How I am upgrading my Dell 4600c MCE2004 to Media Center Edition 2005
I recently purchased a Media Center Extender device, and it requires Media Centre 2005 on the PC, hence my determination to get MCE 2005 installed.
I work for MS so I managed to get the actual MCE2005 bits, but I think most folks can get the OEM bits from various retailers on the net (you have to purchase some hardware with it, so get a new USB cable)
I installed the software and all went smoothly. You can either boot off the CD (and do a fresh new install), or boot into MCE2004 and insert the first cd and let it autorun. This will take you into a GUI setup mode and you can do an upgrade over your existing MCE2004 without loosing all your data. I did the upgrade - it went smoothly. All you have to remember is that when it asks for Windows XP Service Pack 2 disk 1, you really have to put in the first disk of the MCE2005 software!
Here’s the problem: The 64MB ATI ALL-IN-WONDER 9000 "low profile" card that came with the Dell 4600C uses software Encoding. What I heard is that since that card is no longer used by OEMs, ATI is no longer developing drivers for it. As a result, no MCE2005 compatible drivers really exist for it. So, when you start MCE2005, you will get an error message: "Your video card or drivers are not compatible with MediaCenter". I have tried many variants of the ATI drivers but nothing seems to work.
I think my solution is to replace the original ATI AIW 9000 video card. However, there are two problems I am running up against when considering replacing the ATI AIW 9000 low profile card, and here is my plan to solve them.
The AIW 9000 card that came with these machines is a combined tuner and video card. Firstly I will need to find a MCE2005 supported card that is a low profile card to fit into the Dell 4600C chassis. Secondly, as the 4600C is a very compact chassis, there are no open slots for additional cards (hence Dell used the dual purpose ATI AIW 9000). This means I will not have the luxury of installing seperate TV tunder and Video cards. I will need to find another dual purpose card, or simply find a low profile video card and then use a cable box or external tuner for the TV tuning. I do not think this is a problem as I was planning to use a cable box anyway (originally my MCE2004 was connected to basic cable only). I will need to figure out how to connect my cable box to the MCE2005 machine and get the channel switching link working. I am sure this is a simple process - I think I remember getting some cables and an infrared linking device when I got the machine originally.
So, this is my plan. Does anyone know of a low profile MCE2005 supported video card? I’ll buy the card and let you now if I get things going.
I too have a recently-purchased 4600c, and I have also been researching what it would take to upgrade to MCE2005. I've not been able to find any low-profile tuner/video combo cards like the AiW9000. I have found at least 2 low-profile video-only cards that ought to work, but don't take my opinion as the final word. One is the ATI-based Powercolor 9600SE. There are also nVIDIA-based low profile cards such as the Jaton FX5700LE. You can find them both on newegg.com.
The nVIDIA looks better to me for several reasons. First, although I have usually bought ATI in the past, I have read many stories lately about buggy ATI drivers, at least as related to MCE2005 issues. Second, the 9600SE only supports DVI and S-video in its low-profile configuration, not VGA, unless you can fabricate a second low-profile backplate and tie up an otherwise unused slot with it. However, the FX5700LS comes with a second low-profile backplate for the VGA connector. The 4600c fills its only PCI slot with a modem card, which in my case is not needed, so that slot would be available for the second video backplate. If you are planning to use DVI as your video output, then this is not an issue.
Newegg.com lists several PCI-based tuner cards that look like they would fit in a low-profile chassis, but few if any look like they come with a low-profile backplate, and none of them state specifically that they work with MCE2005. Of course, if the 4600c's only PCI slot is dedicated to a tuner, the VGA video output option is lost, so an outboard tuner may be the only viable alternative. As an employee ot MS, do you have access to a list of hardware that has been tested or validated to work with MCE2005? That would sure be a help!
Here are some helpful websites that may provide additional info about MCE2005-related issues.
I am having some luck with the AIW 9000 using the omega drivers. This gets it into media center. There are those who say that they have the tuner also working, but so far that is not happening for me. I am going to try the original oem wdm drivers tonight, this may help.
My other option is this:
I can disable the tuner part of the AIW 9000 in device mgr and just use it as a video card. This is working for me just fine, everything beside live tv is working on the 9000 with the omega drivers. Then there are a few options for tuners and in one case dual tuners.
Use the AIW for video, or get a low profile card of your choice. Then check out the new WinTV-USB PVR 2 http://www.hauppauge.com/pages/products/data_pvrusb2.html for the external solution. This works with MCE 2005 and you can use two of them for dual tuner support if you like.
If you have a slot free and need low profile, use the WinTV- PVR 150 MCE Low Profile card. I can't find the page for the low profile version of the card, but it is announced and I believe available. Here is the press release for all the WinTV MCE 2005 cards. http://www.hauppauge.com/pdfs/pr_mediacenter2005.pdf
Ok, so I took your advice and diabled the TV tuner, installed the Omega drivers. Now when MCE2005 starts I do not get the error message, and the video playback works, but with sound only - screen is black. Everything else works apprat from the live TV (as the TV tuner has been disabled). I feel I am getting close to getting this all working. If I could get the video playback working, I will purchase the USB TV tuner and I will be all set to go.
Now, how do I get the video image to also play, not just the sound?
Hmm.. That did not happen to me. Can you get video when MCE is shrunk down to a window instead of full screen? Also, did you uninstall the ATI control pannel app before the driver change? I am still trying to get the tuner to work. So far no luck, but there are people who have the 9000 tuner working as well. I will probably give up and use it for my video card and get a PVR 150 because from what I understand, even if you get the tuner going, you won't be able to add a second because the first one is software encoded, and performance suffers. When I did the Omega, I just uninstalled the Control Pannel app (Not the drivers) and then let the installation program do the upgrade.
Ok, this is wierd. I can play AVI and WMV files in media player (outside of MCE2005) no problem. Within MCE I can only play WMV files, NOT AVI. Most of my home videos have been captured as AVI files. I used to be able to play them in MCE 2004. I get the sound, but no video.
Any ideas? Last time I did remove all ATI software before I installed the Omega drivers, but I'll do i again to see if t works. If I get this going I will purchase two USB tuners and have a cool system. I cannto wait.
You need to check out the xpmce forum. Someone there has the video drivers you will need for download. You will also need a new dvd decoder. nvdvd 4.00.20 is the one you want to get. Here are some details:
I read through all of that, and I feel pretty confident in the upgrade. It is complex, but I think it will work. It has for others with our ATI card. I also think that Dell will release an update at some point so you might just want to wait. Here are some good posts along with exact details from a guy who has our computer. He did a fresh install with MCE 2005 full version, I believe. I am going to try to just do an upgrade first.
Basic Order Of operations:
1) Format C: 2) Install Windows XP Media Center Edition 2005 3) Reboot 4) Run Windows update 5) Reboot 6) Install official ATI MCE graphics driver and control panel (which leaves six or so devices in the device manager as being "unknown".) 7) Reboot 8) Install Kram's wonderful 4.10 modded drivers 9) Reboot 10) Go into device manager and for every "unknown" device, i go into the properties and click on "Reinstall driver". 11) When it says it found a driver but it is older than the one I am currently using, would I like to overwrite the new driver with the old one, I click on yes. I do this for all the "unknown" devices. 12) Reboot
13a) Install DVD decoder software
13) Open Media Center 14) Run Media Center TV wizard 15) Let it automatically detect the tuners 16) Watch live Tv
Here is another quote....
I finally got it working after a little fiddling... the modded 4.10s (video driver) installed (the ones from ATI wouldn't even start to install.) I then tried to run media center and didn't get the compatible error. But, when I tried to view TV, it said that I didn't have a tv tuner installed. I went and checked and device manager said I had one. So I went into the MCE folder from the extracted 4.10s zip and ran the setup.exe in there. I chose "repair" and once that was done, MCE saw my tv tuner... and everything works great. I'm using the 4.00.20 nvdvd decoder and kram's 4.10s with my dell 4600c media pc.
Here is another quote....
First, I did a fresh install of MCE.
I then put in the Dell CD and installed all of the drivers for unrecognized hardware except for the video.
Then I installed Kram's modified 4.10s.
THen I installed nvdvd 4.00.20 as my dvd decoder(i think that's the version.)
After that, I didn't get the error message when I tried to start MCE. Before, I would get a message saying that my video card wasn't compatible.
After that, I got into MC fine, but when I tried to go to TV, it said I didn't have a TV tuner card installed.
So I went through device manager and "updated" the driver for each of the tv tuner related devices. It found everything automatically. It just seemed to "re-install" them. After that, I ran MC and was able to watch TV and everything.
I'm not sure if this helps you or not, but let me know what happens.
Ok, I did this and have run into trouble. The machine boots ok, but as soon as MCE starts it bluescreens. I am not sure if these drivers ar efor the low prifile card or simply the ATI AIW 9000 standard and pro. To compund the issues - I recently set MCE2005 to start when the OS boots, so now I have to figure out how to stop MCE form loading so I can remove the drivers and re-install the original ones to get my system stable. I am not sure I followed the exact steps you mention above, so when I get teh time this weekend I might re-do the installation you refer to above. So far it's not lookgin good.
Ok, I did this and have run into trouble. The machine boots ok, but as soon as MCE starts it bluescreens. I am not sure if these drivers ar efor the low prifile card or simply the ATI AIW 9000 standard and pro. To compund the issues - I recently set MCE2005 to start when the OS boots, so now I have to figure out how to stop MCE form loading so I can remove the drivers and re-install the original ones to get my system stable. I am not sure I followed the exact steps you mention above, so when I get teh time this weekend I might re-do the installation you refer to above. So far it's not lookgin good.
Success! I rolled back to the original drivers from MCE 2004, and then just did a complete install or Kram's drivers, making sure to update the WDM drivers to the ones in that package. One reboot and WOW! I have not only the video running without issue, but also the tuner! I did not think it would get the tuner to work, but it did. When I get home, I will try to look at the file dates and document the procedure a little better, but it was really just install the thing and everything work. Note that these are different from the omega drivers I was using before.
rshassell
2 Posts
464
0
Posted October 28th, 2004 18:00
I too have a recently-purchased 4600c, and I have also been researching what it would take to upgrade to MCE2005. I've not been able to find any low-profile tuner/video combo cards like the AiW9000. I have found at least 2 low-profile video-only cards that ought to work, but don't take my opinion as the final word. One is the ATI-based Powercolor 9600SE. There are also nVIDIA-based low profile cards such as the Jaton FX5700LE. You can find them both on newegg.com.
The nVIDIA looks better to me for several reasons. First, although I have usually bought ATI in the past, I have read many stories lately about buggy ATI drivers, at least as related to MCE2005 issues. Second, the 9600SE only supports DVI and S-video in its low-profile configuration, not VGA, unless you can fabricate a second low-profile backplate and tie up an otherwise unused slot with it. However, the FX5700LS comes with a second low-profile backplate for the VGA connector. The 4600c fills its only PCI slot with a modem card, which in my case is not needed, so that slot would be available for the second video backplate. If you are planning to use DVI as your video output, then this is not an issue.
Newegg.com lists several PCI-based tuner cards that look like they would fit in a low-profile chassis, but few if any look like they come with a low-profile backplate, and none of them state specifically that they work with MCE2005. Of course, if the 4600c's only PCI slot is dedicated to a tuner, the VGA video output option is lost, so an outboard tuner may be the only viable alternative. As an employee ot MS, do you have access to a list of hardware that has been tested or validated to work with MCE2005? That would sure be a help!
Here are some helpful websites that may provide additional info about MCE2005-related issues.
http://www.thegreenbutton.com/
http://www.xpmce.com/