UNSOLVED

iantz

updated

20 years ago

I

iantz

34 Posts

0

28366

August 2nd, 2006 19:00

E510 fried hard drive in RAID 1 + My solution to this problem

A month ago I bought a new Seagate 160Gb hard drive and setup a RAID 1. Two days ago, one hard drive is fried. This E510 case is abysmal - there is no air flow in the hard drive cage, especially if using two hard drives. The fried hard was the one mounted in the bottom of the cage, and off course it was the one that I bought, so no warranty!

I just bought another hard drive, plus two hard drive fans, plus two 80mm fans for case exhaust. I think I am going to cut the hard drive cage and mount both drives on the bottom of the case, or mount one in the CD bay with the help of an adapter - I saw one that also has three fans for cooling.

Anyway, for those of you with RAID setups, or with 2 hard drives, be aware - sooner or later one hard drive will fry! Back up your data! This has happened to a lot of people on this forum. I have no idea how this flawed design made it to the market!

Message Edited by iantz on 08-03-200602:57 PM

  • shesagordie

    12 Elder

    •

    46017 Posts

    1349

    0

    Posted August 2nd, 2006 20:00

    iantz
     
    Seagate should replace a failed hard drive, try contacting them for a replacement, 
     
     
    Bev.
     
     
  • triky40

    1 Rookie

    •

    14 Posts

    1349

    0

    Posted August 2nd, 2006 23:00

    iantz,

    Could you please tell me what type of hd cooler that you have?  I'm looking for one also.  Normally the hd on my E510 indicates around 55 to 60 deg C under normal use (internet, word processing).  Sorry to hear your lose but if you can help by posting here what you have done to fix the problem I'm sure a lot of E510 users (at least) are appreciate it.

    ty,

    tri

  • iantz

    34 Posts

    1349

    0

    Posted August 3rd, 2006 01:00

    After a couple of hours and about $10 later, this is how it looks now:



    or



    I am still wainting for these 2 from ebay:


    The L brackets are from Home Depot ($2), the 80mm case fans from 2 old power sources, the Y splitter, IDE to SATA power cable and the SATA cable from a local computer repairs shop for about $5. I paid $10 for the HD fans on ebay. Anyway, the HD was the most expansive one - $62 at newegg. I am going to contact Seagate though, and maybe sell the replacement on ebay if I get one.

    RAID is restoring, and I am a happy camper now :) The air flow is amazing now - I put a lighter in front of the computer, and it s u c k e d the flame right in. I love it. I don't even know if I should install the HD fans anymore.

    However, nobody shouldn't go through all this - Dell should have designed a better case.

    Message Edited by iantz on 08-03-200602:58 PM

  • iantz

    34 Posts

    1349

    0

    Posted August 3rd, 2006 12:00

    Bev,

    If seagate replaces my hard drive, do you know if I have to send them the old one? If yes, how do I delete all the info I have on it? I don't feel confortable sending my tax returns etc. to anybody!

    Thanks
  • iantz

    34 Posts

    1350

    0

    Posted August 3rd, 2006 13:00

    Just checked with Seagate - no warranty on the fried drive:

    "The product you identified was sold as a system component. Please contact your place of purchase for service. Seagate sells many drives to direct OEM (Original Equipment Manufacturer) customers. These products are usually configured for the OEMs only, as components for their systems. You must contact your place of purchase for any warranty support on these drives."

    I bought it on ebay, and the seller offered a 30 day warranty - off course it died on the 35th or so....

    Bummer :(
  • iantz

    34 Posts

    1350

    0

    Posted August 3rd, 2006 18:00

    Thanks Bev.

    So, it looks like I lost the $62 I paid for it. Anyway, I am happy with the way the new setup came out.

    Message Edited by iantz on 08-03-200602:27 PM

  • Hal 2001

    18 Posts

    1350

    0

    Posted August 3rd, 2006 18:00

    I have one of the "HOT" HD  E510 machines with the same problem as you AND MANY OTHER's who have the dual drives installed for "DataSafe". The temp on that lower HD drive is so hot that you can't touch your finger to it for longer then seven to ten seconds! This new Dell BTX case cooling design is not workable for those two hard drives . The problem seems to be only in the machines with the two drives for Datasafe. I work with the same models at my job site  (E510)  but with only one drive and they all  operate at normal working temp. specs.  I would like to see Dell address this design issue for units under current warranty and send the owner a WORKING refit for cooling this bad design problem, at no cost.  It would be better for everyone and that includes Dell to face up to this problem and correct it now before hard drives start getting returned and customers churn away from Dell Computer buying! This is an other Optiplex mother board bad capactor type problem.  I hope Dell will value there customer's and handle this issue ASAP as they should. The ball is now in Dell's court so let's see how they play it .  
  • shesagordie

    12 Elder

    •

    46017 Posts

    1350

    0

    Posted August 3rd, 2006 18:00

    iantz
     
    Yes, you're right it's a bummer :smileytongue:
     
    But, at least it takes care of your data removal problem, just destroy the drive, either by taking a hammer to it or opening the case and removing the platters, then cutting them into pieces.
     
    Hope you did not pay much for the drive.
     
    Bev.
  • shesagordie

    12 Elder

    •

    46017 Posts

    1350

    0

    Posted August 3rd, 2006 18:00

    iantz
     
    Seagate will require you to send them the hard drive, prior to receiving the replacement.   Unless you have an account or give a CC number to Seagate, then they will sent the replacement ASAP, but unless you return the defective drive, you will be charged for it.
     
    Unless hard drive works, you cannot erase the data from it.
     
    Bev.
     
     
  • shesagordie

    12 Elder

    •

    46017 Posts

    733

    0

    Posted August 3rd, 2006 19:00

    iantz
     
    That's how we all learn, "the hard way". :smileywink:
     
    I've found  www.newegg.com  and  www.zipzoomfly.com  to be reliable vendors with excellent service.
     
    Bev.