UNSOLVED

ts777

updated

22 years ago

T

ts777

2 Posts

0

6277

January 17th, 2005 18:00

Looking for a definitive answer for a decent video card for the dim 4700

ive read the poll, but it seems that everyone who answered had some kind of problem, with any decent card.(though it says 6600-6800 & x800 work for the 4700, it also groups the 8X00, & the xps in there too)
Is there anyone who has no compatibility problems with thier 4700 & thier card? I picked up a x700, and anyone whose read anything knows that there isnt any compatability.
Should I expect the new video cards coming out to have problems?? Will Dell solve the current problems with current cards ?? Im debating wether or not to return the 4700 I just got & just build a new comp from scratch. Thanks.
  • CastleBravo

    299 Posts

    402

    0

    Posted January 18th, 2005 14:00

    Well, provided you know what you are doing, building your computer will give you a better system than what Dell is willing to deliver.  Like all the mass producers of PCs, they cut alot of corners.  And it isn't like you are going to miss "customer service" that involve a phone call routed to Apu in India...
     
    To tell you the truth, though, as long as you get a card that will fit in the graphics card slot of the 4700, you should be fine.  Most problems with installing graphics cards are a result of operator error/ignorance, not hardware issues.  Follow the FAQs posted here and you should be just fine.
  • rajuncajun

    12 Posts

    402

    0

    Posted January 19th, 2005 16:00

    I purchased a new 4700 last month with onboard video, knowing I was going to upgrade. I too read all the horror stories related to adding a PCIe card to the PC. But for the money (with free 17" LCD) the deal was too good.

    There seems to be problems with ATI X700 for some people, but others get it to work fine. Even after reading all the problems with Nvidia 6600GT cards, I ordered and installed a new Leadtek 6600GT. Unfortunately, the first card was faulty, so I rma'd and obtained a second one, which runs perfectly!

    However, after reading several posts here, I added a PCI dual cooling fan to blow air onto the video card while installing the 2nd 6600GT. It seems there is a possible air flow problem in the 4700 - more to the point a lack of circulation. My adjustable fan blows moocho air (and looks cool with blue LEDs glowing in the case through the side panel ventilation grid), and the card runs very cool.

    I prefer Nvidia, so I would recommend a 6600/6600GT, depending upon how much gaming you do. !WARNING! Some card companies do not secure the cooling system on 6600GT, leading to heat issues (I think this was the problem with my 1st card). There is suppose to be a second revision of the card out, but I don't know how to tell.

    Just be VERY CAREFUL not to bump the cooling fan on ANY card you buy - they are precariously balanced on top of the GPU with only 2 supports. Any bump might cause the GPU to tilt and break the cooling compound seal, causing the card to run hotter than normal.

    Hope this helps!
  • CastleBravo

    299 Posts

    402

    0

    Posted January 19th, 2005 17:00

    Mass-produced computers (not just Dell) tend to have very bad cooling/ventilation.  This becomes more of a problem as you add faster processors and graphics cards, which generate more heat.
  • 402

    0

    Posted January 19th, 2005 21:00

    The main problem with air circulation (or lack thereof) on the 4700 is that the rear vent fan is taking the hot air off the processor heat sink, and not out of the entire case.  You've all seen the green tunnel leading to the back vent of the case.

    That leaves the rest of the hot air in the case, with only the Power Supply fans to try and draw the air out.

  • 402

    0

    Posted January 19th, 2005 21:00

    Rajun, what brand(s) of 6600gt did you get?
  • rajuncajun

    12 Posts

    402

    0

    Posted January 20th, 2005 16:00

    As I stated in my previous post, I purchased a Leadtek 6600GT (not the overclocked version). Why? Well they've been making good cards for many years. Let's face it, all the cards will be based on Nvidia Reference, so pick the one that's cheaper/has better bundle/you like company A vs B/etc).

    The one I bought came with the HDTV outputs, DVI to VGA converter, Splinter Cell Pandora, Prince of Persia, and DOOM 3. It was retail and I paid $193 shipped.

    Runs HL2, Far Cry, Doom3, and everything I can throw at it great. I'm limited to max 1280x1024 on my LCD, so I can just crank up AA and AF filtering and still get high FPSs. Card runs about 34C at 2d idle, and even after long gaming only gets up to about 62C.

    Anandtech's review of 11 6600GT cards awhile back showed the Leadtek had one of the better cooling solutions and it overclocked well. I've not overclocked mine yet, but once it's well broken in I'll bump up the speeds to see what I can get out of it.

    The price of this particular card (with Doom3) seems to vary up and down. At the time Newegg had the same card for $209 + shipping. Bought mine at www.buyxg.com. Was somewhat hesitant about ordering from there with thier reseller ratings, but I got very good service, even with the RMA.