
UNSOLVED
HP VS DELL
ahh the dynamic duo! okay people, im curious. I had an hp pavilion about when xp 1st came out. ai ai yai! hardrive died so many times! then i think the processor went or the motherboard, not sure then i trashed it and got my 2350 and dell has been good to me ever since. It had an AMD processor in it might i add. 1.3ghz if i recall correctly. i paid like $800 for it. Yeah i know it was cheap, but come on, was it supposed to die that often?!!? my dad works for citigroup, has hp desktops, he said his graphics card died, and psu died. before a month! and these were brand new hps! here's the final question... is hp really that unreliable? do they put unreliable parts in their machines? or did i get a lemon? dell has been forever good to me, and i will continue to go with them...
Responses (8)
Solutions (0)
- Many of the HP home machines, EVEN THEIR TOWER MODELS, have an itty bitty poptart sized power supply. Its so small Im sure that its 150 watts max. Emachines and a few others went this REALLY CHEAP route and so when the system dies you get scalped for $230 to replace the power supply that will FAIL AGAIN.
What I end up doing is taking it out of the junk case and putting into a regular tower case. It means you gotta steal some wires and roll your own for others.
Newer Dells seem to have gotten away from that in the TOWER MODELS. The SFF and USFF and SDT still have PROPRIETARY Size.
I order 170L's now. The 170L and the Dimension 4600 and a few others seem to use a
MicroATX case and motherboard but the back of the unit has a standard ATX 12v 2.xx
power supply opening so you can replace the PSU with something from ANTEC or any other GOOD VENDOR that doesnt charge thru the noze Like PC POWER AND COOLING does.
There is Nothing wrong with PC POWER AND cooling. They make good units also.
However their price is over the top. The 430 watt PSU from them is $149.
An Antec True power 430 is like $68 on the web and $88 retail. System_ Shox
8 Posts
286
0
Posted January 14th, 2006 03:00
HP, and for that matter even emachines stopped using the 150 watters (PSU's well) over a year ago. Most of them come with 250-300 wat power supplies. Still, though ... they are not higher end of course. Rails would not tolerate a loaded out PC with a high end VGA adapter like a 7800GX/GTX, X1800XL-XT.Message Edited by System_ Shox on 01-13-2006 11:56 PM

BigBrother
2 Intern
•
4801 Posts
286
0
Posted January 14th, 2006 01:00
ravik521,
Regarding any computer manufacturer, you can find stories of poor support, stories of poor product performance and poor reliability. Regarding any computer manufacturer,you can find stories of great support, stories of great product performance and great product reliability.
Dell has lost customers to HP as a result of poor support, product performance and reliability. HP has lost customers to Dell as a result of poor support, product performance and reliability.
Dell has gained customers from HP as a result of superior support, product performance and reliability. HP has gained customers from Dell as a result of superior support, product performance and reliability.
HP and Dell are among the top of the heap in the categories of both "superior" and "poor". Neither is substantially better or worse than the other. Both companies made their reputations on quality products and excellent customer support. The world has changed in much the same way for both of these giants. They compete head-to-head in a commodity based market place where the margins on their products is very slim. Neither company is substantially better or worse than the other.
Steve