
UNSOLVED
Closed
H
hairbandfan80s
11 Posts
0
33266
June 8th, 2006 22:00
Inspiron E1750/9400 2.0 GHz T2500 vs. P4-3.0 GHz?
I'm considering a laptop purchase and am curious about the new processors. This will be my first laptop purchase. My current desktop is a P4 3.0 GHz with 1GB of RAM and a 256 MB nvidia 6800GT graphics card. I'm planning to purchase an Inspiron E1750/9400 with the 2.0 GHz T2500 Duo processor, 1Gb of 566 MHz RAM and the 256 Mb nvidia 7800 Go graphics card.
I'm curious how these two systems might compare for general computing and for gaming. I have no knowledge of these new mobile processors and therefore have nothing to base it on. Has anyone out there done any comparisons along these lines or have any information on the subject?
Any information would be greatly appreciated. Thanks in advance for any help.
Sincerely,
- Byron Followell
I'm curious how these two systems might compare for general computing and for gaming. I have no knowledge of these new mobile processors and therefore have nothing to base it on. Has anyone out there done any comparisons along these lines or have any information on the subject?
Any information would be greatly appreciated. Thanks in advance for any help.
Sincerely,
- Byron Followell
Responses (9)
Solutions (0)
tigerwolf7
2 Intern
•
3906 Posts
720
0
Posted June 9th, 2006 16:00
A 2GHz Core Duo is considerably more powerful than a Pentium 4 at 3GHz.
A 2GHz Penium M was roughly equivalent to a 3.4-3.6GHz Pentium 4, depending on the game, and Core is faster at the same clock speed (even ignoring the second CPU).
Also that's completly bogus about Oblivion not supporting two CPUs. In fact it's one of the few games so far (the other big one being Quake IV) that DOES support multiple CPUs. The overall performance boost was between 10-30%, so very significant. Writing games to be multithreaded so they can benefit from multiple CPUs is tricky, but we'll be seeing more and more of it, as dual CPUs are now the norm (the first quad core CPUs are coming out in January), plus as games increasingly use physics engines that can potentially be spun off on a seperate CPU, etc.
The one thing I'd upgrade is go to the Geforce 7900GS. It's a BIG step up from the mobile 7800 and well worth the money (the mobile 7800 may be slower than the 6800GT you have now, I'd have to look up specs to remember for sure). The 7900GS would be an upgrade from the 6800GT, and a 2GHz Core Duo is a significant upgrade from a 3GHz Pentium 4.Message Edited by tigerwolf7 on 06-09-200612:44 PM
- Well, if anyone is interested, I contacted the good folks at Bethesda Softworks, makers of "Oblivion" which requires a minimum Pentium 4 at 2.0Ghz... They said that, indeed, the dual core at 1.66 Ghz will not work well because the game is designed for one chip. So, your proposed T2500 would be okay at 2.0 Ghz, but I'm thinking what good is a dual core processor on all these games? It looks like Intel is making this chip but no one has built anything for it yet... I'd rather have a strong pentium above 3 Ghz than what the E1705 offers.Anyone else looked into this? Any serious gamers out there who have played on the current version of the E1705?Chopin
@chopin wrote:
Well, if anyone is interested, I contacted the good folks at Bethesda Softworks, makers of "Oblivion" which requires a minimum Pentium 4 at 2.0Ghz... They said that, indeed, the dual core at 1.66 Ghz will not work well because the game is designed for one chip. So, your proposed T2500 would be okay at 2.0 Ghz, but I'm thinking what good is a dual core processor on all these games? It looks like Intel is making this chip but no one has built anything for it yet... I'd rather have a strong pentium above 3 Ghz than what the E1705 offers.Anyone else looked into this? Any serious gamers out there who have played on the current version of the E1705?Chopin
It is true that the majority of applications do not take full advantage of dual core CPUs so far. That said, it's a chicken-and-egg problem, and now that SMP systems have gone from incredibly rare to incredibly common, we'll be seeing (and already are seeing) lots of SMP-aware consumer applications, whereas only high-end professional applications used to be SMP-aware.
i.e. the second core on the Core Duo will only provide you a small improvement in performance with today's games and media applications, but it provides lots of growth headroom for the next generation of games.
That said, regarding the performance of a single core, a single core of the T2500 at 2.0 GHz will eat a P4-3.0 for lunch.
Of course, in the case of a Dell factory preinstall of Windows, you'll need that second core just for the junk they've given you until you nuke and repave Windows.tigerwolf7
2 Intern
•
3906 Posts
720
0
Posted June 9th, 2006 21:00
LOL! They should market it that way. "You need the second core to run all the preinstalled junk! And be sure to get an extra 512MB too!"
Oh, and another nice thing with dual cores-you can run two copies of something like Folding @ Home (so that you're getting twice as much work done as they run independently).
http://folding.stanford.edu
It's research into "protein folding"-should help with all kinds of diseases, from cancer to alshymers (sorry I can't spell).
My last several computers I've literally bought more CPU than I needed just with the thought that I'd be crunching Folding @ Home data faster :) (Papers have already been published from results found-so it seems to be making progress!)Message Edited by tigerwolf7 on 06-09-200605:14 PM
- But realize a dual core or Pentium M in a notebook may not top even an older Pentium 4 in a desktop because desktops have much faster ram and hard drives (800 mhz - 1200 mhz) was common for many years while notebooks are still around 500-667 mhz now.
And gaming on a widescreen notebook can be a huge no no for older games.Message Edited by sblive on 06-09-200611:40 PM
tigerwolf7
2 Intern
•
3906 Posts
720
0
Posted June 12th, 2006 13:00
Laptops have had basically the same speed RAM as desktops for years...I can't remember the last time they were different.
Hard drives are faster, but that dosen't matter much once a game's loaded.- When I bought my desktop 3 years ago, it came with 1200 mhz ram. Today's laptop ram tops out at 667 mhz if I'm not mistaken. And the graphics cards for laptops are no comparision to desktop graphics cards.
And hard drives do matter when games are loaded because very few pc's have enough ram to house the entire game and maps. tigerwolf7
2 Intern
•
3906 Posts
720
0
Posted June 12th, 2006 22:00
When I bought my desktop 3 years ago, it came with 1200 mhz ram. Today's laptop ram tops out at 667 mhz if I'm not mistaken.The fastest laptop RAM is 667Mhz...which is exactly the same as the fastest RAM in desktops. (Most desktops ship with 400 or 533MHz RAM now, actually, certainlly not 1200MHz!) They've had parity like that for years.And the graphics cards for laptops are no comparision to desktop graphics cards.Yes they compare. They cost more, but you can get basically the same class of GPUs in laptops as desktops.And hard drives do matter when games are loaded because very few pc's have enough ram to house the entire game and maps.Only matters for loading levels-and it's been shown there's very little difference between extremly high-end hard drive solutions and low end ones for game loading. You shave off a few seconds here or there, but it's not going to make a big difference.Message Edited by tigerwolf7 on 06-12-200606:57 PM

chopin
22 Posts
720
0
Posted June 9th, 2006 00:00
Hi Byron,
Forgive me, but I'm with you. That is, I have the same basic questions, and I want to buy an E1705 also. I have heard completely contradictory answers about this depending on whom I ask. I.e., some at Dell have told me that the T2300 duo-core processor at 1.66 Ghz is not as fast as a Pentium 4 at 2.0 Ghz, and thus will not run any games that require a pentium 2.0 or better. Others at Dell say the 1.66Ghz is plenty fast. A guy at Circuit City said that the duo core Centrino processors leave Pentium 4 in the dust and essentially double the Ghz power... or put another way, he said a 1.0 Ghz duo core outshines a pentium 2.0.
I'm going to see if some of the game manufacturers have any info/advice on this, and I'll repost if I learn anything pertinent.
Take care,
Chopin
Message Edited by chopin on 06-09-200611:56 AM