UNSOLVED

calim689

updated

18 years ago

C

calim689

10 Posts

0

24323

June 2nd, 2008 08:00

Important Advice re CD/DVD drives not working

One of the very first things to do is to log a case number with Dell support if your computer is still under warranty.

I found out the hard way yesterday that my warranty ran out 2 weeks ago, when my problem with the drive has been hanging around for 2 to 3 months.  The lack of CD/DVD access had not been a major problem as there were other computers on the home network, and the kids were using the Dimension 4700 for games instead of homework.  Their eventual nagging got me to sniff around the forums, try all the recommended fixes over weeks without avail.  As it seems the drive was not recognised at the BIOS level, I scrounged round a spare DVD drive and spare IDE cable and viola!  Doesn't work either. ??motherboard problem.  That was when I logged in a call to support only to be told sorry, pay for the parts.

It is upsetting to know the problem occurred well within the warranty period but because it was not reported within the period (just 2 weeks out), I am left out of pocket. 

The forums are great for help but I think it is wise to encourage everyone to log in a call within their warranty period or else they will be badly burnt like me.  Maybe a sticky or additional note to the current sticky may help.

I am hoping to speak to the warranty division tomorrow( got cut off today after over an hour waiting and being transferred to different departments) to plead my case and praying that the Gods will smile a little on me.

Message Edited by calim689 on 06-03-2008 07:34 AM
  • osprey4

    6 Operator

    •

    34230 Posts

    1040

    0

    Posted June 2nd, 2008 11:00

    Hi, Calim:

     

    That's a very nice story, but I'm not sure I understand where things stand as far as your specific problem.

     

    By the way, I think your advice, "Fix things while you're still under warranty", is sound, albeit a bit obvious! :)

  • srkmeg

    3 Posts

    1040

    0

    Posted June 2nd, 2008 14:00

    So you had to get a motherboard? I'm having the same problem with bios not recognizing my ext. dvd writer. I've downloaded drivers, working on searching forums for a week! What was your outcome?
    Message Edited by srkmeg on 06-02-2008 10:14 AM
  • osprey4

    6 Operator

    •

    34230 Posts

    1040

    0

    Posted June 2nd, 2008 15:00

    Hi, srkmeg:

     

    Please start a new thread, if you would, and include the following information:

    1. The model of your Dell system,
    2. The model of the drive (check device manager),
    3. The symptoms you are experiencing,
    4. A description of what works as well as what does not is really helpful.
  • srkmeg

    3 Posts

    1040

    0

    Posted June 3rd, 2008 11:00

    My computer is 3 years old, too. I'm  returning my "problem" device (ext. dvd), because everything was fine before I tried to install it. After a week of searching for answers, I'm done. Thanks for your concern:womanwink:
  • calim689

    10 Posts

    1040

    0

    Posted June 3rd, 2008 11:00

    Dear srkmeg,

     

    That seems to be where it is heading.  My outcome is pending but it is likely I will have to fork out for extended warranty even though the issue arose well within paid warranty period.  Otherwise I have to pay for parts and labour or fix it myself.

     

    Good luck with your issue.  How old is your system?  It seems pretty rough for a motherboard to curl up its toes at the three year mark in my case.

  • calim689

    10 Posts

    1040

    0

    Posted June 3rd, 2008 11:00

    Dear Osprey,

     

    Thanks for your interest.

     

    My intention was not just to suggest getting things fixed while under warranty, but to keep the usual rush of blood (of the 'pseudo-techies' like me who enjoy fixing things ourselves) in check.  Log in a case number, then by all means trawl the net, enlist the help of the forums, the gurus and the benevolent net community.  The process can take a long time and as in my case became an unnecessary lost opportunity to claim under warranty.  Technically, the fault occurred during warranty but as it was not logged till after expiration of warranty, I can understand Dell's reluctance to accept responsibility.  It is good business sense but not necessarily good customer relations.

     

    But I digress!  Apologies for not putting in more details of the problem.

    The system is a

    1. Dell Dimension 4700 3.2 GHz, 250G HD running XP Home SP2 with 1G RAM
    2. NEC DVD +/- RW 16X, IDE (?model as I cannot see it in Device Manager)

    DVD drive dropped out of BIOS some 3 months ago.  I thought the kids must have installed and uninstalled games and inadvertently unloaded the drivers.  Rolled back via systenm restore without effect.  Deleted upper and lower filters as per MS knowledge base articles too. The error message at boot up with absent Drive 1 didn't twig until I went around googling and then looking into the forums.  My assumption then was a dead drive.  As I had recently upgraded my office hardware, I had a few spare DVD drives as well as IDE cables that I brought home waiting for a clear-sky weekend to fiddle.  Weeks and months go by until last weekend when I found connecting a new drive with a new IDE cable was not the answer.  The Dell phone support technician suggest it is a motherboard problem.

    I have to say I have not yet cleared the nonvolatile RAM.

     

    Would you suggest I try anything else or just fork out for an extended warranty, or go buy a new motherboard and D-I-Y and hope that IS the problem.

     

    Sorry for the long winded speil.  I have always hated waiting for hours on end talking to a technician, especially if it was to be a simple fix.  Alas simple to the uninitiated is certainly a Pandora's box with the bite of a thousand snakes...

  • osprey4

    6 Operator

    •

    34230 Posts

    1040

    0

    Posted June 3rd, 2008 11:00

    Unfortunately, despite a lot of effort, you've overlooked some obvious troubleshooting techniques. Simply swapping in another drive does not confirm/rule out anything.

     

    Let me suggest you reinstall the original drive, clear NVRAM and run the Dell diagnostics on the drive first, then we'll go from there. You need to have a data CD-ROM in the drive to run the read test.

     

    If the drive comes up dead, then try the second, known working drive. However, you must be sure to set the drive jumper to cable select, and I would also suggest clearing NVRAM after installing the new drive. Then run the diagnostics on that drive and see what happens.

     

    One of my troubleshooting rules: Only change one thing at a time and test after each change.

  • osprey4

    6 Operator

    •

    34230 Posts

    1040

    0

    Posted June 3rd, 2008 12:00

    Sounds good. I'll stay tuned!! :D
  • calim689

    10 Posts

    1040

    0

    Posted June 3rd, 2008 12:00

    Thanks Osprey for the suggestions.  Much appreciated.

     

    I will play around this long weekend (Monday hols in Australia).  Fingers and eyes crossed.

     

    Cheers

  • calim689

    10 Posts

    121

    0

    Posted June 6th, 2008 12:00

    Dear Osprey,

     

    Thought I'll let you know what transpired... The computer started going slow and the hard disk was chattering away like there was no tomorrow during simple word processing or checking email via Outlook.  Discovered that the installed 1G RAM is only recognised as 512Mb via the general tab on System Properties. Played around and found out that if the RAM was installed in SLot 3 & 4 instead of 1 & 2, it returned to a healthy 1G.  Seemed like a dead DIMM slot.  Taking the whole situation in consideration, anyway I cut it, there is a problem with the motherboard that needed addressing. 

    I spoke to the warranty division and the best they could offer was a discount on extended warranty.  I took the option as honestly, I could be spending a few more clear-sky weekends fiddling when I could be back at the office clearing my paperwork backlog.

    The technicians came(next day onsite), predicted that the motherboard was fine and it was probably kids playing with settings that warped the DVD drive.  He left a little red faced having to replace the motherboard as this was indeed the problem!

    It is all good now, DVD drive working fine.

    Still sad that a motherboard can fall over in less than 3 years.  My first Dell desktop is 9 years old(Pentium III 500MHz) and still running..just.

    Thanks for the interest again.