UNSOLVED

maxhodges

updated

20 years ago

M

maxhodges

7 Posts

0

3313

February 21st, 2007 11:00

how clueless can a corporation be?

Dell recommends VISTA on nearly every page thoughout their store, as if it's some panacea to all our computing woes, but a clear look at this forum indicates it surely isn't!

So I go to the Lattitude D420 page, where "Dell recommends Windows Vista™ Business" is boldly written at the top, and select the Vista OS which again, "Dell Recommends" in the option group.

Then I get THREE compatability alerts:
-Windows® Vista does not support Bluetooth Option selected.
-Removable Media Storage Devices Option is not compatible with your Windows® Vista Operating System.
-Windows® Vista does not support Intel Processor w/ Biometric Reader selection.

As a Dell shareholder, I find it outrageous that you're recommending a software product which doesn't work with your own hardware.

It just makes me consider buying a IBM ThinkPad instead. This is just completely idiotic and bizarre to me...no wonder Dell is in financial trouble--seems your suffering a major brainpower deficit.

I posted my inquiry via a online form for "pre-sales/sales questions" and got this reply by email:
"Dell does not currently offer e-mail support for pre-sales questions."

then why do you have an ONLINE FORM for pre-sales questions?

Bizarre, indeed

Message Edited by maxhodges on 02-21-2007 08:42 AM
  • tommyo1954

    1527 Posts

    391

    0

    Posted February 21st, 2007 11:00

    " but my days of buying Dell might be coming to an end...you can thank Microsoft. "
     
    Perhaps you should be pointing the finger of guilt in some other direction ???:smileyvery-happy:
  • maxhodges

    7 Posts

    391

    0

    Posted February 21st, 2007 12:00

    >Perhaps you should be pointing the finger of guilt in some other direction ???

    sorry, i miss the logic of your post. What are you implying? I guess maybe Dell is to blame, not MS. But if MS made Vista more compliant with XP-compliant hardware this whole argument would be a non-issue...
  • mwfanelli2

    83 Posts

    391

    0

    Posted February 21st, 2007 17:00

    You have very specific hardware requirements that do not reflect the majority of users. In fact, device drivers are the responsability of the device makers, not Microsoft or Dell. It will be very hard to get an IBM Thinkpad as IBM sold that business years ago. I guess you mean to say you'll buy a Lenovo computer? In any case, what makes you think that their hardware support will be any better? Dell recommending software doesn't mean you have to agree with them. Thinking on your own is always a good option. When I called about my OS options, I had a choice between XP Pro or Vista. I was not forced into Vista just because it was recommended. First adopters of technology always have problems. If you can't handle the first-pass tech change, stick with what works and upgrade later.
  • maxhodges

    7 Posts

    391

    0

    Posted February 21st, 2007 17:00

    huh? The issue is: it seems idiotic for DELL to recommending a software product (Vista OS) for their hardware that is in fact much more incompatiable than another product (windows XP).

    Why would they recommend Vista all over their site and twice on the page of the system I was configuring and then when I select Vista it says, oh sorry, if you want Vista you need to downgrade the processor (doesn't work with the intel biometric reader), and oh, sorry, forget about using that external CD/DVD drive (the model I selected doesn't even have an internal drive), and that Bluetooth device? nope, sorry, ain't gonna work.

    >>You have very specific hardware requirements that do not reflect the majority of users.

    Bluetooth I can live without, but "Removable Media Storage Devices Option" that's the CD/DVD player, what are the majority of users using? Floppy disks?

    I thought the biometeric reader would be nice to have. Lot of Japanese models have them these days and could be a useful layer of security if my notebook gets stolen. But sorry Charlie, doesn't work with Vista. Just doesn't make sense why Dell would recommending something is the in fact much LESS compatiable with the hardware they are trying to sell.

    As far as Lenovo, when they bought the division they also got the rights to continue to use the IBM logo until 2010. anyway, yeah, a Lenovo ThinkPad. Are you
    aware of hardware issues or just assuming they can't be better than Dell?

    All the machines at the small business I run are Dell. I have dual monitor dell flat panels on all desktops. I'm from Texas, and I worked as the Web Database Administator for Dell Japan's online store until I left to start my own company.

    I appreciate that Dell is rated by Greenspeace as the most enviromentally forward thinking company in the industry (Lenovo is rated the worst). That's why I'm upset with Dell. Because they've really let me down by NOT getting their hardware Vista compatiable. What about all the people who bought their hardware in December with the promise that they would be able to upgrade to Vista (and enjoy all the "security " and "enhanced functionality" ) what a nightmare they must be having.

    Message Edited by maxhodges on 02-21-2007 01:31 PM
  • 391

    0

    Posted February 21st, 2007 17:00

    I tend to agree more with max in this case.  I just recieved my E1705 1.5 weeks ago and I have a NVidiai go 7900 gs and have had nothing but issues with it.  NVidia does not even have a driver listed for this videocard so how is it that Dell has a driver available and why do I continue to have issues with this driver not responding or my system locking on me.  , according to tech support Dell wont even send me a copy o fXP cause it wasnt on my order.....they would rather me send the laptop back and get a refund....not good business.


    Message Edited by batesjerry on 02-21-2007 01:17 PM
  • 391

    0

    Posted February 21st, 2007 17:00

    Well now after all that, I wouldn't get out of the electric chair to install vista. :smileyvery-happy:
     
     
     
     
    XPS 410
    XP MCE
    Core 2 Duo E6400
    2GB DDR2 SDRAM 667MHz
    ATI Radeon X1300 pro 256MB DVIVGA
    Datasafe 320GB
    48X Combo and 16X DVD+/-RW
    Sound Blaster Audigy MB Audio
  • maxhodges

    7 Posts

    391

    0

    Posted February 21st, 2007 18:00

    oh Dudley, get back in your electric chair!
  • jmwills

    2 Intern

    •

    11984 Posts

    391

    0

    Posted February 21st, 2007 18:00

    Place most of the blame on third party vendors who are lazy to write driver software soon enough to avoid all of this.
     
    I'm glad most of the complainers about Vista were not pioneers or we would all still be living on the East coast.
  • jmwills

    2 Intern

    •

    11984 Posts

    169

    0

    Posted February 21st, 2007 19:00

    I can promise that I have installed Vista on more OLD equipment that you will ever hope to.  Dimension 8300, Dimension 2400, and an Insprion 600 and all three work like a charm.  No issues with hardware.  Basic all the way to Ultimate.
     
    I also have Vista Ulitmate on a brand new Inspiron E1705 and every single device works plus the three virtual machines runing Vista pretty much convinces me that Vista will run on virtually any P4 and beyond.
     
    Did you take time to carefully examine every patch that came out recently?  Most were related to Office but if you installed hardware drivers while others were working, well, that was the best thing to do.
  • 391

    0

    Posted February 21st, 2007 19:00

    funny you should say that it is the vendors fault....I updated vista yesterday and programs stopped working cause of patches made to the OS.....whos fault would that be?...microsoft.  that is why vendors wait, they know a bad product is being put out and they wait for a mojority of the patches to hit and the OS to stabalize so they dont have to put the man hours in every time microsoft makes an update......I jus wish Dell would own up and say that this equipment may not work properly ultill thins settle down instead of saying "Buy This!"