ChristianSchmid

updated

18 years ago

0

3007

August 13th, 2008 07:00

Meta volume size

I¿ve got a request to create some 500GB meta volumes on our DMX-3

I¿ve read a recommendation to keep meta member quantity to a power of two. 2,4,8,16 etc¿. I have a need to create a few 500GB Meta. Based on the size of the logical volumes I have created I can use 32 members to create a 539.5 GB Meta and stick to the power of 2. Or I can create a 30 member volume to create a 505.8 GB disk.

My question is, what is the advantage to sticking to the power of 2, is it worth wasting the 2 extra disks (33GB) of disk space to stick to the 32 members?

Thanks,
Christian
  • xe2sdc

    6 Operator

    •

    2831 Posts

    982

    0

    Posted August 13th, 2008 07:00

    The main reason for suggesting "power of 2" is that usually DA processors comes in power of 2 (at least it was always true in the past, not that true with DMX3/4) .. Using 2-4-8 members will hopefully spread the workload on all DA processors evenly.
    Even if this suggestion is still true, it usually applies to our CEs since when they define the binfile they can look easily at where the volumes are in the backend.

    When you (our belove customer) create metavolumes, you usually have to "recycle" volumes previously used by other hosts .. so usually you tend to use what's available (in a true DIY style ]:) ) ..
    I love DIY .. however when it comes to performances it may give not-that-good results (I'd say "poor results" but I don't want to start another fight .. Allen everything OK with your switches?? ;-) )

    Also note that the general rule (power of 2) works better when you have plenty of volumes and they are well-spread in the backend .. We had customers complaining for poor performances of 8-way metavolumes .. But the main reason for poor performances was that the volumes choosen to build the meta was on the same 4 drives.

    So, in a word .. it depends ;-)

    You can form metavolumes as big as you want however please be carefull in choosing volumes spread on differend drives in the backend unless you want poor performances ;-)

    I think that Michael Lee may shade more light on this topic .. however since he is very busy you have to be happy with my answer ;-)
  • Allen Ward

    6 Operator

    •

    2124 Posts

    982

    0

    Posted August 13th, 2008 07:00

    If you do get an answer from him, please let us know here so everyone can take advantage of his wisdom/experience.
  • 982

    0

    Posted August 13th, 2008 07:00

    Turns out he is out of the office until the 25th. If nobody is able to answer the question by then I'll ask him then.

    Christian
  • Allen Ward

    6 Operator

    •

    2124 Posts

    982

    0

    Posted August 13th, 2008 07:00

    Good question Christian... and I'm hoping someone has a good answer. I've never heard this recommendation myself (I may have missed something in a best practices doc though). If there is a strong technical reason for this it may make a significant difference in how we allocate.
  • 982

    0

    Posted August 13th, 2008 07:00

    I got the reccomendation from a EMC Technology Consultant. All that was noted after it was "(leverages architecture of the DMX)"

    I asked here to see if I could get a fast answer. If nobody has heard what he is talking about I'll try to get a hold of him.
  • Allen Ward

    6 Operator

    •

    2124 Posts

    407

    0

    Posted August 13th, 2008 08:00

    If you have ECC, you might already be licensed for SMC. You should check with your account team.
  • Allen Ward

    6 Operator

    •

    2124 Posts

    799

    0

    Posted August 13th, 2008 08:00

    BTW Stefano - I wouldn't have argued with you on that one... you did say "may" :-)

    And the switches are fine. Apparently someone got reprimanded for telling me to do something that would break our fabric, and we've been promised "it won't happen again". Personally I was more worried about it happening to someone else who was more trusting and less informed *lol*
  • xe2sdc

    6 Operator

    •

    2831 Posts

    407

    0

    Posted August 13th, 2008 08:00

    ;-)
  • xe2sdc

    6 Operator

    •

    2831 Posts

    982

    0

    Posted August 13th, 2008 08:00

    Allen please always remember to put a note "This is an advertisement" in the low-right corner of the post ;-)

    Do you earn money when we sell SMC ?? ]:)
  • Allen Ward

    6 Operator

    •

    2124 Posts

    590

    0

    Posted August 13th, 2008 08:00

    I don't make a penny off it. I bet if I let our Vendor Relations team loose on this I'd get something out of it though. It would probably just translate into bigger discounts on hardware though :-(

    Really though, this is a product that has made a huge impact at our site. ECC is so slow with DMX work that it is almost unusable. Command line is fast but more prone to error. SMC gives me the best of both worlds. GUI to help avoid the fat finger errors, and speed of execution. Plus little bonuses like putting good metas together for me and allowing me to copy flag setting from an existing FA port to another by selecting the one I want to copy.

    The engineers who worked on this deserve a lot of credit... and I told them so at EMC World. If you think I'm excited about this product you should hear them talk about it :-)