
UNSOLVED
Responses (16)
Solutions (0)
CastleBravo
299 Posts
364
0
Posted February 28th, 2005 18:00
@adyking wrote:
Hay guys,what do you guys have to say about it?If you guys recommend it, I'm gonna buy it.Any troubles so far with this system?- Ady
The problem with Dell's gaming systems is that they use Pentium 4 processors, which are inferior to Athlon 64/FX64 processors for gaming... and by a pretty wide margin.
http://www.anandtech.com/cpuchipsets/showdoc.aspx?i=2275&p=10
As you can see, when it comes to gaming, even 3.46EE P4's can't consistently beat an Athlon 64 3800+ that costs half as much.
- Great!I have heard a lot about Athlon 64. Everyone says that its faster than Intel Pentium 4.So what would be the best System Configuration according to you guys (if we think about assembling a computer part by part, for gaming purpose and within $2,000).I need some help as I was planning to buy a DELL system, now I think that I should assemble a computer part by part.The only problem is that I'm not that good at computers, so please help,- Ady
Message Edited by adyking on 02-28-2005 08:50 PM
@CastleBravo wrote:
The problem with Dell's gaming systems is that they use Pentium 4 processors, which are inferior to Athlon 64/FX64 processors for gaming... and by a pretty wide margin.
http://www.anandtech.com/cpuchipsets/showdoc.aspx?i=2275&p=10
As you can see, when it comes to gaming, even 3.46EE P4's can't consistently beat an Athlon 64 3800+ that costs half as much.
I would not touch an Athlon 64 CPU with a 10' pole.
They are bugy, glitchy the chipsets they run on crash way too often. I see people all the time complaingin about them on various forums. Yep if they are running right they are faster that day, however I will take the stability offered by an intel system that may get 90fps instead of 100fps in Doom 3 any day.
I have not read one recent review that recommends an Intel over an AMD, especially since the Prescotts were released.
Speaking of buggy, read all the complaints of the overheating Prescotts hitting 80c at load and the thermal throttling kicking in.
Let's face it, most computer problems aren't hardware related, Intel or AMD, I believe most of the issue is with M$. :smileywink:
@adyking wrote:
Great!I have heard a lot about Athlon 64. Everyone says that its faster than Intel Pentium 4.So what would be the best System Configuration according to you guys (if we think about assembling a computer part by part, for gaming purpose and within $2,000).I need some help as I was planning to buy a DELL system, now I think that I should assemble a computer part by part.The only problem is that I'm not that good at computers, so please help,- AdyMessage Edited by adyking on 02-28-2005 08:50 PM
If you are not good at computers Don't do it its not something that is done without knowledge. Buy a system like the Dell XPS or if you really want an Athlon 64 (*bleh*) look at Alienware.- well, i think u r right, being not too good at comps, I should be looking for a stable computer, that can give me good gaming experience but 'without crashing'. Too much crashing will be a pain in the back part :smileyvery-happy:So should I assemble a computer or just buy the DELL offered systems ? \I still have the option of assembling a computer with Intel Pentium 4. All I get confused about is the 'compatibility' issue, I have a computer with P4 2.4 GHz processor, with 256 DDR RAM, and MSI graphics card Geforce 4 128 MB, Sound Blaster Live! Value 5.1 card.Whenever I'm playing a game, my CPU usage goes to 100%, computer goes busy busy busy, i hate that, what should I do ? Please recommend.- AdyThis reply is to the post made by Riylin
Message Edited by adyking on 02-28-200509:58 PM
Message Edited by adyking on 02-28-2005 09:58 PM
CastleBravo
299 Posts
364
0
Posted March 1st, 2005 13:00
@Riylin wrote:
I would not touch an Athlon 64 CPU with a 10' pole.
They are bugy, glitchy the chipsets they run on crash way too often. I see people all the time complaingin about them on various forums. Yep if they are running right they are faster that day, however I will take the stability offered by an intel system that may get 90fps instead of 100fps in Doom 3 any day.
Pure nonsense. If anything, the exact opposite is true: the higher-clocked Prescotts have had reliability issues due to overheating and reduced performance from thermal throttling... we are talking about 115 Watts of thermal output from a Pentium 4 3.6 Prescott core, vs. 67 for an Athlon 64 3500+ Winchester core.
http://www20.tomshardware.com/cpu/20041114/index.html
Kindly know what you are talking about before spreading rumors and general B.S. on these forums.
@Dr. Love wrote:
CastleBravo, please save your AMD fanboyism for the HardForum, Dell is an Intel brand period and your biased opinions are of no interest here.Message Edited by Dr. Love on 04-13-2005 04:15 PM
They are! They are!!He is giving some gud information. CastleBravo didnt say anything bad about anyone. He represented his opinion here which is of great interest to me and may be so many others. Looks like you have some fanboyism for Intel or DELL, which is understood and I respect it though. But you have no right to tell what is acceptable and whats not on these forums.So, thanks for your unwanted advice, and henceforth, thy discussion continues :manhappy:Message Edited by adyking on 04-14-2005 05:59 AM

Riylin
171 Posts
364
0
Posted February 28th, 2005 06:00
It is a very nice system. It has all the goodies you want for gaming, 925XE Chipset, 460Watt PSU, lots of expansion slots. I highly reccomend it.
Only reason I did not get one was I wanted a Dual CPU system, so I got the Percision 670 with dual 3.6GHz Xeon's. Had I wanted a single CPU system just for gaming (I do a lot of video editing so the dual CPU's are a god send) I would have gotten that system.
2 Thumbs up!