UNSOLVED

Serpentor100

updated

24 years ago

0

36000

July 19th, 2002 02:00

WARNING ABOUT THE 8200!

The 8200 features RDRam which Dell's claims is the most advanced. Yes, it does have much higher clock speeds than DDR SDRam. However, no motherboard available can support clock speeds this fast making it meaningless. In fact, RDRam transmits data SLOWER than DDR SDRam. While it is in fact useful for video editing, more common computer functions such as games are much more suited by the DDR Ram. Rambus, the company that makes RDRam is going out of business and Dell knows -- please notice the suspiciously lower price of the "cutting edge" 8200 with RDRam compared to the lower end 4200 with DDR ram. I did not discover these things until after I recently got my 8200. I just wanted to issue a warning to others who might fall for Dell's trap.

-John

  • shesagordie

    12 Elder

    •

    46017 Posts

    266

    0

    Posted July 19th, 2002 03:00



    Hi,

    This is an intresting article from the Inquirer about the subject.

    http://www.theinquirer.net/?article=3004

    Bev.



  • Charger_R-T

    1 Rookie

    •

    116 Posts

    266

    0

    Posted July 19th, 2002 03:00

    I didn't know the 4200 was out! I thought it was just the 2200, 4500(s), and the 8200!

    You just talked me out of an 8200! I'm getting a 4500 if I get anything...

    Charger





    Helping people with their computer problems is a favorite hobby of mine. If you need some help, I'd be more than happy to help you!
    Click Here To Send Me An Email!!


    <><><><><><><><><><><><>
    Dell Dimension V350 Powered By:

    Intel Pentium II Processor @ 350MHZ
    128 Mb SDRAM
    17" Dell D1028L Monitor
    Mad Dog Performer 16 PCI Video Card
    IBM Active Responce Keyboard (Black)
    8.4Gig Maxtor Hard Drive
    Iomega ZIP 100Mb
    Backpack 4X Cd-Rw
    <><><><><><><><>

    I do not work for Dell Computer Corporation or Microsoft. Windows XP logo copyrighted by Microsoft Corporation. All rights reserved. Microsoft Corporation is a trademark or registered trademark of Microsoft Corporation in the U.S. and/or other countries. All rights reserved. All other trademarks are the property of their respective owners.
  • pkeyrich

    81 Posts

    266

    0

    Posted July 19th, 2002 03:00

    Check out Intel's announcement on the first article (with the 2002/7/18 date).

    http://cedar.intel.com/cgi-bin/ids.dll/content/content.jsp?cntKey=Generic%20Editorial::pentium4_binstock_ddr&cntType=IDS_EDITORIAL&catCode=0

    "In early 2002, Intel announced that its Intel® 845 chipset would support double data-rate (DDR) RAM, a high-speed memory architecture that enjoys increasingly wide deployment. While many analysts attributed political motives to the timing of this announcement, it is clear that Intel made a good move in accepting DDR. Currently, Intel supports synchronous DRAM, DDR, and Rambus DRAM."

    Also, here are Dell's own comments regarding memory:

    http://www.dell.com/us/en/gen/topics/vectors_2001-memory.htm

    "In workstations, Rambus has distinct performance advantages over current SDRAM and DDR implementations due to its higher actual bandwidth and the ability of the memory hub to exploit that bandwidth. It will remain the preferred technology in this market until newer technology implementations match its performance."

    "Rambus has plans for a new high-speed memory interface called Yellowstone. This next-generation interface is intended to provide 3.2 Gb/sec per differential signal pair between DRAM components and the memory interface. A 200-millivolt differential signal is planned to support this data rate. The Yellowstone is expected to be within mainstream PC memory cost budgets."

    My Technical Support web page has some good links for Dell support.
    Click one of the following links:

    Phil's Technical Support Page at Geocities.com

    Phil's Technical Support Page at MyExcel.com

    Phil's Technical Support Page at JPS.net

    Message Edited on 07/18/02 10:01PM by pkeyrich

    Message Edited on 07/18/02 10:02PM by pkeyrich

    Message Edited on 07/18/02 10:05PM by pkeyrich

    Message Edited on 07/18/02 10:07PM by pkeyrich

    Message Edited on 07/18/02 10:09PM by pkeyrich
  • Marvin P

    1322 Posts

    269

    0

    Posted July 19th, 2002 04:00

    I posted this news on 2/28/02 ,

    http://delltalk.us.dell.com:81/default.asp?qu=Intel+to+Dump+RDRam&submit=search

    Marvin P

    XPS B800r
    512MB Ram
    Windows XP (2/1/02)
    &
    8200 1.8G
    512MB Ram
    XP
    &
    Truck Vanity Plate "Dell4Me" (Maine)
  • -Friendlyname-

    2 Intern

    •

    858 Posts

    266

    0

    Posted July 19th, 2002 04:00

    Hi, I had more links to show you, but its late and I can't get them all together. It seems that according to PC World that RDRAM has its advantages, and the 8200 won two Prizes in July.


    http://www.dell.com/us/en/bsd/products/model_dimen_dimen_8200.htm

    Get back to you tomorrow, there are probably better sources.
    Jane



    Message Edited on 07/19/02 01:08AM by -Friendlyname-
  • Marvin P

    1322 Posts

    269

    0

    Posted July 19th, 2002 04:00

    nt = No Text

    XPS B800r 512MB Ram Windows XP (2/1/02) & 8200 1.8G 512MB Ram XP & Truck Vanity Plate "Dell4Me" (Maine)
  • 266

    0

    Posted July 19th, 2002 04:00

    I apologize for the typo.. I meant 4500.

  • 266

    0

    Posted July 19th, 2002 04:00

    From the research I've done it seems most of the advantages of RDRam are mostly for those who are doing heavy video editing... correct me if I'm wrong.

  • pkeyrich

    81 Posts

    269

    0

    Posted July 19th, 2002 04:00


    Please note that Intel, Dell, RAMBUS, and others have NOT announce the discontinuation of RDRAM in favor of DDR. Intel's own web site tells that they are supporting BOTH, depending on the performance platform.

    The new RDRAM, demonstrated:
    http://www.rambus.com/company/press/newsletters/NewsletterMarApril2002.pdf

    Tom's Hardware comments:
    http://www.rdram.com/performance/performance_reviews.html#THG_1066" target=_blank>http://www.rdram.com/performance/performance_reviews.html#THG_1066

    The new RDRAM, reviewed:
    http://www.rdram.com/performance/performance_reviews.html#THG_1066


  • JOKERSWILD

    2 Intern

    •

    1448 Posts

    572

    0

    Posted July 19th, 2002 10:00

    3dmark2001 scores with rdram are higher than ddr. ddr overclocks better than rdram though.Dell isn't the only system with rdram rd1066 is out now and alienware and other high end machines all use it .Just because dell might quit it doesn't make it obsolete.

    2.26ghz
    533mhz fsb
    512meg rdram
    ti4600 video
    lite-on 24-10-40 cdrw
    19inch viewsonic a90
    maxtor 80 gig 7200 rpm hdd
    logictech optical wheel mouse

    466mhz
    256mb pc100 ram
    nvidia 64meg mx/mx400 pci video card
    19inch dell monitor
    8-4-32 cdrw