This issue has only become apparent in the last week or so, as when I was reading reviews a couple of weeks ago there was nothing but good things to be found about the monitor.
Now that units are getting into the hands of people all over the world (and not just hand picked units for review sites), there appears to be an almost 100% occurrence of the colour banding showing up. Almost everyone reports that DVI is terrible to the point that the monitor shouldn't be used for any graphics work (involving gradients etc - clarity is great!) and even in gaming or watching DVDs (Step into Liquid - lots of underwater shots - was the first DVD I saw on it) the problem is noticable.
If Dell choose not to acknowledge this problem then they'll almost certainly be able to bluff their way out of 75% of complaints by just shipping them a new copy complete with the same problem, and deal with the maybe 1-2% of purchasers that actually demand satisfaction by either refunding them or giving them an upgrade to a similar unit that works properly.
My specific question is does anyone think Dell will actually do the responsible thing which would be to pull this model from sale instantly until the problem is at least identified? There's no question that it would be the "right" thing to do, but I suspect Dell will take the cheapest approach which will be to address the small number of people that complain bitterly on an individual basis, and silently fix the problem and let all the faulty units just be sold anyway.
What should Dell offer to current owners that are not happy? Complete refund? 2005FPW as replacement with a partial refund? Heavily discounted upgrade to 2405? Refund and discount on a 2007FPW(mark2) after the problem is solved?
Come on Dell, while not a professional monitor, this is a relatively expensive bit of kit and from all the info I have seen, not a single example sold through normal retail methods DOESN'T have this problem.
It would be nice to get a real reply from Dell, but I'm not holding my breath...
Dream on. Maybe if returns hit 50% they might do something. But if they are under 20%, I suspect it is buisness as usual.
Some additional data. This affects both the 4:3 2007fp and the 16:10 2007fpw/wfp wide version. It seems to be DVI problem. People who own the previous monitor and compare them, indicate this problem doesn't exist with the 2005fpw or the 2001fp. People who compare to any other LCD also find the problem worse on the 2007 series. Even 6 bit dithering panels work better.
Now if returns hit some magic number like 30%, Dell might perform an analysis on the reasons to see if something stands out. Now if banding is at the top of the list,they might actually check it. Then they might actually talk to the OEM who supplies the product, and then they might actually check it, and if the fix doesn't require a fundemental change and is cheap to repair, the next production run 6-12 months from now might be ok. IOW if, if, if, might, might, might...
It is not only returns that hurt them. It is people who read the reports on forums and realize there is a problem and just avoid these products (like me). Dell can't track this.
At least with backlight bleed, there seemed to be some chance of getting a good one, here it seems, all the DVI inputs are substandard. I think this is a must avoid.
Hopefully a real review site, takes a crack at a real retail monitor.
hey everyone I just got my 2007FP and will run some tests and take some pics
stay tuned for more info! I want to see it for myself and I am still wishful... we shall see!
A very good user review and comparison (with screenshots) is here:
While the quality of the screen shots is not that good. He shows the gradients compared to a Viewsonic, both of them in VGA and DVI mode. This backs up what everyone has been saying. The problem only really exists with DVI input. Other notable mention. The monitor is just about perfect otherwise.
http://www.widescreengamingforum.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=4203
Note I don't have one of these primarily because of this issue. Which seems obviously a design defect. Therefore there is zero chance of getting one with proper DVI functioning. I will be using both connectors, so not using DVI is not an option and I take photos and do photo editing.
If you do raise a report on this, could you indicate the problem also exists with the non wide 2007fp as well. I have read reports of the same issue and prevalence, this monitor just doesn't seem as popular as the wide version, but it is actually the one I want and would order if there were a resolution.
Well, seeing as Dell has not resolved the widely reported issue with backlights for 2005fpw in 3 versions of that monitor, I'd say it's very unlikely they will do anything about banding.
It's weird that they messed it up though, all that needed to be done was taking the 2005's insides, putting a better backlight in there, and updating the look. That's all; 2005 is a great monitor save for backlights. Why they messed with it I have no idea.
Too bad about the 2007s though, as a graphic designer that would be the worst possible thing to happen to my monitor. I'll definitely let everyone I know of this and tell them to stay away.
I'm glad I did a little surfing and found this thread. The Dell Ultrasharp 2007FPW was on my shortlist for displays. Not anymore. It looks like the Dell displays' reputation is better than the reality. What a disapointment! :smileysad:
The most annoying thing is that Dell are still selling the 2007WFP despite all units being affected.
I rang and asked if they could supply a 2007WFP that did not have the known banding issue and quoted a support ticket number. This absolutely blew their colective mind and I got shoved into an endless loop of salesperson, receptionist, sales person, receptionist.
Dell do a superb job of making sure that Joe Public is NOT ALLOWED to ask questions or speak to anyone outside of the "Place an order" or "Log a support ticket" and the result of this is that for genuinely tricky situations, their low budget phone people simply can't help and hand off the problem so fast it's not possible to get an answer.
If you want real support, DON'T get a Dell, dudes.
I would absolutely love to get a REAL email address or phone number of someone that can help, but I honestly think it will be simpler to return the monitor and just buy from a company with a sane support structure.
It's a shame, because their online support for the 90% of cases / questions is EXCELLENT... It's the few cases that require a brain and a real person to resolve that are proving impossible for Dell to deal with.
I am downunder in South Australia - after waiting 22 days I finally got my 2007WFP yesterday. NOT HAPPY! It looks like the images are displayed in 256 colors even though my video card is putting out 32 bit color! There's no such thing as a gradient on this puppy. Just horrible chunky blocks of color - is that what you guys mean by banding? I intially thought it was my computer - my video card is a bit old - so I took the monitor in to work. I have now tried it on four different PCs with various video cards - both analog and DVI and it's all the same. The only difference with analog is that in some places instead of a chunky color block I get pixels dancing around all over the place - a sort of shimmering effect. I've read other forums saying that the problem is worse in DVI than analog but onmine it's just as bad either way.
C'mon Mr DELL-ChrisM... what's going on & what do we do with our useless monitors?
bytor65
1 Rookie
•
211 Posts
966
0
Posted April 25th, 2006 13:00
Some additional data. This affects both the 4:3 2007fp and the 16:10 2007fpw/wfp wide version. It seems to be DVI problem. People who own the previous monitor and compare them, indicate this problem doesn't exist with the 2005fpw or the 2001fp. People who compare to any other LCD also find the problem worse on the 2007 series. Even 6 bit dithering panels work better.
Now if returns hit some magic number like 30%, Dell might perform an analysis on the reasons to see if something stands out. Now if banding is at the top of the list,they might actually check it. Then they might actually talk to the OEM who supplies the product, and then they might actually check it, and if the fix doesn't require a fundemental change and is cheap to repair, the next production run 6-12 months from now might be ok. IOW if, if, if, might, might, might...
It is not only returns that hurt them. It is people who read the reports on forums and realize there is a problem and just avoid these products (like me). Dell can't track this.
At least with backlight bleed, there seemed to be some chance of getting a good one, here it seems, all the DVI inputs are substandard. I think this is a must avoid.
Hopefully a real review site, takes a crack at a real retail monitor.