UNSOLVED

sumanth41277

updated

20 years ago

0

15782

July 18th, 2006 15:00

recieved a refurbished 2007FPW monitor as replacement

Hey guys,

I Pmed chris a fortnight ago for the replacement of 2007FPW monitor for banding problems. Today i recieved the replacement, but on the top of the box it says its refurbished. Should i open the box or not? I need a new monitor and not a refurbished. what do i do now?.
  • btuch

    5 Posts

    557

    0

    Posted July 18th, 2006 15:00

    same story here (exactly the same in fact). my replacement (A02 from Mexico) also has nicks and scratches on the back and sides. it almost looks like it was used for a game of catch on the factory floor. gradient problem is still readily apparent in multimedia and gaming modes (was that supposed to be the case?).

    Chris, is this the monitor you intended to show up at my door?
  • 557

    0

    Posted July 18th, 2006 16:00

    call dell and return it and ask for a brand new replacement thats not been used. your entitled for a brand new unopened replaced.
  • 557

    0

    Posted July 18th, 2006 18:00

    Same boat here, received a 2007wfp replacement today. Opened it and it has some minor scuffs and nicks. Definitely not new and on top of that, they placed a (insert cuss word here) "Rev A02" sticker over the A00 label. I pealed it off, and behold underneath "A00 China". It was made in China so I think this was a return for the banding issue and they thought they'd just place a sticker over it. I was pretty angry, but I noticed MOST of the banding is gone, I say most because I still see some when I open my Front Row (I'm a Mac user). Also, the text seems a lot clearer and the viewing angles are better so I have a decision to make. I agree though, we should be getting brand new ones and this is no way to handle an exchange program for a WELL known issue. Shame on Dell, my first Dell product and I'd definitely not buy ing anything from Dell unless it was a monitor, but this is making me think otherwise. That Viewsonic vx2025 is looking like a missed opportunity now...Thanks Dell
  • iceeblue

    19 Posts

    557

    0

    Posted July 18th, 2006 22:00

    I would guess that they did not just put a sticker on it. More likly you got a A00 that had it firmware flashed. I got a something simliar and decided to keep it as I had no dead pixels. Bird in the hand is worth two in the bush and all that. The banding is still thier a little, but no worse than other LCD screen I have used.
  • 557

    0

    Posted July 18th, 2006 22:00

    the banding on A02 is worse than my fujitsu 19" LCD which when compared your paying $1200 for a "Super High-End" LCD so i would expect the LCD to have very close to no banding at all.
  • gpro

    2 Intern

    •

    2024 Posts

    557

    0

    Posted July 19th, 2006 00:00

    I think Chris said somewhere that replacements would be new and if you receive a refurbished unit you can send it back. I wish I knew how to ensure you get a new unit. Perhaps you should PM him.

    I understand that some people have received refurbs, however I don't think the A02 sticker implies that - there would have been some A00s in the pipeline that were re-flashed before sale.

    edit: found a link -
    http://forums.us.dell.com/supportforums/board/message?board.id=dim_monitor&message.id=61507#M61507

    Message Edited by gpro on 07-18-200609:02 PM

  • psyh

    80 Posts

    557

    0

    Posted July 19th, 2006 02:00

    I got a refurb A02 as well, but it looks new (no dents/scratches/smudges), everything works, and no dead or stuck pixels so I'm gonna keep it. This has been dragging on for way too long and if I have to return another monitor the UPS guy is gonna break my knee caps off.
  • btuch

    5 Posts

    557

    0

    Posted July 19th, 2006 03:00

    I PMed ChrisM and he said given that I arranged my exchange through him I should have received a new monitor rather than a refurbished one. I am returning mine and will keep doing so until Dell gets it right. I have been a satisfied customer of Dell for almost ten years, owning no less than six Dell laptops / desktops in that time. In the past I have been annoyed when they replaced crashed hard disks under warranty with refurbs. However, this is the first time they have truly let me down.
  • 557

    0

    Posted July 20th, 2006 19:00

    They did put a sticker Rev A02, i peeled it and there was anotehr sticker 'Rev A00'. But most of the banding is gone. I dont see any scratches or dead pixels or any other defect so far. SO i am gonna keep it. But this whole thing is bad. They should have stopped selling these monitors until the problems were fixed.
  • 141

    0

    Posted July 24th, 2006 03:00

    Hey guys, I also received an A02 (from Mexico) that came in a refurbished box. However, everything is clean as in no nicks or scratches. There were some imprints from something on the back, but it was easily wiped off. I've only tested it in VGA mode and it appears almost clear of banding. I don't know if it's a trick of the eye that I see a very slight hint of banding. Tomorrow I'm going to test my DVI connection and hopefully it'll be band free.

    Anyway, I had a question about the warranty. Since we received "refurbished" monitors (although mine looks new), our warranty is still the same right? As in we have a 3 yr versus the refurbished 90 day. Should we be offered any type of discount for receiving a refurbished monitor? We did buy brand new monitors and not used ones. Quite frankly, I'm tired of playing the exchange game.

    If this monitor is band free, I think I might end up keeping it. I just wouldn't feel totally satisfied especially if I really got a refurbished monitor rather than a new one. Any suggestions?