
UNSOLVED
Closed
My computer buying tips for those who are thinking about buying a newer toy! The alternative view.
The alternative view!
I view all lappys as "disposable consummables" with a useful two year life. Each year after really fading fast into obsolesence. (unlike Desktops which are easily and inexpensivly upgradable)
I decide what buy based on experience : Im 21 with 25 years of such experience!(46) Been using and buying PCs since the 8088!(look it up)! I have learned the following in the past 20 or so years in the computer commerce world...
1. What do I want/need to do TODAY?
2. What is the MINIMUM outlay/specs I need to do THAT? (Dont buy more than you need or will use, there is NO future in it.)
3. Seek information via forums, friends (be careful there, you'll get caught up in D**k measuring contests)/ Magazines etc.
4. Buy the lowest priced acceptable configuration and work up from there. ( a good RMA policy is mandatory)
5. NEVER ever buy the fastest GPU or CPU available. (This should be number 1)
6. Never buy Lappy with a desktop processor. (See 5150 overheat shutdown threads, Sager) The small price/performance benefit, if any,is not worth the H E AT ,weight,and battery issues. ,
7. Pass on all extended warranties and "idiot" insurance on All products. Especially those who add 20-30% to the intitial cost.(Even much more complex automobiles with thousands of parts electronic,computers and mechanical only charge 5% more and for a longer time!) Use Tylenol Pm to "sleep better" if you need it, or "Paxil for "peace of mind". (Its cheaper) Besides most computers are replaced not because they stopped running, but because they are obsolete. There are thousands of working PII and PII parts in boxes in garages all over the country. And plenty of old still running lappys as well.
Now understand I could not care less about 3DMark scores or synthetic bench marks or the wow factor from LAN party peers. Thats a sure way to spend way more than you need. Been there, burned there!! All that aside:
Because laptops and all systems are fairly obsolete in a couple years. (See the "loaded at the time" 81/8200 owners screaming for upgraded V cards etc threads) If you can get your current needs met with a minimum configuration, You can then save $1000-$1500 and use that money in two years to buy another refub under the then bleeding edge BUT BETTER AND FASTER THAN TODAYS" $2500 machine in any case for around the same money while the guys who have today's bleeding edge machine still have a year or two's worth of payments left. You will read their whining and petitioning to Dell for upgradable components.
The Top Of Line Lappy TODAY will not be the TOL Lappy in two months or weeks!. BUT YOU ARE PAYING TOL PRICES TODAY FOR THAT! You don't HAVE to!!
My humble machine runs ALL the games listed below well and even looks great in plan ole WXGA. I am used to a 19 inch CRT at 1178 rez. So WXGA is fine and of all the posts I have read, and I did read a lot. There were more issues with the SXGA+ and UXGA (too small for screen size issues, not electrical). I read of no one returning an SXGA for LCD issues. So I figured the SXGA would be fine and it's a SAMSUNG and it is indeed a great LCD in a comfiortable native resolution where ALL LCDs look their best and are the crispest.
All that said, I STILL ordered mine fully expecting to return it. After reading the many posts here and elsewhere regarding the 8600 I was "convinced" I had to have a 1.7 with a Radeon 9600 288mb V card (many of them were bad as well) to run any game without chop. You can imagine my surprise when IT ran everthing I threw at it with no second guessing frustrating experiences. I even edited a 7 min video for a local TV show. Like butta! Rendering time was equal to my 2.4 533 desktop.
If you really believe you need to chase 3D Mark scores well so be it. It's gonna be more expensive all around to chase that car and by the way, it never stops! If you can really "see" the difference between 70 and 110FPS, your stuck with paying the piper and yes own some bragging rights...for a while anyway..
It comes down to what do you want to do today? No matter what you spend, It's old news tomorrow. And someone will always have a better and faster machine at least on paper!
The following humbly spec'd machine runs the following games at med to high resolution:
MAx Payne II
Sim City 4
Madden 2003
Tiger Wood 2003
FS 2004 (locked at 30 FPS MIN)
GTA Vice City
Call of Duty
Medal of Honor
Now I Can't speak for Final Fantasy, Halo, Unreal, Jedi, Warcraft, Doom. I personally don't care for the SciFI or Fantasy type games.I prefer the real human stuff!
Believe it or not this 8600, purchased recently (still have 2 weeks to "upgrade") runs the above very well. And I have not had one reason or doubt to send it back for a better anything.
So those of you who want a decent gamer and run the games mentioned above, don't want to spend a lot for a disposable product, and especially aren't concerned with synthetic benchmarks like 3D Mark scores or hundreds of FPS, just real world application satisfactory rendered. Im here to say you don't NEED a high powered configuration with the latest bells and whistles.
Let the flaming begin!!!
8600 1.4
512 2700 ram
Nvidia 5200Go 64mb
DVD/CDRW
40 GB 5400 rpm
SXGA
Win XP Home
1 year warranty
$1268 refurb
I view all lappys as "disposable consummables" with a useful two year life. Each year after really fading fast into obsolesence. (unlike Desktops which are easily and inexpensivly upgradable)
I decide what buy based on experience : Im 21 with 25 years of such experience!(46) Been using and buying PCs since the 8088!(look it up)! I have learned the following in the past 20 or so years in the computer commerce world...
1. What do I want/need to do TODAY?
2. What is the MINIMUM outlay/specs I need to do THAT? (Dont buy more than you need or will use, there is NO future in it.)
3. Seek information via forums, friends (be careful there, you'll get caught up in D**k measuring contests)/ Magazines etc.
4. Buy the lowest priced acceptable configuration and work up from there. ( a good RMA policy is mandatory)
5. NEVER ever buy the fastest GPU or CPU available. (This should be number 1)
6. Never buy Lappy with a desktop processor. (See 5150 overheat shutdown threads, Sager) The small price/performance benefit, if any,is not worth the H E AT ,weight,and battery issues. ,
7. Pass on all extended warranties and "idiot" insurance on All products. Especially those who add 20-30% to the intitial cost.(Even much more complex automobiles with thousands of parts electronic,computers and mechanical only charge 5% more and for a longer time!) Use Tylenol Pm to "sleep better" if you need it, or "Paxil for "peace of mind". (Its cheaper) Besides most computers are replaced not because they stopped running, but because they are obsolete. There are thousands of working PII and PII parts in boxes in garages all over the country. And plenty of old still running lappys as well.
Now understand I could not care less about 3DMark scores or synthetic bench marks or the wow factor from LAN party peers. Thats a sure way to spend way more than you need. Been there, burned there!! All that aside:
Because laptops and all systems are fairly obsolete in a couple years. (See the "loaded at the time" 81/8200 owners screaming for upgraded V cards etc threads) If you can get your current needs met with a minimum configuration, You can then save $1000-$1500 and use that money in two years to buy another refub under the then bleeding edge BUT BETTER AND FASTER THAN TODAYS" $2500 machine in any case for around the same money while the guys who have today's bleeding edge machine still have a year or two's worth of payments left. You will read their whining and petitioning to Dell for upgradable components.
The Top Of Line Lappy TODAY will not be the TOL Lappy in two months or weeks!. BUT YOU ARE PAYING TOL PRICES TODAY FOR THAT! You don't HAVE to!!
My humble machine runs ALL the games listed below well and even looks great in plan ole WXGA. I am used to a 19 inch CRT at 1178 rez. So WXGA is fine and of all the posts I have read, and I did read a lot. There were more issues with the SXGA+ and UXGA (too small for screen size issues, not electrical). I read of no one returning an SXGA for LCD issues. So I figured the SXGA would be fine and it's a SAMSUNG and it is indeed a great LCD in a comfiortable native resolution where ALL LCDs look their best and are the crispest.
All that said, I STILL ordered mine fully expecting to return it. After reading the many posts here and elsewhere regarding the 8600 I was "convinced" I had to have a 1.7 with a Radeon 9600 288mb V card (many of them were bad as well) to run any game without chop. You can imagine my surprise when IT ran everthing I threw at it with no second guessing frustrating experiences. I even edited a 7 min video for a local TV show. Like butta! Rendering time was equal to my 2.4 533 desktop.
If you really believe you need to chase 3D Mark scores well so be it. It's gonna be more expensive all around to chase that car and by the way, it never stops! If you can really "see" the difference between 70 and 110FPS, your stuck with paying the piper and yes own some bragging rights...for a while anyway..
It comes down to what do you want to do today? No matter what you spend, It's old news tomorrow. And someone will always have a better and faster machine at least on paper!
The following humbly spec'd machine runs the following games at med to high resolution:
MAx Payne II
Sim City 4
Madden 2003
Tiger Wood 2003
FS 2004 (locked at 30 FPS MIN)
GTA Vice City
Call of Duty
Medal of Honor
Now I Can't speak for Final Fantasy, Halo, Unreal, Jedi, Warcraft, Doom. I personally don't care for the SciFI or Fantasy type games.I prefer the real human stuff!
Believe it or not this 8600, purchased recently (still have 2 weeks to "upgrade") runs the above very well. And I have not had one reason or doubt to send it back for a better anything.
So those of you who want a decent gamer and run the games mentioned above, don't want to spend a lot for a disposable product, and especially aren't concerned with synthetic benchmarks like 3D Mark scores or hundreds of FPS, just real world application satisfactory rendered. Im here to say you don't NEED a high powered configuration with the latest bells and whistles.
Let the flaming begin!!!
8600 1.4
512 2700 ram
Nvidia 5200Go 64mb
DVD/CDRW
40 GB 5400 rpm
SXGA
Win XP Home
1 year warranty
$1268 refurb
Message Edited by Tombo777 on 01-31-2004 07:08 PM
Message Edited by Tombo777 on 02-01-2004 03:57 AM
Responses (12)
Solutions (0)
Im not sure about #6.. the mobile processors of the same speed get higher ratings than the desktop processor, and I hope desktop processors aren't higher in price than mobile ones
Good post, #3 is my favorite. I got my lappy because of budget.. and Im careful with my desktop processor.
- No they are actually way less expensive. That was my point. The savings is not worth the slightly better performance over the 3.06. YOu see the heatsinks in those puppys on a desktop?
No wonder lappy makers are underclocking the GPU's. The air flow in a laptop is not adequate for the heat generated and unlike a desktop one does turn the machine off and on many times in it's life. The tiny circuit traces heat up, expand , then contract when cooled. After a few hundred times they may get brittle and open up. A lappy needs to stay cool so the expansion/contraction is to a much lesser extent.
The benchmark chasers are squeezing blood from turnips and the manufacturers are doing their best to give them what they want...Hence the beefy Sagers.No pentium M's there.
As long as there is a market..they will sell...build em and they will come!
Read about the heat issues there on the maxed out ones.
Your machine is way safe. My brother has the 5100..bought it awhile ago. It's been flawless for him. BUt his is not maxed out. You won't see the heat some 5150 ownere with the big GPUs and CPUs are having.
How is game playing on your machine with the 32 MB card? Im curious. What can you run and is there anything you cannot play well enough for your own enjoyment?Message Edited by Tombo777 on 02-01-2004 03:43 AM
- My first 'puter was CP/M...no games on that s*cker! My second was an XT, running Geoworks (much faster than the early Windoze). In support of the video card issue; my 15 month old notebook with the Geforce 460 plays most of the games you've mentioned - including: Halo, UT2K3, Jedi, Warcraft.
Well, I can play Midtown Madness 2 in the highest detail modes at 1024 and it runs perfectly, no lag except a little in high traffic.
Return to Castle Wolfenstein plays well on med-high detail.
I don't have any games newer than Sim City 4 actually, and that is the only game I do have that chugs--but that's also a RAM issue. I may upgrade to the M9 9000 like others have.
CatoftheNight
1 Rookie
•
523 Posts
758
0
Posted February 1st, 2004 17:00
I enjoy Halo on this Inspiron. I admit, it would be nice to have a few more frames. I get about 14 Fps, and when there's action going on I got 0's for FPS (Made me snort when I first saw it). But when you're shooting 20,000 fuel rod gun blasts, and there are 20 other people doing the same thing, plus another 40 people with rocket launchers (Serious exaggeration), and halo uses some 24 different textures for dust alone, and 30-somethin for flames/explosions, that's alot of rendering, so I'm still happy witht he performance. Another good tip for a nice price, wait for deals in the flyers dell sends out. I got a Dimension 8300 2.6HT 512MB RAM, 128mb FX5200, 120 GB HD, for only $1200CDN. It runs Halo much better ;)
Inspiron 2650
-------------------
1.6GHz Pentium 4-M
256MB RAM
30GB HD
Geforce2 Go 8MB <--Probably the only thing making 3D games slowinspiron600m
73 Posts
758
0
Posted February 1st, 2004 18:00
Whoa! We share nearly the exact same viewpoint!
The only difference is that I really really hate refurbished materials.
I purchased my 600m for $1300 during a time with great rebates and freebies.
It can run most games and again, I use it mostly for the mundane stuff.
And after two years, time to replace with something newer and better for again!!! a low price!
Brilliant!
- I think the refurb is a minnomer when it comes to Dell.
When I normally hear "refurb" I think of a returned warranty changeout after a year or two. rebuilt then sent out. Maybe with the 5100 and 8500 that have been out awhile, but not with the 8600 and later ones/ Dells refubs are mostly returns based on their 30 day total satisfaction guarentee. They really are 30 days NEW!!
I even prefer to buy floor models of elecltronincs becasue I KNOW they work if they have been running straight for a period of time , in all likelyhood all will be well for many years, especially TV's. inspiron600m
73 Posts
758
0
Posted February 5th, 2004 03:00
yeah...i've heard a lot of cases where people didnt like the laptops and returned them after 30 days
but i still like getting a brand new machine
knowing that i'm the only one who has ever used it
(besides the techinicans for testing)
it's worth the extra $100 or $200 just to have that peace of mind
- "Peace of mind" is expensive these days
$200-$400 extra for "new"
20-30%% more for extended warranties $300
$100-200 Complete care "idiot insurance'
Up to $900 for "peace of mind"...No wonder Fear Factor is such a hit!!!
kava kava $12 a bottle!!
8600 1.4
15.4 WXGA
512 333mhz ram
40 GB (5200 rpm)
NVidia 5200Go 64mb
DVD/CDRW
INtel wireless
Win XP Home
1 year mail in.
$1268 (refurb)
3D mark 2002 .000052 At avg 1 FPSMessage Edited by Tombo777 on 02-05-2004 03:36 AM

CSmith06
2 Intern
•
956 Posts
749
0
Posted January 31st, 2004 11:00
EDIT: Nice post by the way.
Message Edited by CSmith06 on 01-31-2004 07:50 AM