Dell 3007WFP-HC : S-MVA (or S-PVA) LCD panel instead of S-IPS one ?!
Hello,
I live in FRANCE.
I've just bought a Dell 3007WFP-HC at Dell FRANCE (by phone).
I've got a REV.A02.
I'm almost sure it does NOT use a S-IPS LCD panel, but a S-MVA (or S-PVA) one :
*Viewing angles are below average; black quickly becomes grayish.
*Sub-pixels shape ("boomerangs") is typical of S-MVA/S-PVA LCD panel; see here : http://webzeb.perso.free.fr/Boomerang.jpg I'm really disappointed.
The choice of a S-IPS LCD panel was critical for me (I need wide viewing angles).
Moreover, the LCD panel is different from the one the monitors reviewed by press use : not very fair play Dell !
Has anyone the same problem ?
Does anyone know which LCD panel is used in REV.A02 ? I think it's a CMO M300F1 (http://www.cmo.com.tw/opencms/cmo/products/monitor/products_monitor_M300F1.html?__locale=en); S-MVA panel would explain the very poor viewing angles...
There are only two companies I am aware of making 30" panels, Samsung and LG. LG has been doing S-IPS exclusively, and Samsung S-PVA exclusively (for the 30 inchers). Given that Dell has switched panels without any notification in the past, I wouldn't rule out the possibility of a swap. Let us know if you can conclusively deduce that it is one kind of a panel or another.
CMO (Chi Mei Optoelectronics) does too (M300F1 LCD panel) :
http://www.cmo.com.tw/opencms/cmo/products/monitor/products_monitor_M300F1.html?__locale=en
It's S-MVA, whose viewing angles are inferior to S-PVA (and obviously S-IPS).
As an owner of the HC, I know what you mean about the corners, but its definitely not a S-PVA thing. Do this; take a photo of the screen straight on, then take a photo at an extreme angle like 80 degrees off-center. And see the differences in shades.
Then compare that with what you perceive when you are close to the monitor and looking out to the corners. It should be the same.
The reason you don't perceive this on the other S-IPS panels is because you seldom sit 15 cm away from your 23" and look up to the corner. Go to an apple store and check out their 23" models up close and see for yourself.
Malow
87 Posts
1200
0
Posted August 22nd, 2007 22:00
http://img227.imageshack.us/img227/2917/ips03xk1.jpg
*VA are the "zebra in a block" ;)
http://img213.imageshack.us/img213/3963/ls37r81blcdsa1wa8.jpg
http://img391.imageshack.us/img391/172/spva2cx8.jpg