
UNSOLVED
best audio for recording LP's
Of the following audio setups listed by Dell, which one would be best to use to record LP's via 48Xcdrw? Dell list:
CREATIVE LABS - Sound Blaster Audigy 2 NX External USB Audio System
MIDI Sound, 6 Channels, 24-Bit Playback Depth, USB Interface, 102 db SNR, 5.1/7.1 Speaker Support, Includes Remote
Dell Part #: A0194937, Manufacturer Part #: 70SB030000000
Usually Ships: 1-2 Weeks
View Larger
CREATIVE LABS - Prodikeys DM Dual Keyboard
104 Keys (PC), 37 Touch-Sensitive Music/MIDI Keys, PS/2 Interface
Dell Part #: A0284969, Manufacturer Part #: 70CF002000008
Usually Ships: Within 24 Hours
View Larger
CREATIVE LABS - Sound Blaster Wireless Music
USB 1.1 Interface, Up to 11 MBps, 2.4 GHz, Up to 98 ft Range, Includes Remote Control
Dell Part #: A0226602, Manufacturer Part #: 70PD039000000
Usually Ships: 1-2 Weeks
View Larger
CREATIVE LABS - Sound Blaster Audigy 2 ZS Sound Card
8 Channels, 24-Bit Playback Depth, FireWire/IEEE 1394 Interface, 108 dB SNR, 5.1 Speaker Support
Dell Part #: A0189063, Manufacturer Part #: 70SB035000000
Usually Ships: Within 24 Hours
Compare

MIDI Sound, 6 Channels, 24-Bit Playback Depth, USB Interface, 102 db SNR, 5.1/7.1 Speaker Support, Includes Remote
Dell Part #: A0194937, Manufacturer Part #: 70SB030000000
Usually Ships: 1-2 Weeks
$99.95
$89.96
[You Save $9.99]
104 Keys (PC), 37 Touch-Sensitive Music/MIDI Keys, PS/2 Interface
Dell Part #: A0284969, Manufacturer Part #: 70CF002000008
Usually Ships: Within 24 Hours
$99.95
$89.96
[You Save $9.99]
+ $30.00 mail-in rebate
+ $30.00 mail-in rebate
USB 1.1 Interface, Up to 11 MBps, 2.4 GHz, Up to 98 ft Range, Includes Remote Control
Dell Part #: A0226602, Manufacturer Part #: 70PD039000000
Usually Ships: 1-2 Weeks
$200.99
$180.89
[You Save $20.10]
+ $30.00 mail-in rebate
+ $30.00 mail-in rebate
8 Channels, 24-Bit Playback Depth, FireWire/IEEE 1394 Interface, 108 dB SNR, 5.1 Speaker Support
Dell Part #: A0189063, Manufacturer Part #: 70SB035000000
Usually Ships: Within 24 Hours
$99.95
$89.96
[You Save $9.99]
+ $20.00 mail-in rebate
+ $20.00 mail-in rebate
Responses (4)
Solutions (0)
gerald s. borma
1 Message
408
0
Posted March 11th, 2005 11:00
Dear Firebird: I really appreciate the detailed response. My equipment is an old DUAL turntable, the receiver/amplifiers are Denon-395 and Denon-635R. The problem with the DUAL (a good German turntable, but vintage 1970's) is that it produces a low frequency rumble when I used it to make tapes from the LP's. It was suggested by a speciality audio/video vendor that I get a more modern turntable. What is your opinion?
Can you suggest a vendor for the accessories you recommended ie RIAA, cables, etc.?
I suspect that the procedures to get a decent CD require a bit of study and experience and a lot of time. Given the desire to convert the LP's into a more readily accessible format and at the same time retain as much of the quality as possible I would guess the quality of the equipment and the skill of the recording operator is sort of important. It appears from what you have written that using my Dell 3000 (vintage 2005) to burn CD's is one way to go, but my question is whether it would be better or easier to use a DVD-R unit along with a Denon receiver plus a metering device to monitor decible level? Finally, if it is not prohibitively expensive how about going to a professional sound studio to burn CD's' from a limited number of precious LP's. I am talking about classical music recordings, just to set the record straight. The big question is what is range of frequencies that can be put on a CD? Is it anywhere near the 40 to 20,000db?
Best regards, Jerry Borman, bborman@msn.com
- You need an RIAA amp between the turntable and the sound card.
Pops hiss and rumble can be digitally removed AFTER you record the Raw uncompressed wav files using
Disc Doctor or RayGun or Pinnacle Clean Software.
Riaa Amps can be $29 or $3000 depending on how much you got in your wallet.
For my old Ears the $29 versions work just fine. - The big question is what is range of frequencies that can be put on a CD? Is it anywhere near the 40 to 20,000db?
Best regards, Jerry Borman, bborman@msn.com
~~~~~~~~~~~~
Yes, that is the frequency range of the CD audio format. Of course, what frequency range you will get on your burned CDs will be determined by the frequecy range of the source material.

fireberd
11 Legend
•
33399 Posts
•
112848 Points
408
0
Posted March 11th, 2005 10:00
The internal Audigy 2ZS is the best sound card of what you have listed. An external CD drive is the least desireable.
However, the on-board sound (on the motherboard) standard sound is more than adequate for vinyl records. When you burn to audio CD's you are at 16bit audio anyway and if you "record to the hard drive" as 24 bit with a better sound card it's not really going to get you anything. And, if you burn MP3 CD's instead of standard Audio CD's you've defeated having a "high end" sound card as MP3 audio is a compressed format and is not full fideltiy.
I do a lot of audio recording, and have a small recording studio, but I use a separate hard drive recorder then mixdown to the CD for the masters. I have an Audiogy 2 (EX) model card.
Some other considerations when you get around to converting your vinyl to CD's. (1) you will need an RIAA preamp for the turntable (stereo systems that have phono input have the RIAA equalization built in) you can't connect it direct to the Line In on the Sound Card. (2) you must first "record" to the hard drive and after you have an album on the hard drive you can then make the audio CD. (3) Use CD-R discs, not RW discs, and keep the burn speed to 12X or lower (I use 8X as my standard as I sell my instrumental CD's at concerts) so the burned Audio CD's will play on almost any audio CD player (4) do not use paper labels on the burned CD's if you plan on playing them in a car's in-dash CD player.
Finally, this may also help. Click Me