UNSOLVED

saadlu

updated

22 years ago

S

saadlu

11 Posts

0

35200

January 18th, 2005 00:00

Inspiron 600m harddrive always ticking

Hello all,

I had a Hitachi 40GB harddrive.

From the first day I have my inspiron 600m, the harddrive is ticking even when the computer is doing nothing. I tested in WinXP and in SuSe 9.2 Linux. In both platform, when I do not do anything at all, the harddrive is doing something and it ticks.

I called Dell Customer Service and as usual they didn't ask much question and offered to replace my drive. They sent me a Fujitsu 40GB today (apperantly refurbished).

I installed everything from scratch again. But the ticking sound is not going away. It does not seem as loud as before but there is something goes on with harddrive even when I am not doing anything.

Is this a common problem? Or am I just crazy?

Thanks
Sa'ad
  • billw020104

    152 Posts

    352

    0

    Posted January 18th, 2005 23:00

    Is your BIOS version A14?

    Bill

    Inspiron 600m
    Inspiron 8200
    Inspiron 8100

  • saadlu

    11 Posts

    352

    0

    Posted January 19th, 2005 02:00

    Yes my BIOS version is A14.

    What should I do?
  • billw020104

    152 Posts

    351

    0

    Posted January 19th, 2005 12:00

    Take a look at this on the 600m download page.

    Release Date:  08/02/2004
    Description:  Hitachi Travelstar 5K80 firmware (rev. A5EA) corrects an intermittent clicking noise issue on the following models:

    HTS548020M9AT00 (20GB - P/N M1170)
    HTS548040M9AT00 (40GB - P/N N1166)
    HTS548060M9AT00 (60GB - P/N R1079)
    HTS548080M9AT00 (80GB - P/N P1128)

     
     
    Bill
    Inspiron 600m
    Inspiron 8200
    Inspiron 8100
  • billw020104

    152 Posts

    351

    0

    Posted January 19th, 2005 14:00

    My 600m 60GB 5400 RPM HDD is made by Toshiba---I never hear it or the fan. :smileyhappy:

    Good Luck.

    Bill

    Inspiron 600m
    Inspiron 8200
    Inspiron 8100

  • saadlu

    11 Posts

    351

    0

    Posted January 19th, 2005 14:00

    Well, to test I have to be very close the laptop and it would have to be a quite place. The ticking does not happen continueously in a constant rhythm though...sometime it happens within 2 seconds and sometimes within 30.

    When I run my SuSe Live CD, I don't get any sound whatsoever. So initially I suspected the harddrive. But now that I have changed my harddrive, I don't know if this is really a problem or not.

    Could it be related to my Motherboard. Is there a change that the motherboard is defective and its sending request to the harddrive even though there is not need to?

    Thanks for you help.
  • saadlu

    11 Posts

    351

    0

    Posted January 19th, 2005 14:00

    Thanks,

    But I installed Fujitsu model now. I still get the ticking, though much less annoying. I checked my friends laptop and it seems that his 600m has the same problem (he has a fujitsu model too). So I guess, I will assume this ticking is normal.

    thank for you help.
  • iridium8

    16 Posts

    351

    0

    Posted January 21st, 2005 21:00

    Can someone please provide details on how to go about installing this firmware upgrade (the non-floppy disk version) on my i8600?

    I don't know how to create a bootable USB flash drive. Once that is done, how do you go about installing the firmware?

    Thanks. 

    Message Edited by iridium8 on 01-21-2005 05:24 PM

  • 351

    0

    Posted January 22nd, 2005 11:00

    iridium8:

    Check out these two links which I find helpful:

    http://www.aaltonen.us/archive/2004/03/01/tip-boot-from-usb-key-addendum/

    http://www.memorykeytools.com/ 

  • 351

    0

    Posted January 22nd, 2005 11:00

    I got my Inspiron 600m on Jan 13, 2005 and ever since I started the notebook computer, I have had the same ticking sound as described by saadlu. I've exhausted all means trying to get rid of the annoying noise every few seconds even when I am not working with this computer. The HD is HTS548060M9AT00 - 60G (Hitachi 5K80). There is *no* ticking sound in DOS mode. Run Dell diagnostics, all tests are fine. This same ticking noise occurs in both Windows 2003 and Windows XP.
     
    I've tried the following with *no* success:
     
    1. Make sure both BIOS and drive Firmware are up-to-date
    2. Turn off "Allow the computer to turn off this device to save power" in USB Root Hub (1-4)
    3. Use Hitachi Feature Tools 1.96, to enable Accoustic Management and Maximize the Performance
    4. Turn off Indexing service
     
    Afte much of research of Internet and Dell forums, it appears that some Hitachi drives have this problem. Though, after so much reading, the noise remains mysterious to me as no definite explaination. Dell technical supports suggest a drive replacement. Dell Customer Care offers two options for drive replacement: like for like, or credit towards a new and different hard drive.
     
    I was thinking that a different brand of hard drive would solve the ticking problem. Now I start to doubt that getting a new drive will fix the problem since saadlu got a Fujitsu drive and problem remains. I have two Dell servers (PowerEdge 1600SC with SCSI RAID5 and PowerEdge 1800 with SATA RAID5) and two Dell notebooks (the other one is Inspiron 5150, hard drive got bad sectors after 1.5 years of use). Now I got this problem, sad... ...

    Message Edited by Mr.Unbelivable on 01-22-2005 07:29 AM

    Message Edited by Mr.Unbelivable on 01-22-2005 07:31 AM

  • saadlu

    11 Posts

    282

    0

    Posted January 22nd, 2005 16:00

    Hello All,

    I did the following test in other laptops:

    after sitting very close to the laptop and leaning my ear towards the harddrive area, I count to 60 and try to listen if there is some king of ticking. I am also watching the harddrive LED while doing this.

    I tried two toshiba laptop, one with centrino 1.6 tablet and other A30 Satelite. Both laptop read the harddrive within 60 counts and there were ticks.

    It was the same for another Inspion 600m.

    So my guess is that the periodic ticking is normal. But I am not so sure...you guys can comment.

    BTW: If I do run Linux Live CD (knoppix or SuSe), there no ticking!