Gippsland

updated

18 years ago

Closed

G

Gippsland

22 Posts

0

166545

December 4th, 2008 23:00

XPS M1710 Video Failure and Temperature Monitoring

Hello All,

I recently had failure of Ge Force Go 7950 GTX in my XPS M1710 4 months out of warranty.  Fortunately I had bought the machine using American Express so was covered by Amex Buyer's Advantage insurance and had excellent service from Amex once I got a quote to fix from Dell.  I got 12 months' extended warranty and fix fom Dell.  The first fix attempt was to install a refurbished video card which overheated in seconds when running a game.  At second attempt Dell has replaced Video card, motherboard and fans and (fingers crossed) all appears OK so far.

I want to get the best possible out of this machine now so I would appreciate some advice about temperature monitoring software.  I believe heat is enemy #1 for laptops, particularly high performance ones and I want some visibility into what is going on.

I have found positive comments about i8kfanGUI but I am concerned it may void my warranty as it affects fan control.  Similarly I have concerns about RivaTuner.

For monitoring only software I have found HW Monitor 1.11 (not Pro) from CXPUID and Core Temp 0.99 which looks pretty basic and monitors core temperatures only.

Does anyone have advice about these or any other good alternatives?

Also, any comments about usefulness and effectiveness of laptop cooling mats?

  • TheRealFireblad

    4 Apprentice

    •

    4639 Posts

    1635

    1

    Posted December 5th, 2008 03:00

    HWMonitor and Core Temp are both very good programs, and probably the two best for the job.

    But CPU-Z and GPU-Z are another two you can use for (as their names suggest) the CPU and graphics card respectively.

    SpeedFan is another excellent program.  It can keep an eye on voltages, fan speeds and temperatures, and hard drive S.M.A.R.T info))

    And HDD Temperature FREE is a decent (S.M.A.R.T.-enabled) program for keeping an eye on your hard drive temperature :emotion-5:

  • Gippsland

    22 Posts

    1635

    1

    Posted December 8th, 2008 23:00

    Thanks TheRealFireblade. I have downloaded HWMonitor and it works fine.

    GeForce Go 7950 GTX runs up to 88 C max when gaming but sits at 70 - 74 when not.  I guess tis is pretty normal.  At least now I can keep an eye on it.

  • magedam

    183 Posts

    1635

    1

    Posted December 9th, 2008 12:00

    is 70 to 74C for the GPU temp  , a normal temp in idle ? i guess it should be something like 40 or 50 C

  • 1635

    1

    Posted January 9th, 2009 02:00

    Great and informative thread.

    That's a good point magedam, do any Dell reps on this forum know where we can find out the normal running temperatures of Hardware in Dell Systems?

    I'm going to try out the above mentioned software.

  • mcinturf

    26 Posts

    1623

    1

    Posted January 21st, 2009 06:00

    Actually i8kfanGUI can be ran to monitor without fan control. Not sure if this would void the warranty though. My M1710 is out warranty and I run this program only as a monitor. I think your temperatures seem normal to me. Just curious, what were your symptoms before your video card failed? I had a few instances lately where my screen would flash lines across it followed by a blue screen with barely readable words that I believe showed general hardware failure. I did a system restore to an earlier point and havent seen anything for a couple of days. Just curious if this is what happened to your 7950. I have the 7900GTX btw. Thanks.

  • TheRealFireblad

    4 Apprentice

    •

    4639 Posts

    1623

    0

    Posted January 21st, 2009 11:00

     

    is 70 to 74C for the GPU temp  , a normal temp in idle ?

     

    Yeah... mine normally sit at around 70°c as well :emotion-5:

     

     

     

    i guess it should be something like 40 or 50 C.

     

    They might be that low at idle in a desktop system, but due to room constraints, and the lack of airflow in a laptop, temps for most all the major components will always be quite a bit higher :emotion-5:

     

     

    [edit]  Ha!  Only just noticed now, that I'm a bit late - replying to a post which was put up about 6 weeks ago!

    It was the most recent post which made me think the one I replied to was a new one as well.  Duh!  [/edit]

  • Gippsland

    22 Posts

    1623

    0

    Posted January 23rd, 2009 00:00

    Yes, unfortunately that sounds  similar to the symptoms I had.   The crashes were intermittent at first but soon would happen every time the video card was worked hard.  Generally this was within a couple of minutes of starting Age of Empires III, for example.  I also had failure when running the video diagnostic from Dell Support Centre - would pass sometimes and fail others.  The usual pattern was equally spaced vertical "dashed" double white lines on a blue screen (tram tracks) followed by a blue screen message advising hardware failure.  Then it progressed to failure on Vista start up but I was able to start in Safe Mode.   While waiting for repair I was able to use the computer by disabling the video driver.

    I tried all the software fixes, system restores, updated drivers, bios etc. but none of this made any difference.

    Many people have had this type of problem with nVidia cards.  See below a press release from nVidia in July 2008! 

    http://www.nvidia.com/object/io_1215037160521.html?_tem

    This was followed in August by the below.  Check answer 2214 on the nVidia custhelp site:

    http://nvidia.custhelp.com/cgi-bin/nvidia.cfg/php/enduser/std_alp.php?p_sid=Og9n4Doj

    I also found the following which I am sure all readers will find very interesting!

    http://www.randomprocess.ca/2008/07/29/dell-acknowledges-nvidia-gpu-defect-with-fix/

    And it is not just Dell!

    http://www.electronista.com/articles/08/07/28/hp.laptops.with.nvidia/

  • 1623

    0

    Posted April 15th, 2009 11:00

    I also have an XPS M1710 and my nVidia GeForce 7950 GTX video card failed and the Dell Service Center replaced the video card one month ago (March 2009).  My laptop is still under warranty.

    Last night while running AutoCAD, the replacement video card failed (after one month of use) and Dell is sending out a service technician to replace it. 

    After reading quite a few posts, I'm concerned that simply replacing the video card once again will not stop this problem.  Other customers are reporting continued problems/replacements of the cards.  http://en.community.dell.com/forums/t/19243313.aspx

    Do you have any contact information at Dell from your recent experience that you can share.  While Dell is responding and sending someone out to get the computer up and running again, I do not have confidence another video card replacement will permanantly solve the issue and I don't want to be dealing with this situation after MY warranty expires. 

  • Gippsland

    22 Posts

    1623

    0

    Posted August 29th, 2009 20:00

    Unfortunately the saga continues.

    My XPS M1710 failed again in April.  This time Dell replaced the motherboard, which did not fix the problem, and then another "refurbished' graphics card.

    Now after 4 months the same failure has happened again (so that makes 4 graphics card failures so far).  Technical support has proposed another refurbished 7950 GTX but is telling me I will be not covered after the warranty runs out in 90 days.  So far they haven't been able to come up with a graphics card to install!   I suspect that there will be no fix for this machine as the ability to refurbish these cards must be coming to an end!

    I am hoping that Dell will do the right thing and negotiate a fair replacement machine considering the age of my XPS and the considerable inconvenience i have suffered.

  • Gippsland

    22 Posts

    839

    0

    Posted September 6th, 2009 02:00

    Dell has now advised that nVidia has admitted the cards are faulty. The fix for my machine will be a new 9850 GPU configured to fit the XPS m1710.  However I have to wait at least 4 weeks as there is a "global shortage" (not surprisingly).  Hopefully I get a machine which will now perform as it always should have for more than 4 months.