UNSOLVED

nuda-veritas

updated

23 years ago

0

13224

April 2nd, 2004 03:00

inspiron 8600 - HL-DT-ST GCA-4040N burn cd-r at 16x not 24x

hi,

i received my inspiron 8600 two weeks ago.
so far, everything seems fine apart from a speed problem with the HL-DT-ST GCA-4040N burner

i can burn

dvd+r at 4x
dvd+rw at 2.4x

like in the drive specifications, but i can only burn

cd-r at 16x (instead of 24x described in the drive specifications)
i used 48x verbatim and 48xfujifilm cd-recordables and nero 6 and cd recordnow max 4.5 but it is impossible for me to burn cd-r at 24x speed.
did one of you reach 24x speed while burning a cd-r using the gca-4040n drive?

a lot of people in this forum had problems copying and burning dvd's with the gca-4040n. i haven't had any problems.

greets
bjoern

 

 

 

  • mattcowger

    2582 Posts

    454

    0

    Posted April 2nd, 2004 03:00

    Its a 16x drive. Its not a problem with your system - its a dell misprint.
  • godim

    507 Posts

    454

    0

    Posted April 2nd, 2004 09:00

    Yup, mine also does 16x as advertised on the belgium Dell site. It does say 24x reading of cd's though. Perhaps you switched the numbers. 16x is allready a very nice speed. Evrything more than that just causes more energy use and more vibrations for only little speed increase
  • 454

    0

    Posted April 2nd, 2004 11:00

    hi,

    i didn't switch numbers:

    when i ordered my 8600 at dell germany the specifications of the dvddrive are (4x DVD+RW & 24/10/24x CD-RW Combo Modul)

    my HL-DT-ST GCA-4040N  burn
    DVD+RW at 2.4x instead of 4x (this means a lot more time is needed) and
    CD-R at 16x instead of 24x

    i'm a bit dissatisfied because i bought what offered by dell and received something else.

    do somebody know if there is a real working 4x DVD+RW & 24/10/24x CD-RW drive available and used in the 8600?

    bjoern

  • godim

    507 Posts

    454

    0

    Posted April 2nd, 2004 12:00

    Yup, seems like a type or bad advertisement. The speed indications can be confusion  though. CD-RW drives use aa/bb/cc where a = CD-R write speed, b CD-RW write speed & c the read spead. Most DVD's and certainly multidrives use only 1 write speed indication (the fastest). The burning speeds indicated for DVD drives are always for R media. The 4X can only be optained using DVD+R. usually DVD+RW speeds are one step lower (2.4X in this case). My 8X DVD+-RW at home can burn 8X DVD+R & 4X DVD+RW or DVD-R, DVD-RW is max 2 speed.

    It would be nice to see DVD drives use a CD writer numbering as well :

    DVD+RW 4/2.4/12-16/10/24 tells it all without confusion (by the way, those are the good numbers for the 8600 DVD writer)

  • Free_Linux

    11 Posts

    454

    0

    Posted April 2nd, 2004 19:00

    godim, we are not talking about an advertisement, the customer is talking about a specific offer Dell made and concurred in both invoice and order confirmation. This is indeed serious trouble for Dell as people must rely on what they are offered.
    To all Inspiron 8600 owners who received the Hitach DVD+RW: the Nec drive does both DVD+R and DVD+RW at 4x! You received an inferior drive!
    To all DVD+RW owners who were promised to receive a "4x DVD+RW & 24/10/24 Combo": fight for your rights! None of the two burners can burn CD-Rs at 24x!

    Greets,
    Free_Linux
  • Networqs

    78 Posts

    454

    0

    Posted April 26th, 2004 01:00

    If this is typo, it has not been corrected.  Still says the same thing.

    It also says that both DVD write and rewrite speed are 4x.  I can only get it to rewrite at 2.4x.  Another typo?

  • Free_Linux

    11 Posts

    454

    0

    Posted April 26th, 2004 18:00

    No, Dell is knowlingly delivering two different drives from two manufacturers with different specs to its customers. The Nec ND-5100A can rewrite DVD+RW at 4x with certified media whereas the HL GCA-4040N can only rewrite at 2,4 no matter what media you use.

    This really annoys big time for all those customers paying the same price but receiving an inferior drive.

    In addition to that, none of the two drives can burn CD-R at 24x as advertised clearly by Dell!

    Greets,
    Free_Linux
  • Networqs

    78 Posts

    454

    0

    Posted April 27th, 2004 01:00

    That's terrible.  I actually the drive separately, and it was listed as 4x DVD+R and +RW.  Should I get a replacement?
  • 454

    0

    Posted May 4th, 2004 09:00

    My GCA-4040N (I8600) writes CD-R 24x only in CloneCD. Nero goes only up to 16x. I couldnt find the reason yet.

    The real issue is that it writes DVD-R at 2.4x max. No matter what media type/speed

    Any ideas?
  • Free_Linux

    11 Posts

    102

    0

    Posted May 5th, 2004 05:00

    @Doctor Gonzo:
    This is most likely an error within CloneCD. As I remember from the help file or the FAQ the founder of CloneCD stated once, that CloneCD does not check the recorder for supported writing speeds and does not display the actual writing speed. Therefore selecting 24x does not mean, that it is actually burned at 24x. How long is the burn process? This helps to evaluate, whether or not the burner burns indeed at 24x.

    Greets,
    Free_Linux