted July 30th, 2015 23:00

    sw044009#show system stack-ports
    Topology: Stand alone
    Interface  Connection    Link Speed      Admin     Link
                              (Gb/s)        Status    Status
    ---------------------------------------------------------
    1/1                       10             up        down
    1/2                       10             up        down
    1/3                       10             up        down
    1/4                       10             up        down
    1/49                      42             up        down
    1/50                      42             up        down

    And other half:
    sw044009#show system stack-ports
    Topology: Stand alone
    Interface  Connection    Link Speed      Admin     Link
                              (Gb/s)        Status    Status
    ---------------------------------------------------------
    2/1                       10             up        down
    2/2                       10             up        down
    2/3                       10             up        down
    2/4                       10             up        down
    2/49                      42             up        down
    2/50                      42             up        down

    I'm using GP-10GSFP-1L and GP-QSFP-40GE-1LR4 transceivers. 10G is just for testing. Goal is to run stack with 2x40G.

    40GEs:

    MY-0H93DH-13602-4C1-00IE, USM1G6U
    MY-0H93DH-13602-4C2-00DL, USM1G5L
    MY-0H93DH-13602-4C6-009F, USM1G4V
    MY-0H93DH-13602-4C1-00G6, USM1G6S

    10GEs:

    MY-0RN84N-13602-533-00B6, AT90PDK
    MY-0RN84N-13602-533-009E, AT90PPR

  • radion1

    3 Posts

    3924

    0

    Posted March 23rd, 2017 00:00

    We experience exaclty the same issue but with QSFP-40G-BIDI (0XW7J0) Transceiver. When we change the ports to DAC cables the stack is connected immediately.
    The switches are on FTOS 9.10 (0.1P25).

  • radion1

    3 Posts

    3924

    0

    Posted March 24th, 2017 00:00

    It's an original Dell transceiver with the part number 0XW7J0/407-BBYC and yes it works fine for a non-stack connection.

    I opened a support case and the engineer confirmed that the BiDi Transceivers cannot be used for stacking connections.

    Dell really should communicate this restriction, there is no word about it in any document.

  • 3924

    0

    Posted May 16th, 2017 17:00

    Hi everybody,

    We are with the same problem, when we configure stacking using interfaces 40GB with DAC cable it is work well, but when we are using QSFP-SM4 dosen't work.

    Configuring this interfaces and QSFP SM4 like Uplink or L3 interface this QSFP Work well, normal without problem.

    Could you hem us resolve this problem?

  • 3924

    0

    Posted May 16th, 2017 18:00

    Hello,

    Did You solve this problem? We are with the same problem with QSFP SM4 (40G)

    Could you explain to resolve this problem?

    Best Regards

  • mtr123

    3 Posts

    3924

    0

    Posted May 16th, 2017 23:00

    Jul 2015 we could not get stack working so we moved to VLT. So far it has worked without problems.

  • 958

    0

    Posted May 17th, 2017 07:00

    Thanks, In our case we have 2 differents places where this switches S4048 will stay. Each place we'll put 2 switches using a DAC Cable in the same environment and using QSFP SM4 with fiber to stack with other switch in another place.

    Our custmomer want that these 4 switches working in stacking same they are in different places and, he doesn't want use another type of connection like a AOC cable for instance

    Follows our topology:

  • Stefan Banu

    1 Message

    830

    0

    Posted May 15th, 2018 01:00

    year 2018. We have same problem. Four S4048-ON, the customer ask for a stack, but doesn't work with 10Gb SR transceiver and fiber. Please note, now he have four old 8000 series in stack perfectly working on fiber. 2km between two sites.

    Stacking need only 1 IP per vlan

    VLT/VRRP need 5 IPs per vlan. He have a lots of vlan, someone is full, no more free IPs.

    I have no words....