UNSOLVED

badbob002

updated

2 years ago

B

badbob002

1 Rookie

•

3 Posts

4

19814

July 12th, 2020 21:00

WD19 dock kills local network when laptop is turned off?

My WD19 dock, attached to my Latitude 5400, is connected to my local LAN with unmanged switches. When the laptop is powered off, a few minutes later, devices on the closest ethernet switches can no longer communicate. The lights on the switches are still blinking so the ports are still working.

I don't really understand it but it is easily reproducible.

  1. Plug ethernet into dock and turn off laptop.
  2. On another PC on the same network, do a continuous ping of another PC.
  3. After a few minutes, ping will fail.
  4. Fixes/workarounds:
    • Unplug Ethernet cable from dock/switch
      or
    • Turn on laptop
      or
    • Plug Ethernet cable directly into laptop instead

I have no idea what is going on. Could the dock trigger some sort of power saving feature on the switch and that somehow affects all its ports?

  • jphughan

    11 Legend

    •

    13985 Posts

    •

    79931 Points

    6013

    0

    Posted July 12th, 2020 23:00

    @badbob002  Very strange indeed.  I haven't seen this reported elsewhere, and the only way I've seen an entire unmanaged switch get taken down is if both ends of the same Ethernet cable are connected to switch ports, which can create a broadcast storm.  I don't even have a guess as to what the dock could be doing in power save mode that could cause this, and if you have an unmanaged switch, that obviously limits opportunities for gaining visibility and insight into traffic.  But just as a preliminary troubleshooting measure, are you running the latest firmware?  You can get it from the WD19 Downloads page here.

  • mbcastro

    1 Message

    5935

    0

    Posted August 2nd, 2020 13:00

    I'm having the EXACTLY SAME behavior here. I have two WD19 docks and both have the same issue. Both are connected to apple macbook pros.

  • MrAndrey

    6 Posts

    5874

    0

    Posted August 31st, 2020 21:00

    I am having the same exact problem when macbook pro is connected, but not when precision is connected

  • jdsde

    1 Message

    5795

    1

    Posted September 3rd, 2020 03:00

    I experienced the same problem on our network today and once in the past (about month ago)

    setup:

    Dell Latitude 5400 14 FHD (99VH8) running updated windows 10 connected to DELL WD19 130W 

    connected to gigabit LAN network, network died (other computers were unable to use internet or even get IP from DHCP) when the laptop was turned off, LED on the network port on the switch the dock was connected to indicated very high activity, when cable was disconnected network started to work again (other computer able to use network again), when connected back the network died again.

    Please provide some kind of fix because otherwise we will RMA all WD19 docks - this is unacceptable.

  • DELL-Cares

    Moderator

    •

    27843 Posts

    •

    745 Points

    5787

    0

    Posted September 3rd, 2020 04:00

    Hello, we sent you a direct message.

     

    Thanks


    #IWork4Dell

    For all non-technical issues that require your private data, we must communicate via a private Direct Message
    Dell Partner GEM Program, Out of Warranty Support options, No free goodwill repair, Get a copy of your Dell invoice

  • MrAndrey

    6 Posts

    5658

    0

    Posted October 16th, 2020 14:00

    Hi, I assume when you say "you sent someone a direct message" you mean it's a solution - could you please send this to me as well - I am having that same exact problem. Thank you. Andrey

  • 5600

    0

    Posted October 24th, 2020 01:00

    I'm glad I've found this. I've been having trouble with my local network, which I initially thought was related to a switch or router failing but some further diagnostics yesterday revealed that it was the WD19 at fault. A short time after booting my XPS 9500, my whole home network died - nothing on it was accessible by IP address, from any machine or device.

    I'd restarted all my networking hardware (just Netgear gigabit switches and an AVM router). I noticed before/after restarting that there was a *lot* of port activity on specific ports, which I traced back to originating from the port the network cable from the WD19 was connected to. Unplug that network cable, everything starts working again.

    Only a power cycle of the dock resolved the problem. It's happened three times in the space of 2 weeks though, and it's not a minor thing to happen either. What on earth is it sending out that's knocking everything off the network??

  • badbob002

    1 Rookie

    •

    3 Posts

    5559

    1

    Posted November 4th, 2020 10:00

    My solution is to NOT use the ethernet port on the dock.

  • mk001

    1 Message

    5417

    0

    Posted December 7th, 2020 12:00

    I'm experiencing this exact same issues while using the WD19 dock in combination with a Precession 5530 laptop running Ubuntu 20.04.

    All is fine, but minutes after turning off the laptop, while connected to the dock, my local network goes crazy. The leds on the switch indicate heavy traffic. None of the other devices on the network can make any connection. 

    Is there any way to fix this behavior? 

    For instance, how I can I configure that the network interface of the dock turns off, when the laptop is off? Currently, when the laptop is off, the port on the switch still indicates the dock being connected.

  • Vmcsnekke

    1 Message

    4512

    1

    Posted December 14th, 2020 00:00

    I also have the exact same problem.
    I'm using a Dell XPS 7390 and Dell USB-C docking station (mobile adapter DA300
    I think it is). If the XPS is turned off my nearest ethernet switch might go crazy because of
    an ethernet broadcast storm.
    For some reason the laptop or docking station sends back an ethernet broadcast frame, this is forbidden and a major flaw!

    I'll try to capture the broadcast that is looping forever ... I cannot imagine it is something simple
    as an ARP broadcast (then it'll happen to everybody).. my guess it is an STP BPDU or another not-so-common
    Ethernet-II broadcast (I'm using a Sonos audio system which does this).

    In the meantime I disabled Wake-On-LAN and a USB-C docking station setting (wake-up or something)
    in the XPS 7390 BIOS, maybe this helps.