We are about to replace an DMX-2 (about 70 TB and 24, 2 GB fa's). I'm of the opinion that we should go with a DMX-4 (still working on the size, FA's and the like). First I like DMX for the scale, the reliable, the power of symcli and ECC and lets face it, its what I know.
There are forces (evil in my opinion) that want to go with a bunch (number?) of cx3 type arrays because somehow this fits the whole Linux, cluster, open source model. I think this is a disaster from a knowledge standpoint but I doubt the powers care much about that. We are primarily a Oracle db shop, sizes from 500 MB to 7 TB, about 90 of them, some flat file processing but not a whole bunch.
I'm just looking for some chat, any particular concerns, any big cx3 support. Anything you got.
Bruce I'm a little biased since I do know a little of symcli and a bit of DMX while I don't know very well Navicli and the CX .. but don't think at what you don't know as evil .. We (EMC) have a lot of medium/small customers that do live happy with their CX .. And also big customers tend to have CX for some specific environments. Maybe someone else in this forum can post some of their experiences with CX family.
In Italy we love cars .. but there are a lot of different cars .. maybe you like BMW and dislike Fiat cars, but at the end of the day they both will drive you home .. Maybe it will take some extra-time, maybe you are required to move your seat by hand instead of a lovely electronic control, maybe you have to turn a key to switch the engine instead of pushing a nice button, maybe you will need to read new manuals .. but they both work ..
Bruce, trust me, they both work. And they work very well!
bruce ...i have one word .."scalability". I got so frustrated the other day when my customer asked me to create a BCV like copy on CX700 before his application upgrade. I was like ..sure no problem ..let me clone it for you. The application is rather large ..around 120 LUNs, since i don't clone on CX too often i looked at Snapview guide and see the limit of 100 clone sessions per CX700/CX3. That was very disappointing ..(i know CX700 is old but CX3 ..common). So i asked my customer if they could keep the application down for 4-5 hours so that after i was done syncing the first 100 LUNs ..i had to fracture them and delete the clone groups ..and then create the other 20. Pain in the rear .... Luckily the application was able to remain offline for so long (so that i could get consistent snap) but how about mission critical apps ? There is no way i could get that kind of an outage on my SAP or PeopleSoft database. And Oh my god ..don't get me started on navicli ...it probably equates to symcli version 1.0. I like managing Clariions cause Navisphere is very easy to use ..but i would rather use DMXs for sheer scalability, flexibility and true active/active front-end.
Bruce, I have been supporting CLARiiONs for a few years and think they are a great platform for the small or mid-range shop. They are easy to manage, the Cx3 line is a good evolution of the product, and I have found them to be very reliable. For most operations the performance is more than sufficient.
...but they don't come close to scaling out the way a DMX will and cannot touch the performance of a DMX system for normal operations. Watch your CLARiiON processor utilization when cloning a LUN. The array and hosts are impacted significantly just from clone operations (I learned my lesson from trying sync the clone of a production app during the day).
My company has grown to the point that I am deploying a DMX-4 instead of another Cx3-80 or two. The CLARiiON line just cannot meet our growth or performance needs any more for the front line production apps. We will still invest in CLARiiON but for the BCP site, development, and apps that do not require the DMX.
I hope that you have all the information you need so far to get your future work set up.
I was really staying away from this topic, just so you know, as I am a mostly Symmetrix person and have worked on both lines.
With that said and the point I really wanted to throw out is this: It all depends on the matchup of your business to the hardware required. Do the best for your business as you already state in your first statement.
Any of the local people will be more than happy to help out and by you being engaged in here for a cross functional response on your question will be a great knowledge base wealth.
xe2sdc
6 Operator
•
2831 Posts
491
0
Posted August 9th, 2007 02:00
In Italy we love cars .. but there are a lot of different cars .. maybe you like BMW and dislike Fiat cars, but at the end of the day they both will drive you home .. Maybe it will take some extra-time, maybe you are required to move your seat by hand instead of a lovely electronic control, maybe you have to turn a key to switch the engine instead of pushing a nice button, maybe you will need to read new manuals .. but they both work
Bruce, trust me, they both work. And they work very well!