Dell Venue Pro - "memory card is not working properly" and then shuts down
hi Dell,
I preordered your machine in Europe. After 4 months of use (with slowdowns and glitches), i get daily messages that "the memory card is not working properly". This is a 600euro phone we're talking about, and it won't even last 4 months, that's a bit insulting. To add insult to injury, you put a sticker on top of the SD card slot so we can't replace it ourselves. Your support department refers me to the store and the store refers me to your support department.
I cannot spare the phone for more than a week. What do you suggest I do? Right now if I dont have a solution and this will be what I do soon:
- I will void your warranty because I cant get my warranty to stick anyway
- I will avoid further purchases of Dell products in the future, because this was the most expensive phone on the market you'd have expected similar quality.
Complaints:
- random slowdowns
- random unresponsiveness of the touch UI
- memory card not working properly
- Dell support and warranty non-existant
Meanwhile the net is filled with people having SD card issues in their DVP's and the only way to fix them is to void warranty apparently. I personally think that right now the only acceptable solution is either a recall or admitting that users do not void warranty by replacing a faulty part that should have been good in the first place.
Well supposedly in a week or two Dell should have a firmware fix for the SD card issues primarily and a couple of other fixes. As far as you are getting that Memory IO error, then unfortunately you might be in the same situation as me and the phone is bricked ... sadly you and I are holding expensive bricks in that case.
If you hadn't pulled the sticker, I suggest you get the warranty issue settled and do that. If Warranty process is not to your liking as in my situation then you are out of luck for now ... poke away at the phone until you find some hack, or wait for some other person to make some sort of unbricking software for the DVP.
The issue here is that Dell made this phone apparently with no Reset path that consumers can do in situations like this especially with faulty/ flaky hardware such as the DVP. Other WP7 OEM manufacturers have a built in method to resetting and reformatting the SD cards, the Dell branded phone is shipped apparently without such common sense feature. It is by my assessment the most brick prone phone to ever be made. I have had phones brought back to life from the edge of software testing and hardware swapping the Dell DVP was really not suited for commercial release with such a inept configuration. MS plays a participatory role in this as well. They created an OS that has a file system that extends to the local storage partition ... reason why we can't add a SD card through a dedicated slot. The entire OS is underpinned to a single point of failure, the user memory. Anything goes hay wire with the user memory then it is liable to failing to load and entering such a dire state. Now in MS's defense, they wanted to have flash memory soldered onboard, the OEM's and carriers saw it more fit to use SD cards not so well protected or isolated. It invites tampering, and even carriers were marketing SD's targeted specifically for WP7. As for me, my SD card self bricked itself and I think it has something to do with corrupted memory and restarting the phone ... something the firmware should be fixing. It was working fine for me on original SD and because the phone felt sluggish and some apps were crashing, I restarted it. Only to be confronted by said message.
Again it would be great if Dell provided a recovery tool fro Bricked phones ... I believe the SD needs to be reformatted or reset. Current 'updatewp.exe' times out when trying to reset ... Dell must have a solution for this.
My suggestion is hold the grudge, or deal through the bureaucratic Dell warranty machine and see how you land.
As far as I know, SD cards use FAT, given a reader for the pc its quite possible you'd be able to scandisk or format the thing. The dealbreaker is however, even if the store lets me send it back to them, that takes a week, then it gets to dell, another week, and they return me one with the same issues because theyre intermittent after a month of being phoneless, which i can't afford to be either. Sometimes it works fine, other times any thing the OS tries to save bricks it until I take the battery out. It would be far more cost-effective to break warranty and attempt it myself. Mind you, you don't expect a phone's memory to break within 4months of use. According to European consumer law, I can request my money back in full. I am very disappointed in Dell qaulity control. I'm betting their server quality goes through the same 'rigourous' quality testing. And I'm not even talking about the camera that only succeeds in taking blurrier pictures than the LCD display shows me.
Dude, read into the WP7 SD ... to reformat isn't even as simple as sticking it into to the Card Reader, you would have to use a N8 or some special software not available currently. As far as the SD card goes it is a propreitary file system using the 'Security' part of SD cards by creating a key that the WP7 creates by I guess a CRC/ or Checksum method and if the SD isn't provided that 'Key' it cannot be accessed that is what is at issue.
Now it would be unwise if Warranty was your option to forego it. If you start playing with the SD then you'll be on your way to finding a way to unbrick the phone because it is bricked for now. The DVP is a useless door wedge, or a wobbly coaster at best for you and me until an unbricking method is revealed by Dell.
Again what is broken is the shared Key between phone and SD is corrupted. The firmware has at issue a fault in corrupting storage by shared DMA between SD and WiFi.
If the phone is not in the constant loop with the storage (SD) error which allows either emergency or to restart the phone ... then you are in luck. Rather than break warranty and brick the phone, turn WiFi off to gain stability. Wait a week or so, and once the new firmware becomes available try it out. It should be the fix for said storage errors. Your phone is not bricked if it can boot into WP7 and gets passed that emergency screen occasionally.
I waited - the update is "not valid" says zune, stating an error code. I think Zune just prevented my phone from being bricked by Dell's shoddy programming. Meanwhile Dell is actively deleting posts on how to mod your device.
Might I ask for a reply from Dell why I'm getting an update "not valid" error?
Your sticker covering the SD card slot now means nothing any more: Windows itself tells me occasionally your SD card is either broken or non compliant, and *I* should replace it.
Guess what, I've been instructed by your machine to replace it, I'm taking a picture and if so much hint at tampering with warranty when i need it, I'll sue you stating that your own hardware has instructed me to perform said steps, and that the sticker does not mention 'warranty' on it. Meanwhile you should look forward to some negative press comments, because I'm making sure you get some.
For anyone else with the same issues: look for ZDNET Dell upgrade 32GB online and you'll figure it out. Just take a picture of the OS instruction you to do it and you're legally covered i believe. The picture's worth will not be huge in court, but will allow for the court to retrieve the version of the operating system at that time and determine you're right.
I am saddened by Dell for erasing my reply, this is the second time a post of mine was erased under baseless pretenses. I think Dell has to show some responsibility on the matter. I will reiterate the main point's I seem not to get across to Dell and I say this in a non hostile manner but rather as a owner/ operator of one of your products who is concerned with the way the Dell Venue Pro was handled.
I am not advocating for legal recourse, but rather I think there is an opportunity to reach an amicable conclusion to this issue. The first step is to distribute the firmware to fix the phones, and the second is to release a recovery path to the customers with bricked phones.
Sending in a phone for warranty is not what you do to re flash your phone because this is normally an inbuilt functionality of phones. It makes developing on Dell phones a gamble, it means trying new beta WP7 OS's more of a gamble, and it is not simply ideal to send out a phone where the fix can be done by the individual. More so the issue of a phone being bricked is what Dell is wholly responsible for, the situation with the phone and how Dell has handled this created this tumultuous environment. Dell has been negligent that of which I am certain of, because the phone was/ and is (so long as the firmware is not publicly available) defective. The temporary remedy was to remove and change the SD card, something that voided the warranty. A void label that was not clearly marked or gave enough forewarning, also the act of changing an SD card is fraught with the possibility of bricking the phone, and the phone does not have a restore/ reformat boot loader to even allow one to recover from such a simple task. Also I and some people actually had the SD card just fail and go straight into the bricked state, and the message displayed on the phone suggests the user to remove the SD. Dell went silent over the progress of a fix for a very lengthy time while still selling these phones fully knowing the issues at hand.
I really think their is plenty of people who are in this dreaded bricked phone state, I would go so far as to say a 10th of DVP owners have bricked phones because it really is that easy to brick from faulty sd's, faulty firmware, and people trying to change sd's ... their really is that many points of failure for this phone. The warranty situation is even quite nebulous in the matter as well. How are people with SD's removed handled, how about those with an SD that is borked, most warranties are limited in scope and only cover hardware ... what I'm trying to get at is their is no service advisory providing more clarity on the matter.
Again the best amicable remedy is for Dell to release some software which we can reflash/ reformat our phones from the PC. I mean seriously does Dell intend to be a serious contender in the mobility market without having phones that can be recovered? A restore point is not the same as a reflash/ reformat based recovery ... restore relies heavily on the restore point something that can be erased as someone reformats there pc. All the other WP7 phones in the market have this capability, except for Dell ... what gives?
Also to K_Ev, did changing the SD solve your issue? For me it didn't and exacerbated the flaky phone problem into a full out bricked phone.
The post above me mentions the courts, I think my post unfairly got deleted and there seems to be a non-parity way of dealing with threads ... quite selective if you ask me. My post is about taking responsibility, I hope this message board is not complicit in making Dell avoid taking responsibility for such a simple issue, even Samsung Omnia has a recovery pc software available for their phones.
I wanted to further add another harmless scenario which makes the phone require a reflash/ reformat procedure and that is forgetting your password for when your phone goes into hibernation/ hold. There is someone on the XDA boards with that issue, and one could do a restore but if a restore point does not exist then you are out of luck.
As far as I know, the Zune software does a restore point upon upgrading the OS, their is also a community made app to initiate this process. If the Zune method is to be relied on, their is a good possibility not enough people have restore points for there phones.
Could you imagine a scenario where forgetting the lock password is grounds for bricking? This is a badly thought out design for this phone, and a way of remedying this is required.
Slowmoe
10 Posts
1596
1
Posted July 5th, 2011 05:00
Well supposedly in a week or two Dell should have a firmware fix for the SD card issues primarily and a couple of other fixes. As far as you are getting that Memory IO error, then unfortunately you might be in the same situation as me and the phone is bricked ... sadly you and I are holding expensive bricks in that case.
If you hadn't pulled the sticker, I suggest you get the warranty issue settled and do that. If Warranty process is not to your liking as in my situation then you are out of luck for now ... poke away at the phone until you find some hack, or wait for some other person to make some sort of unbricking software for the DVP.
The issue here is that Dell made this phone apparently with no Reset path that consumers can do in situations like this especially with faulty/ flaky hardware such as the DVP. Other WP7 OEM manufacturers have a built in method to resetting and reformatting the SD cards, the Dell branded phone is shipped apparently without such common sense feature. It is by my assessment the most brick prone phone to ever be made. I have had phones brought back to life from the edge of software testing and hardware swapping the Dell DVP was really not suited for commercial release with such a inept configuration. MS plays a participatory role in this as well. They created an OS that has a file system that extends to the local storage partition ... reason why we can't add a SD card through a dedicated slot. The entire OS is underpinned to a single point of failure, the user memory. Anything goes hay wire with the user memory then it is liable to failing to load and entering such a dire state. Now in MS's defense, they wanted to have flash memory soldered onboard, the OEM's and carriers saw it more fit to use SD cards not so well protected or isolated. It invites tampering, and even carriers were marketing SD's targeted specifically for WP7. As for me, my SD card self bricked itself and I think it has something to do with corrupted memory and restarting the phone ... something the firmware should be fixing. It was working fine for me on original SD and because the phone felt sluggish and some apps were crashing, I restarted it. Only to be confronted by said message.
Again it would be great if Dell provided a recovery tool fro Bricked phones ... I believe the SD needs to be reformatted or reset. Current 'updatewp.exe' times out when trying to reset ... Dell must have a solution for this.
My suggestion is hold the grudge, or deal through the bureaucratic Dell warranty machine and see how you land.