
UNSOLVED
C
chinaatdel
8 Posts
0
23630
April 6th, 2004 23:00
Issue identified with Dimension 8300 Media Center Edition with ATI AIW 9000 Video Capture - problems with Audio
This is really an audio problem but it is specifically related to the video capture capability. All other functions of the system are functioning as expected, however Dell technical support appears to be completely unaware of the issue.
System: Dell 8300 with MS-Windows XP Media Center Edition P-4 3Ghz with the ATI AIW 9000 (with the Sound Blaster Live 5.1 digital - but that is actually unimportant as it is not related to the problem).Problem #1 - With MS-Movie Maker the audio capture device correctly identifies the ATI Rage Theatre as the audio input device, displays audio levels (so I know the audio is being detected correctly) but upon initialization provides the error message "device in use". If I select the Sound Card, MS-Movie Maker functions correctly but without any sound capture. In order to capture the audio I am required to disconnect the stereo audio connections from the ATI AIW 9000 and (through a "Y") connect to the Sound Blaster "IN" in order to record.
Problem #2 (Which Sonic advises is not a problem but is standard with this configuration of Dell) - Using My-DVD video capture I am able to record both audio and video through the ATI AIW 9000, however My-DVD's audio input is deactivated and there is no audio playback when performing the video capture, though the audio is captured and is present upon playback.
When I discussed the situation with Dell technical support (3 occasions), they insisted on re-installing the Sound Blaster device drivers and provided me with a support number at Roxio to obtain support. Roxio was not impressed because My-DVD is actually sold by Sonic. I did contact Sonic, and they initially felt the responses to problem #2 were unusual. I was told that I should be hearing audio during video capture and that I should be able to select either my sound card or my video capture card for audio input; however after verifying my Dell configuration they finally confirmed that the Problem #2 described above is actually not a problem but is functioning as expected. This must be a special configuration for Dell because their documentation doesn't reflect this.
Back to problem # 1; it seems that I am not alone. I have encounter another support group where other Dell 8300 customers are encountering the same problem with MS-Windows Movie Maker.
http://forums.us.dell.com/supportforums/board/message?board.id=si_digvideo&message.id=2812
This again is a totally unknown issue as far as Dell technical support is concerned. When I tried addressing with them that the issue may actually pertain to the ATI card, they provided the helpful advise that I may contact ATI and use the technical support service which does charge by the minute for support. I did visit the ATI site and the particular version of the ATI AIW 9000 which is installed in the Dimension 8300 Win XP MCE is actually manufactured specifically for Dell, and they do not provide documentation or "free" support for the product. They referred me back to Dell.
Anyway - no solution to the problem, however I will be sending a registered letter to both ATI and to Dell confirming my disappointment in how the current problem has been addressed. Seeing as these two companies did collaborate in the product, I do feel that support would be the very least expected. I am anticipating that should I upgrade my system to another video capture software product I would have related problems as this definitely strikes me as an issue of compatability between the Dell version of the ATI AIW 9000 and the Dimension 8300 with Win XP MCE.
Oh, by the way, I did receive a follow-up survey from Dell to determine my level of satisfaction with the technical support service. While being fair in the evaluation, because the technicians did try to help, they had no real concept of how to address a problem which was not described in their training. The person who conducted the survey asked if I would like a follow-up call from technical support. I said yes. I am waiting, and waiting, and waiting!!
Message Edited by chinaatdel on 04-06-2004 07:47 PM
Message Edited by chinaatdel on 04-06-2004 08:19 PM
Responses (16)
Solutions (0)
- I too am having the same problem. I contacted Dell Support and was told to get a Analog/Digital converter. I purchased the converter yesterday, but unfortunately I got the wrong S cable. I will let you know if it works after I get the right cable. What amazes me most is that Dell Technical support referred me to the community forum to an article where the writer states how unhelpful the technical support staff were. Do they not read these things?
I have a Dell 8300 Media Center 2.8 GHZ with the AIW 9000. The whole reason I bought this machine was that it had a AIW card. My objective 2 months ago was to buy a machine that would let me convert all of my VHS and 8MM video onto DVD. The appeal of this card, in case Dell did not know it, was that it was a combination decent video card, TV tuner, and a analog capture device. (AiW does stand for All in Wonder, doesn't it?) For them to suggest that you buy another capture devide is just ridiculous. I have not been able to capture any audio with the card. Video works ok, but what good is it without sound.
I have read similar problems in other threads that I think may have been solved by installing the Ati software. Has anyone tried that? Does it create any other problems? If it was in fact turned off in the BIOS, why? If I had known I was going to have this many problems with what I thought was pretty decent PC equipment, I would not have taken the plunge. This is the 5th Dell I have in the family and by far the worst experience yet.
If anyone, including the gurus at Dell, have any insight into solving this problem, it would be greatly appreciated if they shared it here.
Dave
mmainprize
260 Posts
675
0
Posted May 17th, 2004 23:00
Take a look here http://www.rage3d.com/board/forumdisplay.php?s=&forumid=24
ATI has people that watch the forums there and with a serach you may find that others have this problem and they may have found a work around or fix.
This is a shot in the dark, but go to Control Panel > Sounds and Audio Devices. Under the 'Volume', look in the 'Device volume' box (not 'Speaker settings'), and click the 'Advanced' button. When the 'Play Control' window comes up, click on 'Options' and then 'Properties'. Under 'Adjust volume for', pick 'Recording'. In the list below that, make sure every box is checked, and then click 'OK'. You should now get back to a window that shows all the various recording devices, and at the bottom of each one is a check box called 'Select'. If you have one called, 'What U Hear', I would suggest checking off that one and then trying to record again. If that doesn't work, try some of the other ones (maybe something like 'Analog mix' or 'Sytem mixer').
FWIW, I have an AIW 9800 Pro, an Audigy 2 ZS, and regular XP. I know there were a lot of changes made to XP to make MCE, so I have no idea if the SB Live! (Dell version) and MCE controls are similar to what I have. However, I've run into the problem before with audio not being captured correctly (whne using the ATI MMC PVR), and fixing it was a matter of choosing the correct device in the recording control.
Hope that helps.
-Chris
BTW, don't get me started on Dell Home Systems Tech support. I am going to change the name of my notebook from Inspiron to Inprison as it has spent most of the past month in the custody of the Dell Correctional Facility (repair depot). I got it back today and it was still not fixed properly (3rd attempt). Grrr.
- Well as it turns out the analog/digital converter from Radio Shack didnt work, you need an S link into your PC. I went to Fry's and bought a program and converter called ADS Tech USB Instant Video CD. I loaded the software and plugged in the device via USB. I went back to Windows Movie Maker and tried again. You have to select the video device as USB Instant VCD and then the Input Source for Audio has to be Microphone. Now I get Video and Audio, but this was the only way it would work. The software with the adapter included in the box cost $69.00. I still think there has to be a way to get the AIW card to work, but I have yet to see anyone who has the answer. Least of all Dell!
chinaatdel
8 Posts
675
0
Posted May 22nd, 2004 02:00
I have been continuing to follow-up with Dell, but so far no satisfactory response. I have encountered another issue though, of which I have advised both Sonic and Dell. With the MyDVD (Deluxe version) software I have captured a 7.2GB video which I wanted to record. Using MyDVD I have parsed the size down with the intent to burn to two DVD's. All appears fine and normal in MyDVD until I commence the burn. At about 10 minutes into the process the computer re-boots for no apparent reason, which of course means no DVD burn. I have reported this to both parties. Dell is silent on the issue. Sonic have advised me that they have escalated the issue to a higher level, but so far no suggestions. To the credit of Sonic and MyDVD - the product does record the movie and format it ready to burn. Smaller source files did copy correctly. The issue appears to be when a 115 minute movie is captured which results in a larger file and this combination seems to be an issue either for the software or for the Dell MCE 8300.
Because I bought all this hardware specifically to burn my home videos to DVD I am now a little burnt about the lack of support. Trying another software product may be the answer, however looking at it from this perspective; the 8300 ships with MS-Movie Maker which doesn't work on the system, and now the product promoted by Dell as being compatible with the system also fails to meet expectations.
I am ready to try Pinnacle or some other DVD authoring software, but I am leery as it is very obvious to me that Dell has serious compatibility issues with this MCE version of the system.chinaatdel
8 Posts
675
0
Posted May 22nd, 2004 02:00
No, Dell still are not interested in the issue. I did finally get through the client customer service line (technical support was a total loss). Customer service have responded to me that the issue was important and that it would be looked into. That was several weeks ago now.Has anyone come up with a solution to this issue yet? I need to start converting videos and photos to DVD.
What additional software have you acquired to combine videos and pictures? I want to author a combination of pictures and videos with music using this wonderful piece of hardware that cannot capture audio at this point.
Dave
chinaatdel
8 Posts
258
0
Posted July 23rd, 2004 23:00
Not all is resolved. I have been in contact with Sonic of MyDVD and they have provided me with a new download with a more recent build. With this build the issue of audio when capturing is fixed (for me anyway) and if that is your major issue then it may be worth contacting Sonic. There support is responsive when you use the on-line support page.
So far all enquiries to Dell have fallen on securely deaf ears.

emjay98
2 Posts
675
0
Posted April 15th, 2004 01:00
I have the same system configuration with the same movie maker audio issues.
I have had this PC for about a week. Dell Support is still ignoring the problem.
I will continue to push the issue until it is resolved.
Have you had any success in finding a solution?