Attn: Chris_M 2407 menu adjustment to fix banding??
Chris,
I have a 2407 Rev A02. Desktop mode displays mild visible banding horizontally and more prominantly in vertical directions. Diagonal shades are somewhat out of kilter too.
I love the monitor but not the banding..... I need advice from you before I opt to send it back for a refund. Options are:
1. I can return for refund as it's a design defect not me.
2. I can wait on Rev A03: is there a true fix for this being produced? - timeframe?? will I be elligible even if it's in 3-4 months time? (i.e. does dell acknowledge this as a design defect warranting replacement when the design is rectified?)
3. Different people seem to report different levels.... the manufacturers menu has gain controls etc... can adjustment of these reduce or remove the banding? i.e. is it the tuning out of the factory that is the issue and not the 'design'??
Can you please seek some advice from engineering staff and let us know? A walkthrough of required adjustments would be nice if this is a method of fixing things.
I would like to know the same things. For me I see mild banding with VGA (only at the dark end of the spectrum). I see prominent banding with DV, even at the bright end of the spectrum.
If DVI worked to the same level as VGA, I would be satisfied.
1. I can return for refund as it's a design defect not me.
* Within the initial XX days of invoice date, yes. For a full refund. We are adding days to the policy for this issue alone.
2. I can wait on Rev A03: is there a true fix for this being produced? - timeframe?
* There is NO A03 planned.
will I be elligible even if it's in 3-4 months time?
* You may initiate an exchange at any time during the warranty period.
(i.e. does dell acknowledge this as a design defect warranting replacement when the design is rectified?)
* You may initiate an exchange at any time during the warranty period.
3. Different people seem to report different levels.... the manufacturers menu has gain controls etc... can adjustment of these reduce or remove the banding? i.e. is it the tuning out of the factory that is the issue and not the 'design'??
* Users will have to test the adjustments in the Service Menu. We don't have any guidelines for this.
Message Edited by DELL-ChrisM on 06-27-200611:45 PM
Might have been nice to have some feedback from the folks who made the screen since I have no idea what adjustments in the service menu will do to help (if anything).
At least I know what's what so I can make a decision now.
I can report that switching off Adobe Gamma (or other monitor profiles) still results in banding with DVI & Desktop mode.
Furthermore, accurate calibration (profile) of a monitor is the cornerstone of photo editing. Without calibration we may as well be working with no monitor at all.
So the 2407 banding issue has not beeen resolved as far as I am concerned.
I can report that switching off Adobe Gamma (or other monitor profiles) still results in banding with DVI & Desktop mode.
Furthermore, accurate calibration (profile) of a monitor is the cornerstone of photo editing. Without calibration we may as well be working with no monitor at all.
So the 2407 banding issue has not beeen resolved as far as I am concerned.
Shilesh"
I too have banding. Maybe the Faroudja chip issue resolved in A02 isn't the real problem.
yes, still bands, just a fair amount less so without those profiles.
yeah, perhaps it was not all the Faroudja. it is true that it should not have been on for desktop mode and it probably should be expected to reduce the number of shades when working properly in special modes, but considering that it seems to reduce the number of shades by what appears to be an unusually large amount and that there is still somewhat of an unusual amount of banding even without it on, maybe that was not the real issue, just something that made it more apparent?
anyway, i shouldn't say anymore until I can get back to the monitor and others for comparison.
Hi all,
I think there is still some confusion about the 2407WFP A02.
Some user experienced NO BANDING at all, some still do!
Should we start a new thread called "User Results - Banding Issue for the 2407WFP A02"?
Also, users should provide systems info and details.
ie: Exact Model Number, Graphics Card, Resolution, Mode used, Color Correction software used, testing method, cables (Dell or other),...
I would like to add one testing advice for some unexperienced users.
Do not use a photo as reference for your tests!
And if you do, make sure that the photo hasn't been altered and has at least 16 bit channels. You see, most photos have had some digital treatment applied to them (ie: beautiful wallpapers find online, jpgs...) these treatments sometimes (if unproperly done) creates banding on the photo itself. Therefore they cannot guarantee an accurate testing. Use accurate testing tools (see other threads)
The only valid test you can do with an "average" photo is compare it side by side with another monitor(CRT)
Anyway, I didn't feel like starting a new thread myself (so many outthere!!)
But maybe one of you (Chris M perhaps) is willing to create one.
And let's keep it clean....
My 2407WFP (A02) is arriving today or tommorow...so I'll let you know.
G.
Well I tested my new A02. Banding issue.
The most relevant thread (+ result)
http://forums.us.dell.com/supportforums/board/message?board.id=dim_monitor&message.id=59280
tgb456
8 Posts
467
0
Posted June 25th, 2006 23:00
excellent questions. i would like to know as well.
cheers