UNSOLVED

sandersconsulti

updated

19 years ago

Closed

0

11323

March 10th, 2008 08:00

Sudden shutdown of XPS M1530

About 2 hours ago, I was playing Unreal Tournament on my XPS M1530, when suddenly I heard snap from the headphones and saw the screen instantly go black, right in the middle of a game - total, unexpected, instantaneous shutdown.   The battery was fully charged and AC adapter plugged in when this happened. No other devices experienced any power fluctuations. There were no warnings. The game was running uninterrupted up until the moment of shutdown.

Does this sound like a Vista problem, or a Dell hardware problem?  If it's Vista, then  I'll toss it on the ever-growing pile of Vista annoyances.  If it's the XPS, then I'm worried.

I have had Vista grab control and reboot *in the middle of a business meeting* recently (without warning), so this wouldn't be unprecedented.  BTW: Is there any way that Vista could be more annoying?  I don't think so.
  • scorntoro

    2 Posts

    224

    0

    Posted March 10th, 2008 23:00

    Hi Sanders. This could be a hardware issue. My 1710 did the same thing.

    A big question here is, is the computer hot in the top right quadrant? near the keyboard?

    There is three reasons for this.

    1. Your heatsink is full of crud from placing your computer on soft surfaces or by smoking around your computer (if neither of these, ignore this suggestion)

    2. The hard drive has failed. Start up the computer using the FN+power button to start the computer up. It might take a while, but it will start up the system in diagnostics mode. Find out if the hard drive fails and if it does, report it to dell. You will be able to tell if your computer fails because it starts high pitch beeping at you.

    3. The motherboard has failed and needs to be replaced. This is usually indicated by high temperatures in the upper rright hand quadrent near the keyboard. Dell will want to ensure the above has been checked first and before they will consider this an issue. They will even want to replace your heatsinks and fans first, then have you replace the hard drive before they will replace the motherboard.

    I had my new motherboard in my computer for about 11 hours before it failed again. When I called up dell again, there was no question about replacing my computer.

    Hope this helps.
  • 224

    0

    Posted March 11th, 2008 01:00


    @scorntoro wrote:
    Hi Sanders. This could be a hardware issue. My 1710 did the same thing.
    Uh oh.  That's what I was afraid of.

    This sudden shutdown I'm reporting was exactly like the sudden shutdowns I had with my Apple MacBook.  That turned out to be a bad motherboard (logic board), which required factory replacement by Apple.
    A big question here is, is the computer hot in the top right quadrant? near the keyboard?
    Pretty warm; but not obviously so. I've run CPU fan monitoring diagnostics, and never saw anything unusual.
    2. The hard drive has failed.
    Hard drive was upgraded.  Tests show it's fine.
    3. The motherboard has failed and needs to be replaced. This is usually indicated by high temperatures in the upper rright hand quadrent near the keyboard. Dell will want to ensure the above has been checked first and before they will consider this an issue. They will even want to replace your heatsinks and fans first, then have you replace the hard drive before they will replace the motherboard.
    This does not sound good.  Intermittent problems are notoriously difficult to reproduce and to troubleshoot.  I'd rather it just fried itself than to limp along, crashing every so often. (I'm sure Dell technicians agree.)

    I've grown accustomed to the bombproof reliability of 3 Dell laptops in a row (Inspiron 600m, Inspiron 6000, Inspiron E1505) that I assumed that by purchasing a high end Dell XPS,  I wouldn't have to go through this kind of thing. 
    I had my new motherboard in my computer for about 11 hours before it failed again. When I called up dell again, there was no question about replacing my computer.
    Chalk one up for Dell.  That sounds like a happy ending (as long as the replacement XPS works reliably).
    Hope this helps.
    Yes, thank you.  Extremely helpful.


  • 224

    0

    Posted March 23rd, 2008 11:00

    I think it might be that one of the brackets on your heatsink has broken off. I have no idea how but it just happened to me.
    Message Edited by bmheffernan on 03-23-2008 07:36 AM