UNSOLVED

b-o-s-s

updated

20 years ago

BO

b-o-s-s

2 Posts

0

40491

July 28th, 2006 09:00

Precision 690 - initially too slow, but sloved

Hi,

we got a new Prcision 690 and were very disappointed with its initial performance for CAD. The benchmark was to open a large assembly in Pro/Engineer, and it took far too long for this highend machine.

After a lot of investigation it turned out that the SATA hard drive was the culprit. We had to disconnect it from the SAS controller and instead use one of the Intel onboard ports in AHCI mode. Then we installed the "Intel Matrix Storage Manager" Software (v6.0.0.1022). DO NOT USE THE SATA DRIVER FROM THE DELL PAGE!

Performance rised about factor 4, which is pretty impressive. Opening the assembly now takes around 3 min, wheras it was 12 min. It's probably the enabled NCQ that pays off impressively here, though I'm not sure every application will benefit that much.

Oh, another thing: Has anyone noticed the low memory bandwith of around 25.5 MiB/s (measured with Sandra 2007) ? Even my 2 year old P4-3.2 manages nearly twice as much...
  • ntheno

    44 Posts

    900

    0

    Posted July 28th, 2006 19:00

    Hi, I just tried Sandra 2007 on my Precision 690 and got much higher memory bandwdith numbers than you see. 

    Benchmark Results
    RAM Bandwidth Int Buff'd iSSE2 : 6664 MB/s
    RAM Bandwidth Float Buff'd iSSE2 : 6665 MB/s
    Results Interpretation : Higher index values are better.

    Int Buff'd iSSE2 (Integer STREAM) Results Breakdown
    Assignment : 6751MB/s
    Scaling : 6869MB/s
    Addition : 6605MB/s
    Triad : 6432MB/s
    Data Item Size : 16 byte(s)
    Buffering Used : Yes
    Offset Displacement Used : Yes
    Bandwidth Efficiency : 63% (estimated)

    Float Buff'd iSSE2 (Float STREAM) Results Breakdown
    Assignment : 6667MB/s
    Scaling : 6875MB/s
    Addition : 6573MB/s
    Triad : 6548MB/s
    Data Item Size : 16 byte(s)
    Buffering Used : Yes
    Offset Displacement Used : Yes
    Bandwidth Efficiency : 63% (estimated
    )

  • b-o-s-s

    2 Posts

    900

    0

    Posted July 31st, 2006 10:00

    Sorry, I just see I posted the wrong memory bandwith number. It should have been

    RAM Bandwidth Int Buff'd iSSE2 : 2583 MB/s
    RAM Bandwidth Float Buff'd iSSE2 : 2853 MB/s

    of course...

    Still, you've got more than twice as much. How can this be?
    What CPU and memory configuration do you have?

    We have a single XEON 5050 (dual core, 3.0 GHz) with 2 GB RAM, which, according to the BIOS, runs in Dual channel mode. FSB at 667 MHz and memory at 533 MHz. Pretty strange, I think...

    Thanks for reply!
  • ntheno

    44 Posts

    900

    0

    Posted July 31st, 2006 12:00

    So, your configuration is quite a bit different than mine.  That probably explains the difference in our numbers.

    I've got two Xeon 5130 CPUs (2.0GHz with 1333 FSB) and four 1GB 667MHz DIMMs.

    When you install four matched DIMMs, you get quad channel memory mode with is faster than dual channel.  Also, my FSB and memory clock speeds are faster than yours.

     

    Message Edited by ntheno on 07-31-200610:02 AM

  • 900

    0

    Posted August 1st, 2006 15:00



    @ntheno wrote:

    So, your configuration is quite a bit different than mine.  That probably explains the difference in our numbers.

    I've got two Xeon 5130 CPUs (2.0GHz with 1333 FSB) and four 1GB 667MHz DIMMs.

    When you install four matched DIMMs, you get quad channel memory mode with is faster than dual channel.  Also, my FSB and memory clock speeds are faster than yours.

     

    Message Edited by ntheno on 07-31-200610:02 AM



    Indeed.  Excellent point.
  • HDTechnical

    29 Posts

    900

    0

    Posted August 16th, 2006 16:00

    Great - I KNEW it was a drive issue.  Write speeds are horrendous.

    So we're using the SAS controller for a mirrored raid configuration.  Sounds  like this isn't going to work if we really want to USE the system.

  • YannickM

    11 Posts

    900

    0

    Posted August 25th, 2006 08:00

    Hi,
    Got same problem with memory speed...
    I have 2 x 2 Gb, and sisandra gave a bandwith half of the one I got on a 670
    RAM Bandwidth Int Buff'd iSSE2 1707 MB/s
    RAM Bandwidth Float Buff'd iSSE2 1700 MB/s
    I haven't found settngs in BIOS or what to do to solve that issue.
    I'm running XP64, and we got that problem on several machine in my company.

    I sent that to Dell support, and waiting for answer...

    Yannick
  • YannickM

    11 Posts

    900

    0

    Posted August 25th, 2006 13:00

    Interesting test.
    Well, the Sales rep didn't suggested it to me, so I supposed it was fine with 2 Dimms only.
    So if those machine are not able to run properly with only 2 DIMMS, they should not sell them this way. It is not the customer to have to guess what is the proper config to run it.

    Also they are running anyway in Dual channel, so I didn't expect it to be too soo slow.
    And note that I have a power edge with also only 2 Dimms, and I got a bandwith around 5000 MB/s.
    Even on 3 years old PC, medium range, I have a bandwith around 4000 MB/s.

    I will see if I can get some memory from DEll, and do a test. I will keep youposted with Dell support answer.

    Thanks
  • ntheno

    44 Posts

    900

    0

    Posted August 25th, 2006 13:00

    Hi Yannick,

    If memory performance and bandwidth was important to you, why did you just get 2 DIMMs?  See the note on the Dell order page:

    The Dell Precision 690 has a quad memory bus architecture, Dell recommends that all four memory channels be populated with DIMMs for maximum performance.

    On my system, I have four 1GB 667MHz DIMMs and got a Sandra score of ~6600 MB/s.  As a test, I just removed two and ran the benchmark with two 1GB 667MHz DIMMs and got a score of ~2500 MB/s.

  • tphillips63

    4 Apprentice

    •

    2629 Posts

    •

    7922 Points

    900

    0

    Posted August 26th, 2006 03:00

    Here is a good and quick article on FB DDR2
    http://www.anandtech.com/mac/showdoc.aspx?i=2811&p=4
  • YannickM

    11 Posts

    234

    0

    Posted September 25th, 2006 08:00

    Was painful, long and difficult, but got Dell to exchange my 2 Dimms, by 4 Dimms.
    That get my analysis performance to reasonable value.

    But for a 3.8 GHz, this machine is similar as a precision 670 with a 3.4 GHz processor.

    So I'm not really enthousiast about those 690, and by the fact that Dell is selling those machine without 4 Dimms by default...