UNSOLVED

Dsolow

updated

18 years ago

Closed

D

Dsolow

2 Posts

0

10130

July 29th, 2008 15:00

M1530 arriving soon, advice?

Hi, my M1530 is "in production" and should be shipped in a few days.

 

I just learned that these computers seem to fail pretty reguarly.  

 

A few questions:

 

1. Is this failure inevitable? If so, how can dell justify selling the product?

 

2. If the failure is not inevitable, what can I do to prevent it?

 

If it is inevitable, I'll be buying a Mac. My sister and friends already recommend them, but I've never had any trouble with Dell in the past, so I stuck with them for this laptop.

 

It would be pretty immoral to sell computers that will fail soon after use. I can't see a company getting away with that easily in today's market, so I'm a bit skeptical about all the complaints.

 

Thanks for any help. 

  • ejn63

    11 Legend

    •

    87469 Posts

    •

    321256 Points

    496

    0

    Posted July 29th, 2008 15:00

    All notebooks will eventually fail;  no one knows when.  The best defense is a 3-4 year warranty;  after that point, most systems are ready for retirement anyway.

     

    As for Apple, it hasn't yet weighed in on changes to battle the thermal cycling problems - but is DOES use the same chips as everyone else, and there's no reason to think its notebooks are any less subject to the nVidia problem.  If you buy a Mac, get a 3-year AppleCare warranty - they won't do anything longer than that.

     

    If you're worried about the video issues and need a 15" notebook unlikely to have them, either buy one with Intel integrated video, not nVidia - or consider one of the new Dell Studio 15" notebooks, which use ATI video chips.

     

    Rumor has it the next generation of Mac notebooks will not have nVidia video - just as Dell has been releasing ATI-based models.

     

     

  • Matto2134

    81 Posts

    496

    0

    Posted July 29th, 2008 16:00

    Like ejn said, any PC that has an Nvidia 84xx or 86xx gpu will have the same problem, it's not isolated to Dell's units.  What you should do is make sure you have a 3 year warranty.  When you receive your PC, you should immediately flash the BIOS to the latest revision (A09, I believe).  This will keep the GPU cooler by running the fan more often.  It's far from the ideal solution, but it's all they've got until this whole mess is sorted.

  • 496

    0

    Posted July 29th, 2008 16:00

    They should, if the customer wants to, replace the motherboard with an equivalent GPU next time the motherboard burns rather than replacing the motherboard with the other defective GPU. I don't know why they don't have that kind of an option.

     

    Running the fan all the time is just a way to slow the process, not to prevent it. I'd rather keep an older BIOS so motherboard does burn so I get new motherboards while the warranty lasts, and as soon as the warranty expires, I'll get a new BIOS. :p

    Message Edited by the5threvolution on 07-29-2008 12:54 PM
    Message Edited by the5threvolution on 07-29-2008 01:27 PM
  • Dsolow

    2 Posts

    496

    0

    Posted July 29th, 2008 17:00

    Thanks for the replies so far, much appreciated.

  • Kafkar

    133 Posts

    496

    0

    Posted July 29th, 2008 21:00


    @Dsolow wrote:

    Hi, my M1530 is "in production" and should be shipped in a few days.

     

    I just learned that these computers seem to fail pretty reguarly.  

     

    A few questions:

     

    1. Is this failure inevitable? If so, how can dell justify selling the product?

     

    2. If the failure is not inevitable, what can I do to prevent it?

     

    If it is inevitable, I'll be buying a Mac. My sister and friends already recommend them, but I've never had any trouble with Dell in the past, so I stuck with them for this laptop.

     

    It would be pretty immoral to sell computers that will fail soon after use. I can't see a company getting away with that easily in today's market, so I'm a bit skeptical about all the complaints.

     

    Thanks for any help. 


     

    Here is my answer, honestly: I would cancel my order IMMEDIATELY and look for something else. I would definitely STAY AWAY from those notebooks who have affected GPUs.

     

    Under no condition would I have bought the computer if I had known that it would have such a defective GPU!

  • hotrent1

    239 Posts

    496

    0

    Posted July 30th, 2008 02:00

    Before you go somewhere else, look at their forums and you will find the same there as here.  There are problems with all companies and the majority of the people that have one, will post on a forum.  How many posts say, this is an awesome computer, and service is the best.  Do something wrong and they will tell 10 people, Do something right and they tell 1 person.  This is my third Dell Laptop and the best. 

    I am happy i purchased this m1530 and i learn from the techs here on the forum and disregard the few that have to badmouth 'Dell.  My saying has always been, you have to be smarter than the machine.

     

  • steve_89

    552 Posts

    496

    0

    Posted August 1st, 2008 05:00

    Everything has a life cycle.With the current Nvida cards the life cycle will just be shorter.Personaly im waiting.My 9300 has NEVER had a issue.And i use it everyday.Next round of cards i bet will run alot cooler.And thats where ill put my money.