
UNSOLVED
Does the fan noise from your 4500 bother you?
Background:
Bought a Dell XPS D233 in 1998. Still have it. No problems.
At work I service 231 Dell GX150s, running CPUs that clock over 1GHz. I'm impressed by these Dells because they're so quiet that I have to look at the power light to see if they're on, even when I have the cover open.
Problem:
Took delivery of a Dimension 4500 on 6/21/02. The NMB fan (item 9M060) that cools the Pentium 4 gets DC power from the motherboard (not directly from the power supply). The motherboard DC source seems to VARY the fan speed considerably. Sometimes the fan runs so quietly, I have to visually check that it's running. Usually, however, the fan is very noisy.
How do I quantify how loud it is? Louder than the forced air conditioning system. Louder than a TV at normal volume in an adjacent room. Louder than the shower in a different adjacent room. Loud enough to be a constant distraction, especially because it's always speeding up and slowing down.
These wild swings in fan speed (and noise) occur even when the system is sitting idle (per Task Manager, the CPU usage is less than 4%; no applications are running.)
Dell replaced the fan four days ago. The new fan has the same symptoms.
Am I being too critical? Does this bother anyone else?
Bought a Dell XPS D233 in 1998. Still have it. No problems.
At work I service 231 Dell GX150s, running CPUs that clock over 1GHz. I'm impressed by these Dells because they're so quiet that I have to look at the power light to see if they're on, even when I have the cover open.
Problem:
Took delivery of a Dimension 4500 on 6/21/02. The NMB fan (item 9M060) that cools the Pentium 4 gets DC power from the motherboard (not directly from the power supply). The motherboard DC source seems to VARY the fan speed considerably. Sometimes the fan runs so quietly, I have to visually check that it's running. Usually, however, the fan is very noisy.
How do I quantify how loud it is? Louder than the forced air conditioning system. Louder than a TV at normal volume in an adjacent room. Louder than the shower in a different adjacent room. Loud enough to be a constant distraction, especially because it's always speeding up and slowing down.
These wild swings in fan speed (and noise) occur even when the system is sitting idle (per Task Manager, the CPU usage is less than 4%; no applications are running.)
Dell replaced the fan four days ago. The new fan has the same symptoms.
Am I being too critical? Does this bother anyone else?
Responses (22)
Solutions (0)
- I have a 4300. Dell has replaced the fan twice,since I got my system in December.
It still sounds just as bad really worse. Everything works so smoothly on the
computer though. The noise just drives you crazy. I do wish it could be fixed..
I really dont understand how to do anything inside the computer and reseat
cards and etc.
Sandra Davis
- Thanks for your reply, vinevessel.
You could easily be talking about my machine in your post. Your description fits my symptoms exactly.
The replacement fan was the same as the original: NMB item 9M060 model 3612KL-04W-B66, 12VDC 0.68A brushless fan motor. Lots of posts on this forum indicate a preference for NMB over Datech.
However, I don't think it's so much the fan as it is the variation in DC voltage coming from the motherboard. I'm trying to figure out if my real problem is a bad motherboard.
- Many other computer systems use a fan ON the heatsink, and the motherboard alters the speed of that based on temperature, due to the fact the MOTHERBOARD has a temperature sensor in it. Dells are different, they use passive cooling, no fan on the heatsink. The only cooling is the power supply fan and the case fan. These case fans have a temperature sensor IN them, and they are run off the motherboard power plug, just like other systems power the heatsink fan. So the reason the case fan speed changes is simple, it's in reply to the temperature changes as the loads on the system cause it to get hotter or cooler. Unlike you're running something that causes the cpu to run flat out all the time, the fan speed is going to change. Also for most Dells the intake is on the back bottom of the case. So if you've got your system in a confined area, like under a desk, or shoved against the wall so it's restricting the air flow, it's going to run hot and noisy. Check your air intakes on the back for lint, and around the buttons on your optical drives. Do you have dust bunnies in your place? They might have gotten in your case. Open your case and look. Get a can of air and blow the system out.
Dimension 4400
1.8 GHZ
768MB DDR
Western Digital WD1200JB / 120GB SE
Maxtor D740X / 80GB
NEC 5800 DVD ROM
GE 8160B CDRW
Geforce3 Ti200
Soundblaster 5.1
IBM P275 21" Monitor
Logitech Cordless Freedom Optical
Altech Lansing ATP# Speakers
Epson C40UX
APC LS 700VA
XP Home
Roxio Platinum
Zone Alarm Pro
AdSubtract Pro
Sandra 2002 Pro
Belarc Advisor
Adaware
Folding @ Home - Team 33 ardOCP - Well, I'm not sure how the DELLs designs are, but on my computer, the fan on the CPU is what appears to make the varying fan noises. Someone else said this, but I'll say it again, lol. My motherboard has a temp sensor near the CPU, so when it senses a higher temp coming from the CPU, the fan speed increases to cool it down. This speed varies according to the CPU temp. I usually notice an increase in fan speed (and slightly noiser sound) after or during play of a demanding game, like return to castle wolfie. My case and power fans also sometimes vary in speed, but its the CPU fan that changes alot
Well, thats my experience
-Silent Service Agent157
"Custom built PCs are the BEST. so beware all you companies who think you can rip ignorant people off. Its only a matter of time now..."
"Does anyone use CDRW discs anymore?" (so far one person has said yes)
"Do to your PC as you want done to you"
"Angelina"
ABIT TH7-2 RAID Soc478 Motherboard
Pentium4 1.7Ghz CPU @ 400Mhz FSB
1028MB RDRAM
80GB 7200rpm (8MB Buffer....better than 2) Western Digital Hard Drives on RAID0
80GB 7200rpm (8MB Buffer...yumyum) Western Digital Hard Drives on RAID0
21" SONY G520 Monitor
Visiontek Xtasy GeForce4 4600 TI 128MB DDR
SoundBlaster Audigy Platinum
Sigma Designs XCard (DVD Decoder....hardware is always better than software)
US Robotics V.92/56K Fax Modem
3COM Ethernet Card (RoadRunner kicksbutt)
ASUS 16x48x DVD-ROM ATA100 (ATA100 on a DVD drive? Believe it)
Plextor 16x/40x CDRW (Plextor's the best)
Logitech Internet Keyboard & Optical USB Mouse
Windows XP Pro OS - Wait a min...are you telling me there is physcially no fan on the heatsink itself? If that were so, the CPU woulda melted after a while...a heatsink alone can't save the cpu from overheating and power/case fans only cause air to go in thru one and out thru the other. The CPU produces its own heat...and alot too. I'm sure there has to be a fan on the heatsink....on top, left or right, but on it.
I heard my fan on my heatsink around its max spin speed, which is like 4k...and but its no where to the noise described from the other users :-/
-Silent Service Agent157
"Custom built PCs are the BEST. so beware all you companies who think you can rip ignorant people off. Its only a matter of time now..."
"Does anyone use CDRW discs anymore?" (so far one person has said yes)
"Do to your PC as you want done to you"
"Angelina"
ABIT TH7-2 RAID Soc478 Motherboard
Pentium4 1.7Ghz CPU @ 400Mhz FSB
1028MB RDRAM
80GB 7200rpm (8MB Buffer....better than 2) Western Digital Hard Drives on RAID0
80GB 7200rpm (8MB Buffer...yumyum) Western Digital Hard Drives on RAID0
21" SONY G520 Monitor
Visiontek Xtasy GeForce4 4600 TI 128MB DDR
SoundBlaster Audigy Platinum
Sigma Designs XCard (DVD Decoder....hardware is always better than software)
US Robotics V.92/56K Fax Modem
3COM Ethernet Card (RoadRunner kicksbutt)
ASUS 16x48x DVD-ROM ATA100 (ATA100 on a DVD drive? Believe it)
Plextor 16x/40x CDRW (Plextor's the best)
Logitech Internet Keyboard & Optical USB Mouse
Windows XP Pro OS - Dimension 8200. Same problem. It'll run at a pretty good pace with a 3D intensive screen-saver, but when I click on the keyboard to turn off the screen saver, the system winds up like a 5 speed transmission going from 4th to 2nd. After a while, it dies down. I would've figured it would do the opposite, going from the screensaver to just the desktop. Who knows. The computer runs great though.
Should've said that. My 30 day return perios ends tomorrow!!
~Wild Bill~
System 1
Dimension 8200
P4 2.53Ghz, 512 Megs RDRAM, XP Home, Office XP Pro
19 Inch Flat Panel LCD (Dell 1902FP)
80 Gig Western Digital HDD WD80 0BB-75CA00
SIIG Ultra ATA 133 PCI controller card(running HDD)
GeForce4 Ti4600 128 Meg Video(Driver 3.0.8.2)
LiteOn 16x LTD163 DVD (Secondary IDE)
TDK VeloCD 40x12x48 CDRW (Primary IDE)
Nero 5.5.9.6 / InCD
SB! Live 1024
HK-695 Speakers
Intel Pro 10/100 w/ Motorolla Cable Modem
Multimedia Keyboard(PS2)
Logitech Optical USB Mouse
Norton SytemWorks 2002, Personal Firewall, Ghost
Powerquest Partition Magic 7.0, Drive Image 2002
HP 1115 Photosmart Printer
System 2
Inspiron 5000e
PIII 750Mhz
384 Megs PC100 SDRAM
15" UXGA
8x DVD(Toshiba) 8x4x4 CDRW (Matsushita)
Windows 98SE, Office Pro
Nero 5.5.8.2
Roxio Direct CD
Norton System Works
20 Gig 4200 RPM HD(HITACHI)(Slow & Noisy)
16 Meg ATI Rage Mobility
Xircom RealPort 56k/ 10/100 Ethernet
Roadrunner Cable w/Motorolla Modem - Yes that's exactly what I'm telling you. It shows you don't really know Dells. Look HERE at the 8200 HERE at the 4400 and HERE at the 4500. On some of the older systems Dell used a fan on the heatsink. But on none of the newer ones. CLICK HERE to look at all the system guides. And no if you can do a good enough job with passive cooling, as Dell has done, you DON'T need a fan on the heatsink. Since you can't overclock a Dell it can't get that hot.
Dimension 4400
1.8 GHZ
768MB DDR
Western Digital WD1200JB / 120GB SE
Maxtor D740X / 80GB
NEC 5800 DVD ROM
GE 8160B CDRW
Geforce3 Ti200
Soundblaster 5.1
IBM P275 21" Monitor
Logitech Cordless Freedom Optical
Altech Lansing ATP# Speakers
Epson C40UX
APC LS 700VA
XP Home
Roxio Platinum
Zone Alarm Pro
AdSubtract Pro
Sandra 2002 Pro
Belarc Advisor
Adaware
Folding @ Home - Team 33 ardOCP EddieFlorea
34 Posts
466
0
Posted August 18th, 2002 10:00
Silent157 wrote:
- "Does anyone use CDRW discs anymore?" (so far one
- person has said yes)
Since you ask this question all the time! YES...Thousands! A lot of us use CDRW Disks. All of my wife's and my brothers and sisters and their kids use them too. Mostly to burn songs for their cars CD Players. The kids use them in their Walkman's. I use Bearshare.com to download songs and burn. So, Add another 25 to that list for my family and another 10,000 who thinks your question is silly. Why do you think they offer CD-RW Drives with every system!
400Mhz processors are obsolete - Everybody is phasing them out! The 533Mhz rules! Q3 of 2003 Pentium introduces the 667Mhz.
Dimension 8200 2.53Ghz 533Mhz
1024MB Samsung PC800 RDRAM 40Ns
120GB Western Digital Ultra ATA 100 Hard Drive w/8MB Cache
128MB Nvidia GeForce 4 Ti4600 Graphics Card
Turtle Beach/Santa Cruz Sound Card
Altec Lansing THX Certified 5.1 Dolby Digital 6 Speaker Surround Sound
16X DVD-Rom Drive
24X/10X/40X CD-RW Drive
Sony FD Trinitron 21in Flat Screen Monitor
Microsoft Intellimouse Explorer
Norton Symantec System Works
HP OfficeJet K80 printer, scanner, copier and fax
DSL ( Faster than cable ) the only way to surf
Win XP Home
Wife's system:
Gateway 700XL Pentium 4 2.53Ghz 533Mhz
1024MB PC800 RDRAM 40Ns
120Gb Western Digital Hard Drive w/8MB Cache
128MB Nvidia GeForce 4 Ti4600 Graphics Card
DVD-R Drive and 48X/24X/48X CD-RW
Soundblaster Audigy w/IEEEE 1394 ( firewall ) - ( Turtle Beach/Santa Cruz Sound Card sounds better )
Boston Acoustics BA7800 5.1 Dolby Digital Sub/Satellite System
18in LCD Flat Panel Analog/Digital Monitor
Microsoft Intellimouse Explorer
Win XP Pro
HP OfficeJet K80 printer, scanner, copier and fax
DSL - The Best connection
Message Edited on 08/18/02 09:04AM by EddieFlorea- Hi qdemn7,
Thanks so very much for your post!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I've been looking for precisely the information you posted. I've read the technical documentation you reference in a later post, but I failed to discover that "These case fans have a temperature sensor IN them," and that "the reason the case fan speed changes is simple, it's in reply to the temperature changes as the loads on the system cause it to get hotter or cooler."
I've double and triple checked the air flow. Everything is clean and unrestricted.
With the case open, the fan slows down until it becomes silent when I lift the green shroud directing air flow over the Pentium 4's heat sink. The fan immediately speeds back up to its noisy self when I return the shroud to its normal position. During this time, no applications are running, only the OS (Windows XP).
Thank you again, for your explanation of why the fan speeds up. But I'd like to ask you: does your 4400 exhibit the kind of noise I talked about in my original post? I.e., does the fan in your machine get loud? Does it get distinctly louder than other ambient noise in the room? And does it basically stay that way all day? (Mine does).
If the fan in your 4400 gets loud enough to hear over other ambient noise, does it bother you? (I don't want to be just another crank. I'd like to know if I was in good company or bad company.)
Thanks again for your time, your expertise, and your generous assistance!!!!
Regards,
Mac

Vinevessel
86 Posts
466
0
Posted August 18th, 2002 00:00
Hello,
I own a Dimension 8200 and get the same Symptoms as you.
Bought here in Australia, 20 / 12 / 2001 and I already faced it since then.
Did the replacement Fan still has the same Brand? If you are in USA, try to ask for another Brand Replacement.
In Australia, all the Dell Systems are made in Malaysia out from their Asia-Pacific Factory and, unfortunately, they just didn't understand what I mean a problem with the Fan, so I couldn't ask for a Replacement.
I spent a couple hours try to describe, but ended up nothing. But, I think it is the behavior of the Fan, which has sort of dynamic Speed adjustment according to the CPU Activity, but, my Experiences is that, with mine, once it is louder (caused with large CPU Utilization), then it won't back to when the first time I turned it on (very2 Quiet).
Sometimes also it will increasing / decreasing according to the Utilization. With mine, when opening Power Hungry Application, the pitch will decrease, and after that, will gradually increasing. It will sounds like Motor Boat in the worst case.
Btw, mine is Datech Brand.
Thanks.
-----------------------------------------------------
Ivan Adrianto,
Melbourne, Australia
http://www.vinevessel.com
-----------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------