UNSOLVED

bc_acadia

updated

20 years ago

B

bc_acadia

38 Posts

0

5365

April 28th, 2007 07:00

The 4600 power supply issue

I purchased my wife a 4600 in August 2004. This past week I read the article that listed the 4600 as "one of the 10 worst pcs" ever built because of the faulty power supplies that affected thousands of customers.

My question: When, if ever, did Dell stop making 4600s with the faulty power supplies? Did they fix the problem the start making 4600s with good power supplies?

I see that most systems effected were from late 2003 into 2004 and I'm hoping that we may have dodged a bullet and purchased a system after the problem was fixed. But was it ever fixed?

So far her system has worked perfectly but now we hold our breath every time that we turn it on.

Thank you very much.

Acadia
  • Lenny_eh

    181 Posts

    242

    0

    Posted April 28th, 2007 12:00

    I purchased a 4600 in january 2004 and had no problems with the power supply but a couple of weeks ago I had an issue with the video card fan not running. When Dell sent a technician out to fix it Dell sent a new video card, mother board,USB ports and a power supply. When I asked the technician why the power supply he said that there was issues with them and he says a lot of times Dell replaces them. He checked out the old one and told me it was in good shape but replaced it anyways since Dell sent it out.
  • kdmphx

    322 Posts

    242

    0

    Posted April 28th, 2007 14:00

    bc_acadia,
     
    I got my 4600 in Sept 2004. Eleven months later it became hard to "power on". I had to press the front power button multiple times to get it to turn on. It was getting worse and luckily I was under warranty when I called Dell. After much arm twisting and escalating the issue, they decided I did have a problem and they replaced the PSU and motherboard. They told me the problem was "either" the PSU or motherboard and it was easier for them to replace both at one time rather than come out twice. In hindsight, I can probably guess it was the PSU. I read the same article you did and you might notice they say they erroneously misdiagnosed a lot of the problems as being a bad mobo.
     
    I also have a 4400 with the same 250W PSU that I got in June 2003. No problems with that one to date. Chances are, if yours is still working, it will continue to do so. In any case, you are lucky that the 4600 can accept any standard 20/20+4 pin ATX PSU. The cutout in the rear will accept one with an on/off switch (the 4400 and others can't without some minor surgery!)
     
    That being said, of course anything electrical can fail at any time. But as I said, you can replace it easily if that day arrives when you find it won't turn on. Keep this one in mind. Others have used it and it will probably last longer than the rest of the machine!
     
     
    Good luck...
     
    Ken
  • bc_acadia

    38 Posts

    242

    0

    Posted April 28th, 2007 15:00

    Ken, thank you for that link. I have bookmarked it!

    Acadia
  • shesagordie

    12 Elder

    •

    46017 Posts

    242

    0

    Posted April 28th, 2007 19:00

    bc_acadia

    If you ever need to replace the D-4600 power supply, because this system has an open back, you can use most standard generic ATX PSUs, with or without the on/off power switch and with either a 20-pin or 20+4-pin main motherboard connector.

    Bev.





    ===================================================
    Please don't send me questions about your system by DCF Messenger.
    Post the issue in the appropriate Board, where they will be answered.
  • Cypherus

    2 Intern

    •

    336 Posts

    242

    0

    Posted April 29th, 2007 03:00

    I purchased my 4600 back in March 2004, and I have had no problems running my nVidia Geforce 6800 off the power unit for 1.5 years. In any case, I just purchased a new Ultra X-Connect 500 Watt PSU, a standard ATX PSU, this weekend to upgrade to a X1950 Pro AGP.
  • Jerrybarr

    14 Posts

    242

    0

    Posted April 29th, 2007 23:00

    I bought the Thermaltake 430 watt powersupply for my 4600 about a month ago after my dell psu failed.  It's been fine.  That's a great price at Newegg.