UNSOLVED

galvgil

updated

20 years ago

G

galvgil

29 Posts

0

28554

October 6th, 2006 04:00

What is the beefiest Video card a 8200 with a stock PSU can handle?

I have researched this Customer list of possible video card upgrades  here:http://forums.us.dell.com/supportforums/board/message?board.id=dim_video&message.id=142118
 
 
what is not stated if the PSU are stock or not.  I read how the stock 250W  PSU  (Dimension 8200) is under rated but by how much?  I have a budjet so a upgrade PSU leaves very little left for a decent card.  Thanks in advance.
  • plguzman

    12 Posts

    662

    0

    Posted October 6th, 2006 05:00

    Technically, it can support any AGP card. I converted my 8200 into a 8300 (keeping the old PSU) and I had a 6800 OC that worked like a charm. Now I have a X800XT. Realistically, you can't go very far, because your MOBO is AGP 4X, and your RAM is not so fast, as your processor, and you will have a huge bottleneck if you get a "beefy" card. I suggest a X1600PRO or a GeForce 6600 as the most powerful cards to consider. You can find both cards at Newegg for about $100.

    Cheers!
  • galvgil

    29 Posts

    662

    0

    Posted October 6th, 2006 13:00

    Thanks for the quick reply.  I bought a 1300 which didn't work and I found out thru researching that series has issues with Dell computers so I wanted to check here first.  The card I was interested in was the nVidia 7600GS 512mb which has a power requirement of 350W (as does most mid-range cards).  From your post.......the issue will be that of bottle-necking rather than power....right?  I upgraded my CPU to the fastest the mobo will allow and I can up the RAM (be it very expensive) but I was hoping that the card would give me the (quickest) cheapest boost I want for gaming.
  • plguzman

    12 Posts

    662

    0

    Posted October 6th, 2006 21:00

    Why the 1300 didn't work?. It should, the thing is that is a very basic card that won't allow you to play almost no games at all (at least decently, what I think you are trying to do). The bottleneck will happen with the CPU, only IF you get a very powerful card. Your PSU is enough to handle a new low-mid level card.

    I know that RAM issue. I morphed the 8200 into a 8300 precisely because of the RAM. I got a MOBO, Processor and RAM PC3200 for about the same money than 512Mb RDRAM (almost 2 years ago). But yeah, you need to increase your RAM to at least 1Gb. 768Mb is not enough for gaming.

    By the way, in my first post I didn't noticed you have a 9800 Pro. That's a great card, old, but good. Now I think a 1600Pro or a 6600 won't give you a notable boost in raw power. I think you may consider a 7600GS as you said. In terms of power the card will work fine. I just would check (if I were you) if the P4 2.4 will accept the card without choking.

    Cheers!
  • speedstep

    11 Legend

    •

    46969 Posts

    662

    0

    Posted October 6th, 2006 22:00

    The 6800 GT OC from BFG works fine

    The 7800 series REQUIRES a 500 watt power supply from
    a real vendor. Not one that uses a marker to say 500 watts on the outside
    with a 150 watt psu on the inside.
  • galvgil

    29 Posts

    662

    0

    Posted October 6th, 2006 23:00

    Thanks to plguzman and SpeedStep for your quick and informative replies.
     
    @plguzman
     
    The 1300 would not even allow my rig to boot up......just a blank screen.  I searched here and googled and checked with Dell support as well as ATI and both said there was a issue with the 1300 and some Dell computers and they are working on the problem......though 1 user emailed me and said he installed his with NO issues. http://www.tek-tips.com/viewthread.cfm?qid=1246308&page=3 
     
    I will try to find  a 7600GS in my price range.
     
    @SpeedStep
     
    I'll look into the 6800GT.  Any idea how in compares to the 7600GS?

    Message Edited by galvgil on 10-06-2006 07:35 PM

  • plguzman

    12 Posts

    662

    0

    Posted October 7th, 2006 00:00

    The 6800GT is a little bit more powerful than the 7600GS in some situations, but IMHO will be overkill for your system. The 7600GS is cheaper, cooler (uses less power and is not so hot) and a better card for your system. You can find a nice 7600GS for around $130-140.
  • treyzaphod

    114 Posts

    662

    0

    Posted October 7th, 2006 02:00

    I have an 8300 with a similar, if not identical power PSU. I've been running a BFG 7800GS OC for 4 months and haven't had any problems. This is in addition to 2 SATA drives, and an Audigy sound card. To my knowledge, the 7800 is the most powerful AGP card available.
  • galvgil

    29 Posts

    662

    0

    Posted October 7th, 2006 13:00



    plguzman wrote:


    I know that RAM issue. I morphed the 8200 into a 8300 precisely because of the RAM. I got a MOBO, Processor and RAM PC3200 for about the same money than 512Mb RDRAM (almost 2 years ago). But yeah, you need to increase your RAM to at least 1Gb. 768Mb is not enough for gaming.


    Cheers!

    Can you post the particulars of that morph......ie. part #s and prices?  thanks
  • plguzman

    12 Posts

    662

    0

    Posted October 7th, 2006 15:00

    Can't remember well, but I got a 8300 Motherboard - that part I remember the price, $49.99 shipped :-) - , then 1Gb PC3200 CL3 (around $100 I guess). In the first time I used my P4 2.4 in that motherboard, and ran well, but the RAM didn't run at 400Mhz (the bus in the P4 2.4 is different). Also I got the video card (at the time a BFG 6800 OC). After (about 3 months later) I decided to get a Prescott 3.2Ghz (my actual CPU). But basically for $150 I replaced the MOBO and RAM, got a PC working, and got a AGP 8X, and more room to upgrade.

    My BFG died a couple weeks ago after 2 years, so I got a AIW X800XT to replace it (they are under $200 now, a very sweet price for a VERY powerful card), and that's my last upgrade (oh, I got another HD lol). I will wait until the quad processors appear to move to my next DELL.

    Cheers.
  • thatsme

    270 Posts

    346

    0

    Posted October 7th, 2006 17:00

    A regular 7800GS with stock clock speeds of 375-1200MHz will run fine with the stock power supply in a 8200. I ran mine for 2 months before getting a new PSU. Mine came overclocked from eVGA at 460-1350mhz and I run it at 490-1450 24/7. If it wasn't for that, I wouldn't have upgraded the PSU.
     
    My highest 3Dmark 06 score running at 500-1500MHz on the 7800GS was with the stock PSU. I got the same identical score after installing my new PSU.
     
    Going from a vanilla 6800 unlocked and overclocked at 350-790MHz to this, made a big difference for me. Being able to run games at 1280 x 1024 with AA turned on is awesome.
     
    I have the fastest 3DM 06 score for an approximate CPU speed of 3.06GHz and a 7800GS, "with the stock PSU".
     

    Message Edited by thatsme on 10-07-2006 02:51 PM