UNSOLVED

davelee98

updated

20 years ago

D

davelee98

3 Posts

0

38648

September 17th, 2006 16:00

2407 WFP A03 Intermittent Failure

I'm disappointed in the quality control on the 2407 WFP panels. My first 2407 WFP was DOA. It wouldn't even turn on -- no sign of life when operating the power button. It took several phone calls and 30 minutes with the offshore tech support people to get them to agree it was DOA. What a waste of time.

At least the replacement panel arrived promptly the next day. The first DOA panel was made in Mexico. The replacement 2407 WFP is made in China. The new panel worked great for about a month. No dead pixels and picture was flawless. HOWEVER, it is now failing intermittently. Here are the symptoms:

Unit "turns on" fine -- the power button and source indicator both turn green. Then, it shows a picture for about 1/2 a second after which the picture immediately shuts off similar to power-save mode. The buttons however are still green. During the split second where the picture is on, it looks completely fine.

Second test: I disconnected all unnecessary cables from the back of the monitor, only power and DVI cable are connected. After turning on the monitor, again, I get my windows desktop for about 1/2 second before the picture turns off again. 2407 is still showing green #2 and power button.

Third test: Disconnected everything but the power cable. Monitor turns on in "Power-save" mode with amber buttons. I press the "menu" button on the monitor and I get a 1/2 second of the blue message box saying that no sources are connected after which the picture turns off again. Buttons stay green for a few seconds (which should be the normal duration of the message) before it goes back to power save.

I got lucky earlier today and managed to get the monitor to actually work for about 15 minutes after which it returned to the failure mode described above.

Anyone else have a similar problem? I assume the unit is simply defective and I will have to RMA for my third 2407WFP.

- David
  • davelee98

    3 Posts

    432

    0

    Posted September 17th, 2006 17:00



    @ArchAnge1 wrote:
    Hi Dave, lots of people are having this problem with A03, you can read about it in threads here, dctokyo being one person having simular issues.

    Im sad, i want to buy a A03, i been saving for a year for my dream widescreen lcd, all this news is not pleasing to me, can i ask you, would you recomend me buying a 2407wfp, as its a huge purchase for me and im afraid ill get something i wont be happy with :( ? Sounds like Dell hasnt been helpfull to you also :( Perhaps i should buy another brand ? what do you think man ? Are you happy with DELL ?

    Hope you get what your after in the end there. DELL needs slapin.




    When the 2407WFP is working, it looks great. However, given my personal experience and reading about problems on this and other forums, I would advise potential purchasers to wait until this panel goes through a few more revisions. Ultimately, as long as the panel keeps failing, Dell will have to keep replacing it. It would be interesting to see the RMA rate on this product as I suspect it is astronomically high. Dell customer support will eventually do the right thing, but only after wasting my valuable time. The mere fact that they suggest unplugging / replugging parts from the wall to reset devices such as monitors to see if it fixes problems speaks volumes about the poor quality of the electronics inside. Imagine if they suggested to your local datacenter that they should cycle the power to a set of server racks because the dell servers were acting up! My last monitor was a NEC XP17 17" CRT monitor that cost about $1000 in 1995 that still works as good today as it did when I first bought it. That monitor was made in Japan and is bulletproof. It's too bad they don't make electronics to the same level of reliability today.
  • ArchAnge1

    344 Posts

    432

    0

    Posted September 17th, 2006 17:00

    Hi Dave, lots of people are having this problem with A03, you can read about it in threads here, dctokyo being one person having simular issues.

    Im sad, i want to buy a A03, i been saving for a year for my dream widescreen lcd, all this news is not pleasing to me, can i ask you, would you recomend me buying a 2407wfp, as its a huge purchase for me and im afraid ill get something i wont be happy with :( ? Sounds like Dell hasnt been helpfull to you also :( Perhaps i should buy another brand ? what do you think man ? Are you happy with DELL ?

    Hope you get what your after in the end there. DELL needs slapin.
  • all the facts

    2 Intern

    •

    983 Posts

    432

    0

    Posted September 17th, 2006 17:00

    ArchAnge1 , beat me again:)

    davelee98
    The intermittent failure sounds like another post I read here. No display and green lights on. I recommended exchanging it.

    You seem to have a bad internal connection and a possible short somewhere, because it's loosing its signal to the display.

    You did about everything you can do.

    If you want to, try unplugging it, plug it back in and set it to factory defaults in the menu, if it stays on long enough, see if it's O.K. after that. If you can't do that much, unplug it, leave it unplugged so you don't risk a short turning in to a FIRE, then exchange it again. One report here of a smoking panel. Be safe, not sorry.

    Don't waste any more time with it.

    Hope you get a good one next time and exchange until you get what you want.

    Good Day!

    Message Edited by all the facts on 09-17-2006 01:45 PM

    Message Edited by all the facts on 09-17-2006 01:57 PM

  • ArchAnge1

    344 Posts

    432

    0

    Posted September 17th, 2006 18:00

    "all the facts
    I don't work for Dell or any of its affiliates"
     
     
    Oh rite, i heard a rumour that all the facts was Mr Dell himself hahahaha.
     
    JUST KIDDING.
  • davelee98

    3 Posts

    432

    0

    Posted September 17th, 2006 18:00



    @all the facts wrote:
    You wrote,

    The mere fact that they suggest unplugging / replugging parts from the wall to reset devices such as monitors to see if it fixes problems speaks volumes about the poor quality of the electronics inside.

    I suggested you do that also to try to save you anymore lost time and waiting for an exchange.




    I have of course tried the unplugging and replugging routine since it does clear up problems sometimes. I stand by my original remark, however, that if that fixes anything, the equipment was borderline faulty to begin with. When was the last time someone asked you to unplug and replug the battery in your car because it failed to start, or unplug and replug your television because it wouldn't turn on? Or your microwave or dishwasher? This unplugging business is what you end up with when a product has insufficient QC on electronic components or an electrical design that is run too "close to the edge" or a too-cheap power supply in order to save money.

    In any case I will be RMAing this monitor as it is clearly defective.

    - David
  • Ambress

    7 Posts

    432

    0

    Posted September 17th, 2006 18:00

    Dave.
     
    Your problem with the 2nd 2407WFP you received sounds to be a duplicate of the same situation I am having with a new version A02 unit I received.  Here is my original posting on it: 
     
    Now having returned from vacation and able to take the time to deal with this monitor, I think the answer is a simple one given all the problems I'm reading about.  I'm returning it.  I'll either wait until Dell puts out a higher quality unit or pursue another brand with better reports.
     
    Regards,
     
    Daryl

    Message Edited by Ambress on 09-17-2006 02:34 PM

  • all the facts

    2 Intern

    •

    983 Posts

    432

    0

    Posted September 17th, 2006 18:00

    You wrote,

    "The mere fact that they suggest unplugging / replugging parts from the wall to reset devices such as monitors to see if it fixes problems speaks volumes about the poor quality of the electronics inside."

    I suggested you do that, also, to try to save you anymore lost time waiting for an exchange.

    I also wrote, if it doesn't work then unplug it and leave it unplugged.

    It's always your choice.

    all the facts
    I don't work for Dell or any of its affiliates.

    Good Day!

    Message Edited by all the facts on 09-17-2006 02:07 PM

  • all the facts

    2 Intern

    •

    983 Posts

    432

    0

    Posted September 17th, 2006 18:00

    Paycheck plus bonus please:)

    Someone with a working A03 please toggle the soft dither button in hiddebn menu.

    See if banding comes back when OFF and goes away when ON in desktop mode and the other two modes.

    As a reminder, Dell screens allow you to access the hidden ‘factory’ OSD menu to find out some additional information about your screen. Here is how to do it, it will become important later on…



    1- Turn off your screen, while your computer is still on.
    2- Press simultaneously the 'Menu' and '+' button of the screen.
    3- While holding the 2 buttons, press now the 'Power' button. Now let go.
    4- Once the screen in ON, unpress the 3 buttons.
    5- Just press the '-' button.
    6- Press menu again to exit hidden menu.


    Good Day!

    Message Edited by all the facts on 09-17-2006 02:31 PM

  • skeetz

    2 Posts

    432

    0

    Posted September 18th, 2006 01:00

    just out of curiosity, those who are having this problem - any of you using factory oc'ed nvidia cards? I read somewhere that they have a tendancy to shut off the video signal to the the lcd monitor. Because the symptoms of those cards seems eerily similar - screen goes blank (black) but everything else seems fine.
  • Ambress

    7 Posts

    314

    0

    Posted September 18th, 2006 03:00

    Hi Skeetz,

    That's a good thought, but no, even though the new PC I've built is using an nVidia GeForce 7600GT graphics card, it is not factory overclocked to my knowledge. Even had it been slightly overclocked, I think a properly built monitor should be able to handle that. In any case, I also tested out my 2407WFP on an Inspiron 9300 laptop with an ATI Mobility Radeon graphics chipset and a Compaq desktop PC with an ATI 9500XL graphics card. So, again, good thinking, but I don't believe an overclocked card to be the source of the problem here.

    After a 47-minute call to Tech Support and ultimately Customer Care where our call got disconnected, a follow-up 30-minute call again to Tech Support and Customer Care led me to obtaining a return authorization with Dell arranging for UPS to pick up the monitor and return it at Dell's expense. So, once I see the credit refund, I'll be satisfied and will then keep my eyes open for a better-built and higher quality LCD monitor in the months ahead. Maybe Dell will even manage to produce another that is more akin to what I'd expect to see from them in terms of quality.

    Regards,

    Daryl