
UNSOLVED
D
daniel2094
2 Posts
0
7418
September 24th, 2004 20:00
Ati X300 SE vs. X800 SE
Hello, I have some questions containing the dimension 8400.
I want to buy a Dim Superior, and it should be a silent pc.
I'm not sure, if the X300se is powerfull enough to play a full HDTV wmv.
And I do play sometimes a game, but I'm not a gamer.
1. Produces the 3.2GHz P4 more noise than the 2.8GHz P4?
2. The X800 SE has an active fan. Can I hear them? What about power consumption?
3. Are there any Specs about noise? ( db(a), sone )
thanks a lot
Message Edited by daniel2094 on 09-24-2004 04:16 PM
Responses (2)
Solutions (0)
Fred-from-NYC
11 Posts
76
0
Posted September 26th, 2004 04:00
daniel2094, I have the Dimension 8400 with a 3.2 GHz Pentium 4 processor and X300 SE video card. I am not sure what exactly you are referring to when you speak of HDTV WMV. If you mean WMV HD files like the ones at the WMV HD Content Showcase from Microsoft (http://www.microsoft.com/windows/windowsmedia/content_provider/film/ContentShowcase.aspx) then you won't have any problems with the configuration I described. I have downloaded several of the 1080p video files and they play beautifully on my computer.
This computer is also fine for playing games. I have tried America's Army at 1280x1024 and it looks great at the default video settings. If you go to ultra high quality the frame rate drops and I doubt that this computer could handle Doom 3 or Far Cry, but from what you wrote I don't think this poses a problem for you.
Regarding noise, the computer is not completely silent but it is much more quiet than I had expected. I was very concerned about noise but now I have the computer sitting on the floor next to my desk and I can hear the fan, but it doesn't bother me at all. However, compared to my notebook computer the fan in the Dimension 8400 is more noticeable.
Conclusion: get the 8400 with the X300 SE and spend the money you saved on a RAM upgrade. I have 1 GB RAM and I think this is a better investment than a more expensive video card. If you feel that the X300 SE no longer fulfills your needs you can upgrade to a better video card in the future, when prices for PCI Express cards have come down.

The_Man42
415 Posts
76
0
Posted September 25th, 2004 20:00
The new dimensions are relatively silent, the P4 560(3.6Ghz) I have makes very little noise, and even when the fine kicks into high, it's still not really loud at all. The X800XT I have I rarely ever hear, only when it's fan goes to higher RPM in graphics intensive games and even so, it isn't loud.
You do NOT want the X300SE, it will not cut it for even WMV HD, you want the X800SE, it is an okay card, and it will play HD fine
If the GTO is available and you can afford to spend the extra $$, go with it, it is better thant he X800SE.