sneakymoose

updated

16 years ago

0

204238

December 23rd, 2008 19:00

Seagate firmware updates for correction of audible "clicking" noise from hard disk

I have a Latitude D830 which included the Seagate ST9120823AS 120GB hard drive. Occasionally, I hear clicking noises from the drive. Usually it is several (maybe 10-25?) successive clicking noises, spread over nearly as many seconds.

I see that Dell has released firmware updates for the following Seagate models during the last few weeks:

  • ST9120411ASG
  • ST9160411ASG
  • ST9200423ASG
  • ST9250421ASG
  • ST9320421ASG
  • ST980411ASG   (I'm guessing this one's missing a digit... I copied the list from Dell's firmware update notes)

Unfortunately, the ST9120823AS is not supported by this firmware update. Any word on if/when one will be made available? The clicking noise worries me. I'm sure it's totally unrelated, but it reminds me of the famous zip drive click of death. :)

Thanks,

Jonathan

  • cooke6

    6 Posts

    4065

    1

    Posted July 10th, 2009 09:00

    As far as I can tell, the problem is a direct result of the APM setting on the hard drive, causing an excessive number of spin downs, and therefore an excessive load cycle count. This isn't something that is unique to Seagate drives, or Dell computers either, as I've read reports from a wide range of people with different configurations. Check out this thread, it provides some pretty good information, and it's where I started when I began to try and diagnose the noise.

    http://forum.notebookreview.com/showthread.php?t=168425

    Dell did release a firmware update for a big list of drives (DE17), and it seems to have worked for a lot of people. However, my laptop (Inspiron 1520) wasn't on the compatibility list so the update didn't work when I tried it. For now, I've been using the hdparm solution mentioned in the thread above. They recommend an APM setting of 254 (high performance) which should reduce the number of spin downs, but for some reason or another that really didn't work for me. However, APM setting 255 (turning APM completely off) has basically stopped the clicking altogether. You should note, though, that this might cause a hard drive to overheat because it will basically never spin down. It will also reduce battery life. Having said that, I mainly only use my laptop plugged in (power not an issue), and I constantly monitor the HD temperature, which has gone up 1 or 2 celsius but nothing major.

    So...to answer your question, no there is no real definitive solution (excluding DE17), and yes, the noise is probably causing excessive wear and you should be concerned about this.

     

  • osprey4

    6 Operator

    •

    34230 Posts

    3478

    0

    Posted December 24th, 2008 04:00

    Hi, Jonathan:

    Clicking is not a problem that can be solved by a firmware update, but it is frequently a sign of a failing hard drive. So make sure you back up your important data daily, and run the Dell diagnostics on the drive to check for issues.

    Good luck!

  • TheRealFireblad

    4 Apprentice

    •

    4639 Posts

    3478

    0

    Posted December 24th, 2008 05:00

    It would also be worth running Seagate's own diagnostics tools as well (SeaTools?) :emotion-55:

  • Kaaino

    1 Message

    3483

    0

    Posted February 16th, 2009 15:00

    Same problem here and for some reason the firmware update is no more available. Probably there are problems with that particular update.

    Also, I have another piece of info to add. I have just installed ubuntu on my E4300 and there is no clicking whatsoever. So it is probably a problem with the Vista driver.

  • Mr_Zero

    5 Posts

    3483

    0

    Posted March 5th, 2009 13:00

    Bill -

    I have the ST9320421ASG drive which my XPS M1730 was shipped with.  I never experienced the 'clicking noise' issue however I did apply the DE17 firmware update.  I did not apply the DE16 update when it was available. 

    I have been running a clean install of Vista and after applying the firmware update (DE17), I have noticed a big slowdown with the drive.  Running HDTune I am seeing the burst rate is way down as well.  Typically in the range of 50-55MB/sec.  This is very low.  Prior to the DE17 firmware update, I was hitting about 140MB/sec burst rate.  Any thoughts?  As I said, this is a clean install and the firmware was just applied.  Now I am seeing performance issues.  The BIOS is set for AHCI and I have confirmed all settings are correct.  The drive is not overloaded with data, currently 200GB of free space.

    I am about to call XPS Support, but came across your post and wanted to hit the community up to see if anyone else was seeing this behavior after applying the firmware update.

    Thanks.

  • Mr_Zero

    5 Posts

    3483

    0

    Posted March 5th, 2009 14:00

    Thanks for checking on this Bill.  If needed, screen caps from HD Tune can be seen here:

     

  • ils1

    25 Posts

    3483

    0

    Posted March 19th, 2009 10:00

    Hope you can help me.

    I have two of these hard drives in my M6400 and I can't update the firmware.  The current firmware version on them are at DE16.  I found the model number in device manager.  I made the boot disk and booted from the CD.  The problem I ran into is (I forgot most of it): when flash started and it reads the updated firmware, I got DE17.lod is invalid.

    I hope you can shed some lights into my problem.

    Thank you much in advance.

    The link I downloaded the firmware update is below:

  • cooke6

    6 Posts

    1144

    0

    Posted June 25th, 2009 13:00

    I have a related question. I just recently recovered from a HD failure and picked up a Seagate 7200.3, which is included on the list for the DE17 firmware update, but my Inspiron 1520 is not. The 1525 is included though, anyone know why the 1520 was left out? I have been experiencing the constant clicking, and have done lots of reading about it, have tried NHC etc...I highly doubt my HD is failing as I have run all the diagnostics from SeaTools and everything comes back fine.

  • shim.sim

    73 Posts

    1144

    0

    Posted July 6th, 2009 01:00

    Just took delivery of a dell e6500, have the same clicking problem, drive model ST9250421ASG. Just updated the HD to the DE17 firmware, used seatools to confirm firmware  version and its showing DE17 but i still have the clicking every 5-10 mins. is the firmware update independant of OS or BIOS setting or is there something else i need to do in order to stop the clicking?

  • shim.sim

    73 Posts

    1144

    0

    Posted July 6th, 2009 09:00

    passes dell diag ..... i was reading that DCP might have something to do with the problem, any other suggestions?