XPS 8930, booting from wrong drive after accessing safe mode
Windows booting from wrong drive
XPS 8930. Background is that last December I uninstalled Optane and installed an nvme drive that was a clone of the hard drive. I followed a video on youtube and everything had been fine up to this point. Past couple of days boot times decreased drastically so I decided to do some troubleshooting. Went in to safe mode using msconfig to see if it booted faster and it did but when I returned out of safe mode the pc booted from the original HDD (which still had functional WIndows on it) and not the cloned nvme and I now have no clue how to get it back.
Disk 0 is the cloned nvme which I have been running windows off until I messed something up in msconfig (?)
Disk 2 is the original hdd that has now been reset to the C boot drive
I disconnected everything except the nvme drive and tried to boot. Got errors about missing necessary drives and winload.efi being missing or containing errors. So I followed a post about winload.efi involving using a windows boot usb to access the command prompt and then using bcdboot (won't post exact details as I am not a tech person and more or less did that blindly, so would not post here in case someone copies me and does it wrong and causes unfixable harm; sure google can find instructions but I am not recommending to do that unless someone more knowledgeable walks you through it)
First boot after doing that I got same error, and then I shut it down. For whatever bizarre reason the next time I booted it worked. But now booting with just the nvme connected I get a message about choosing an operating system
Windows 10 on volume 6
or
Windows 10
the second windows 10 has nothing about volumes written on it. At this point I would request some support from anyone who can help me figure out
-why going into safe mode messed up my boot drives and how to fix it so it doesnt happen again
-how to get rid of the which windows to boot option
-can I just install windows 10 fresh or does being a dell machine which had optane somehow mess with it
-if I format the HDD that still has the windows partition to remove it will that be problematic
Also on a sidenote I discovered the post about realtek drivers affecting boot times, went into device manager > sound video and game controllers => right click realtek audio and selected 'rollback driver' my boot times returned to previous speed.
Connected up all drives nvme with windows and hdd with windows. boot time resolved with realtek driver rollback but now I get offered two windows options: on volume 14 or volume 5
if anyone can shed some light on what I did re safe mode to cause my boot drives to switch it would be much appreciated.
@asap79 Are you sure you ever booted from Disk 0 (NVMe SSD)? You indicated boot times deceased drastically even before you tried Safe Mode. What you should have done in the beginning was to disconnect the HDD after cloning was completed before booting from the SSD. If you don't disconnect the HDD, you have two bootable drives, so then you should have booted using the F12 Boot Menu and then selected the SSD as the boot drive. I assume you really don't want two bootable drives, that you want to boot from the SSD, so you should boot your system using the F12 Boot Menu, select booting from the SSD, backup the data that you want to save on the HDD, and then reinitialize the HDD to use as additional storage. The procedure to reinitialize the HDD using DiskPart is here: https://macrorit.com/partition-magic-manager/initialize-disk-gpt-mbr-from-cmd-diskpart.html
Be cafeful, make sure you use to 'list disk' command to identify the SSD, and the 'select disk' command to select the disk you want to reinitialize.
I'm 100% certain I was using the nvme since I did the cloning and booting last December as I did as you suggested at the time, and booted from the nvme with everything else disconnected. Also when the switch happened today after I rebooted from safe mode there were no new bookmarks in Firefox since the transfer date December 2020, no new events in Event Viewer since said transfer date, and a bunch of stuff I'd installed since the transfer from hdd to nvme had disappeared. Also after the safe mode switch changed the windows boot drive back to the HDD the desktop displayed that 'loading desktop icons' behaviour where desktop shortcuts 'pop in' after boot that I hadn't experienced since installing the nvme.
The only reason I kept the windows hdd intact instead of reformatting was I figured it would save me hassle if the nvme died prematurely. I was planning on wiping it once the nvme was 1 years old (give or take)
Can you help me understand what happened to cause the switch in boot order? Occasionally when doing amateur troubleshooting I have to access safe mode and I'd really like to do so without worrying about my boot order getting broken.
Also my google skills are lacking. Do you happen to know a way that I could clone/image only certain parts of the boot drive to boot from if the boot drive fails? So on my boot drive all I really want cloned/imaged is the 100gb give or take of Windows and key programs, and not the other storage that is games etc that can be easily reinstalled. Basically I'd want to have a bootable clone/image of the boot drive on a 100GB partition of another drive, so if the boot drive fails then I can just boot from the cloned partition on the backup drive. Is that a doable concept?
Use Macrium Reflect (free) or similar imaging software to clone allpartitions the boot drive and save that image on an external USB drive. All the "other" stuff you said you don't need is in the same partition on that drive, so you can't (easily) pick and choose what to back up.
And if I'm reading your disk management screen correctly, it looks like your 500GB SSD is assigned drive letter G: while the 1T HDD is assigned drive letter C:. So it's probably not surprising the PC is booting from the HDD.
Back up (image) both drives first on external media to be safe. If you use Macrium Reflect, be sure to set the compression to MAX so you need less space on the external drive to store each image and be sure to set Macrium to validate each image right after it's made.
Then use disk Management to change the drive letter of the HDD to something down the alphabet (eg, M:), a letter that Windows won't normally need. Now change the drive letter for the SSD to C:, reboot and confirm the PC boots from the SSD again.
Assuming it boots from the SSD, use disk management to change the drive letter for the HDD to D, or perhaps just leave it with whatever drive letter you assigned to it, above. Reboot again and confirm PC still boots from the SSD.
@asap79 Keeping the Windows HDD intact is not the best approach. Windows updates and other software updates in addition to your own user created content would make the version on the HDD old pretty fast. A better approach is to do as @RoHe suggests and use Macrium Reflect Free Edition to create an image of your SSD that is stored on removeable media like a large backup USB drive. Then using Macrium Reflect ability to create Rescue Media you can restore the image to your SSD in the event you need to. Just be sure to update your backup image periodically so that you have a recent copy. I would reinitialize the HDD to use as additional storage; you can then put the backup image on the HDD.
Appears to be running okay again. Wiped the HDD that had the 'original' Windows installation still on it, did multiple boots with just the nvme connected, and multiple safe mode boots just to be sure nothing weird happened again.
"it looks like your 500GB SSD is assigned drive letter G: while the 1T HDD is assigned drive letter C:. So it's probably not surprising the PC is booting from the HDD."
That's the 'switch' that happened after I was in safe mode. The original Dell config was the 1TB HDD plus Optane 16gb. I cloned that HDD to the NVME and added a sata SSD which before the 'safe mode glitch' was C=nvme, F=HDD, G=sata ssd. The reason I posted here for help was because I was concerned there was some hidden Dell info that had gotten left behind in the cloning process telling the machine to boot specifically from the exact HDD it shipped with; which had somehow been triggered by me ticking some box or changing some setting in msconfig by accident.
While I have your Dell expertise, does changing the configuration from HDD+optane to nvme mean the Dell recovery options will no longer work because they 'expect' the HDD+Optane config?
I was thinking of doing a clean Windows install but the Dell instructions involve giving a service tag in the OS Recovery Tool. Would this mean it would expect the original optane configuration based on the sevice tag, potentially causing an issue? Can I just clean install using Microsoft
In relation to the above I did not update the bios around the whole spectre thing as a bad experience in bricking a machine has left me wary of bios updates (google suggests neither exploits have been seen online practically). But if I reinstall WIndows will all the drivers I would need to install from Dell only be compatible with the latest bios?
Did you disable the Optane cache before you installed the NVME SSD? Otherwise, it shouldn't be able to boot from the HDD with the Optane replaced by an SSD.
You can use the Microsoft ISO file to create a bootable USB for a clean install. It's probably more up-to-date than the Dell OS Recovery image.
Drivers should be independent of BIOS version. And it's likely Win 10 will install all the ones you need. If something isn't working correctly, you can install Dell's version of that driver. CAVEAT: Windows Update and Dell are both offering a new Realtek+Waves MaxxAudio driver for the XPS 8930 that's a dud, so be careful about that one, regardless of where you get it.
You can update BIOS directly using the Flash Update option on the F12 boot menu with the BIOS .exe file on a non-bootable USB stick. IMO, don't update BIOS either manually inside Win 10, via SupportAssist in Win 10 or via Windows Update. WU is pushing the newest XPS 8930 BIOS but numbers it as "0.1.1.18" while Dell calls it "1.1.18", without the lead zero.
Worse, WU thinks 0.1.1.18 is a new version even though my XPS 8930 already got 1.1.18 installed via the F12 menu and the file on Dell's support page. So WU keeps offering it to me...
Did you disable the Optane cache before you installed the NVME SSD? Otherwise, it shouldn't be able to boot from the HDD with the Optane replaced by an SSD.
Yes. I followed a guide on Youtube which directed me to use the Intel Rapid Storage Technology application to 'decouple' the Optane from the HDD before removing it. Coincidentally I was checking to remind myself what steps I took to swap the optane out, which led me to checking IRST application to see the boot nvme was missing from the status list, and that led me to your post in this thread
saying IRST is not necessary when Optane is removed. I still have IRST application in my taskbar so should I uninstall it, or just leave well enough alone?
The dud Realtek driver is what led to my predicament as I was booting into safe mode to see if it booted faster, after which my drive letters got swapped around.
Thanks for the info on drivers/clean install and the BIOS update. I bookmarked this page if I ever summon the courage to change the BIOS
Thanks again for the help here and all the other posts you've made on this forum that I've made use of as a lurker. You're one of the good ones :thumbsup:
Sorry to hear you fell victim to that bum Realtek driver. It's up to the Dell platform team if this driver is pulled and/or a link to the prior version is posted. Meanwhile, you'll just have to live with the slow booting if you want to use audio. Or, as some did in that other thread, install the Microsoft driver. But Waves MaxxAudio probably won't be available with that driver.
FWIW, I don't use SupportAssist or Dell Update. I always download new drivers and BIOS updates manually and save the .exe installer files in a folder on my D(ata) drive. So if I ever need to reinstall one of them, I already have a fresh copy and don't have to worry that the link on the Support page might disappear...
asap79
12 Posts
1537
0
Posted October 16th, 2021 15:00
To update
I disconnected everything except the nvme drive and tried to boot. Got errors about missing necessary drives and winload.efi being missing or containing errors. So I followed a post about winload.efi involving using a windows boot usb to access the command prompt and then using bcdboot (won't post exact details as I am not a tech person and more or less did that blindly, so would not post here in case someone copies me and does it wrong and causes unfixable harm; sure google can find instructions but I am not recommending to do that unless someone more knowledgeable walks you through it)
First boot after doing that I got same error, and then I shut it down. For whatever bizarre reason the next time I booted it worked. But now booting with just the nvme connected I get a message about choosing an operating system
Windows 10 on volume 6
or
Windows 10
the second windows 10 has nothing about volumes written on it. At this point I would request some support from anyone who can help me figure out
-why going into safe mode messed up my boot drives and how to fix it so it doesnt happen again
-how to get rid of the which windows to boot option
-can I just install windows 10 fresh or does being a dell machine which had optane somehow mess with it
-if I format the HDD that still has the windows partition to remove it will that be problematic
Also on a sidenote I discovered the post about realtek drivers affecting boot times, went into device manager > sound video and game controllers => right click realtek audio and selected 'rollback driver' my boot times returned to previous speed.
Thanks for any future help