UNSOLVED

w0okie

updated

16 years ago

W

w0okie

27 Posts

0

51714

May 3rd, 2011 00:00

Will a 525W PSU work with GTX 580 + i7 2600k ?

Dell is sending me a replacement system for my R3 because of the freezing issue. My original system has a 875W PSU with the 6870 CFX. My PSU is downgraded to 525W from the 875W PSU.

I asked tech support if the 525W is going to be enough for my replacement system but he said that it will be fine. I would like a second opinion on this because the PSU calculators that I have used all say that I need a ~650 or greater power supply. I really want to make sure the replacement system will not have any problems so I need to make sure this won't have problems.

 

Here is the replacement configuration:

1 225-0598 Alienware Aurora-R3 $609.99
1 313-8750 AlienFX Color, Quasar Blue $0.00
1 313-9776 Integrated 7.1 Channel Audio, INFO, CDT $0.00
1 317-3898 CPU Liquid Cooling $0.00
1 317-5737 16GB Dual Channel DDR3 at 1333MHz,AVDT $520.00
1 317-6022 Intel Core i7-2600K OTB 3.9GHz $450.00
1 318-0241 Single Drive: 24X DVD $0.00
1 318-0247 Matte Stealth Black, 525W Aurora $0.00
1 320-2088 1.5GB GDDR5 NVIDIA GeForce GTX 580 $600.00
1 320-7810 NO MONITOR $0.00
1 330-6074 Alienware MM Keyboard,AWDT $0.00
1 330-6082 Alienware Optical Mouse, MG100 $0.00
1 330-6350 AUTO-UPDATES,CRIT,AW $0.00
1 331-0885 DELL RESOURCE DVD,BACK-UP,SWIFT $0.00
1 331-1441 Accessory Kit, Aurora, Can, AVDT $0.00
1 342-1946 1TB SATA 3Gb/s,7200RPM $100.00
1 410-1867 ADOBE READER 9.0,MLANG,I/S/X DT $0.00
1 410-2448 MCAFEE SECURITY,15MONTH,KIT,AWDT $49.00
1 420-6436 PC-RESTORE, DIM/INSP $0.00
1 420-9691 DATASAFE LOCAL BACKUP $0.00
1 421-0975 NERO 9,ANWDT $0.00
1 421-1424 Alienhead 3D $0.00
1 421-2064 WIN 7 HOME PREM, 64, ENG,AW CDT $30.00
  • Tesla1856

    10 Wizard

    •

    18086 Posts

    •

    71947 Points

    736

    0

    Posted May 3rd, 2011 00:00

    It might work, but why risk it?

    http://www.legitreviews.com/article/1461/17/

    It takes like 15 minutes to swap it out (it uses the same wiring harness), and Dell's cost difference is surely less than $50.

    With only 525w max output, that little PS is going to be running near 80-90% all the time ... not good.

    Dell Rockstar

    Microsoft Windows and Apple iOS Developer (Retired)
    - Like many of you, I can appreciate a good game-engine.
    - I answer questions here, but I'm not a Dell employee.
    - Consider giving posts you like a "thumbs-up"
    - Posting models-numbers and software versions speeds trouble-shooting.
    - Click "Mark as Accepted Answer" on any post that answers your question best.

  • MaDMaX68

    1 Rookie

    •

    46 Posts

    736

    0

    Posted May 3rd, 2011 00:00

    as far as i know dell psu's are underated so it should be fine but you will not be able to SLI/CF with it, apparently the 2nd set of PCIE connecters are blanks as in not really connected with the 525w psu

     

    anyone feel free to jump in on the enough power part thou

  • w0okie

    27 Posts

    736

    0

    Posted May 3rd, 2011 03:00

    Well, they ordered the replacement without telling me what the specs are going to be.

    How do I convince them to get me a 875W PSU ? It was like talking to a brick wall when I was asking to give me my old 875W PSU.

  • MaDMaX68

    1 Rookie

    •

    46 Posts

    736

    0

    Posted May 3rd, 2011 04:00

    Im confused surely when you originally purchased your R3 it came with the 875W psu, when i configured mine i had to pay extra, but irrespective!

     

    how can they change from what you orginally had!  thats like buying a ferrari and getting a mini cooper as a replacement, has to be wrong[:@

     

     

  • C_ronic

    431 Posts

    777

    0

    Posted May 3rd, 2011 06:00

    I wouldnt take it. Most likely a refurbished unit. They are probably giving him the refurb parts they had available at the time. Keep in mind this is just speculation. My PC arrived broken and they said they would send me a replacement "new" unit. It was refurbished. They come in the EXACT same packaging with all the extras and bells and whistles. I sent it back. They are very tricky and from how it sounds it seems like you might get one too. SO I advise you to inspect it very closely upon arrival. I feel like you dont deserve a refurb just like I didnt because we never had a working unit to begin with. I am not 100% but they did it to me so I am hoping it doesnt happen to you either.

  • m3th0d1c4l

    265 Posts

    777

    0

    Posted May 3rd, 2011 07:00

    Actually that looks like a brand new unit to me. If the order has the 7 digit part numbers in the format xxx-xxxx, its a new unit. A refurb unit will have a 5 digit part number consisting of numbers and letters, for example, DW5CW.

    Plus Aurora R3's are not even available in the outlet yet, so I highly doubt its a refurb.

    In any case, when the new unit arrives, just pull the 875W PSU out of the old unit and swap them out and send it back with thr 525W PSU, since they are downgrading your PSU. Its an easy swap.

  • C_ronic

    431 Posts

    777

    0

    Posted May 3rd, 2011 08:00

    Thats weird because my replacement info looked identical. I dont REMEMBER any differences in format from the original list. They told me it was "new" too. So I would not be so sure. Where did you find this info? Maybe outlet units use a 5 digit part number and not necessarily a replacement. Also from what I read on this forum people who knowingly purchased refurbished units didnt get a lot of the extras or the fancy box. So there has to be a difference in the outlet refurbs and the replacement refurbs in the write up. Either way im not saying it will be refurbished. Its just they also told me mine would be new so I think he should as least look very closely when it arrives.

  • m3th0d1c4l

    265 Posts

    777

    0

    Posted May 3rd, 2011 09:00

    From my experience, anytime I had an order list that looked like that, it was a brand new system. Especially given that the Aurora R3 just came out, they probably don't have refurb systems available to purchase or send out yet. They are probably testing all those returned and refurb'd units as to why they had problems on a brand new machine.

    I am 99.9% sure its new.

  • w0okie

    27 Posts

    306

    0

    Posted May 3rd, 2011 12:00

    Well I received a call from Dell just now and they apologized for all my troubles and provided some solutions. I am extremely satisfied now.

  • w0okie

    27 Posts

    777

    0

    Posted May 3rd, 2011 12:00

    Are you allowed to swap out the PSU like that ?