i have the PERC320 card with a raid 5 of 4 Seagate 300gig's
and I'm getting read speeds of 25mb/s, and 2.5mb/s write.
this is from a bench mark within a video capture program, but all i need is a write speed of 4.5mb/s to capture the video quality i want. Reading on the forums this performance is much lower that what i have seen from other peoples results. Now the benchmark within the video capture program my not be reading the true performance of the drives, but over all everything that has to do with writing to the drives has been slow. In the beginning i figured this slow performance was due to the drives still being verified by the raid controller, and during that process write speeds were 1.3mb/s, but that process has finished and the performance has just barley doubled. I tried enabling the WRC on the controller from default to enabled but there was no performance increase. I also checked if the SCSI cable was really 320, cause in another part of the forum they were saying it could be 160.
I figure I'm going to have to send it back to Dell and have it reconfigured with 1 boot drive, 1 scratch drive, and 2 in a raid 1 for data protection. I would do that my self but seeing as i don't work in the IT department, I'm not allowed to, and the IT department sees that as being over there head, so I'm going to have Dell do it.
But before i go through all that trouble if anyone has any suggestions as to how i can increase the performance of the drives even 2 more mb/s, i would be very happy to hear it.
I am not sure why you are getting that type of performance for a Raid 5 configuration. You should be seeing Read/Write north of 70mb/sec. It almost seems like the Raid 5 is configured to transfer in synchronous mode; usually reserved and used on some UNIX systems.
You suggestion to dismantle the array and configure: 1 boot drive, 1 scratch drive, and 2 in a raid 1 for data protection, will yield excellent results at the expense of wasting massive amount of storage. You should try to have a boot drive of 73GB or 146GB and have a small 15K for the page file and Raid 3 300GB drives & 1 300GB for additional data backup.
Also I am not sure if the drives are being air cooled; the Seagate 300GB if not properly cooled will reach critical operating temperatures within a very short time if actively used; specially with video editing. These drives should reside in an external air cooled enclosure.
I have all my SCSI 300GB & 15K in external enclosures and still the operate at a decent temperature. If the drives are not actively cooled they will fail prematurely; even with the Raid 1 you could loose all data since the temperature will create data corruption, and even Raid 1 will not salvage the data.
Have your IT look into your configuration and cooling requirements.
P.S. The raid card has an option to enable disk cache, if not enabled, this feature will produce a jump in performance.
Message Edited by Chipstone on 07-07-2005 03:13 PM
My IT department has taken over the operation of fixing the machine so i dont know what they plan to do. Ive gotten word that dell has suggested that they change out the controller because it may be malefunctioning.
They might also reconfigure the computer with the system/scratch/RAID 1 setup that i suggested.
Hopefully in that configuration the preformance will be more of what is expected.
It shouldn't run anywhere near that slowly if properly configured. It sounds like either a shared IRQ or a stripe size problem. If your stripe is too big or too small that will restrict throughput -- especially in RAID-5 writing. It sounds like the stripe is WAY too small (ie: 4k or smaller). With too small a stripe the controller has to work overtime generating parity for each chunk.
An IRQ conflict may be the culprit as well. Make sure the card is in a master slot and is not in conflict with and other PCI-x/e adapters.
We have 4 numbers of Dell Precision 670, dual 3.6GHz, 4GB RAM, 4 x 300GB Ultra320SCSI HDD(Fujitisu) , PERC320/DC RAID adapter.
I am getting very poor performance on disk transfer rates (20-33MB/sec) while file copy/process etc. We use large imagery files at the size of 2GB-15GB. With other Dell machines like Precision650 with Individual disks (without RAID) we are getting better performance than this.
After going through this forum I enabled the write cache on the controller from the controller bios but no visible difference. We have machines with RAID5 as well as RAID0. With RAID0, we are getting maximum ~33MB/s.
i have thus given up on dell. It is rediculous that these machines preform so poor and yet they still sell them they way they are.
I have returned the computer with this setup and have been wating for the replacement for about 3 months now. Apparently there was some issue with shipping (not dell's fault, my company's) or something, so its taking way longer then it should.
I no longer use Raid configurations. The new high capacity drives: 300GB 10K & 146GB 15K, have excellent sustained transfer rates for most of my projects, and far exceed the benefits of some raid configurations.
However, the transfer rates you are experiencing, even on a Raid 0, are probably related to the Raid controller card. Remember the 670 PCI-X has the capacity of 100 MHz bus; some raid cards do not take advantage of the new PCI-X speed, and are capped at the old 64 bus interface.
I use the hybrid Adapted 39320A-R controller card; it can be configured as a Raid or SCSI controller or both, if you have the dual channel model. I have tested Raid 0 configurations for clients with 300GB Maxtor & Fujitsu, as well as 146GB 15K Maxtor, Fujitsu & Seagate. Sustained transfer rates are north of 140mb/sec on the 300GB and over 160mb/sec with the 15K; bust transfer are 270MB/sec.
So I believe the problem may reside in the Raid card. The Adaptec 39320 chip has new SCSI protocols that have improved, exponentially, the performance of rear/write and transfer rates.
It’s not the 670 PCI-X or the drives causing the problem; it’s the Raid controller card.
I am just wondering whether any one from Dell is really looking in to this issue of RAID performance!! Apparently there are lot of people facing this problem and only a few are visible in this forum or will enter to this forum after desperation of trying all other ways (like myself).
On the issue of RAID card, I tested one of our Prec-670 machine after removing the PERC320/DC card. I used the built-in ultra320SCSI bus(on the motherboard) instead of the PERC RAID card and the performance improved a lot. The only issue now is that the built-in RAID/SCSI does not support a RAID-5.
Comparison of PERC320 v/s built-in SCSI on RAID0 configuration with writecache enabled:
With PERC320/DC file copy test was 22MB/s and on built-in SCSI this improved to 50MB/s
With PERC320/DC createdata was 30MB/s and on built-in SCSI this improved to 106MB/s
Similarly Readdata changed from 40MB/s to 101MB/s
Local Dell dealer suggests to use PERC4 RAID card with 256MB memory. But I don't know how much this helps. Any one got any idea on this card?
In a good workstation (Not like Dell) a RAID 0 should be one of the fastest RAID Configuration. You must not choose RAID 5 for performance but for fault tolerance + Disk space. If you want both of them, choose RAID 1+0 but you will need an extra RAID Controller because the integrated one cannot do this.
I have spend 8 months on this problem and Dell / local Dell dealers are playing hide and seek nowadays. The best solution I found is
1. Discard PERC320 (You will loose RAID5)
2. Use built-in SCSI for RAID0
This will improve performance almost 2 times of what you are getting now.
Another way is to use the built-in controller but don't select any RAID levels. select one drive to use for OS installation and leave the others without configuring.
From the Operating system - like Win-XPSP2- use disk management to select the remaining 3 drives as a stripe set. This will be working as a RAID0 with much better performance than a PERC320. Remember to backup your data in this volume because drives are not very reliable nowadays.
Chipstone
525 Posts
764
0
Posted July 7th, 2005 18:00
You suggestion to dismantle the array and configure: 1 boot drive, 1 scratch drive, and 2 in a raid 1 for data protection, will yield excellent results at the expense of wasting massive amount of storage. You should try to have a boot drive of 73GB or 146GB and have a small 15K for the page file and Raid 3 300GB drives & 1 300GB for additional data backup.
Also I am not sure if the drives are being air cooled; the Seagate 300GB if not properly cooled will reach critical operating temperatures within a very short time if actively used; specially with video editing. These drives should reside in an external air cooled enclosure.
I have all my SCSI 300GB & 15K in external enclosures and still the operate at a decent temperature. If the drives are not actively cooled they will fail prematurely; even with the Raid 1 you could loose all data since the temperature will create data corruption, and even Raid 1 will not salvage the data.
Have your IT look into your configuration and cooling requirements.
P.S. The raid card has an option to enable disk cache, if not enabled, this feature will produce a jump in performance.
Message Edited by Chipstone on 07-07-2005 03:13 PM