UNSOLVED

mtburn

updated

21 years ago

M

mtburn

4 Posts

0

3510

January 13th, 2006 17:00

Dimension 8400, RAID 0 & MAXTOR hard disk problems

Hello!
 
Short Version:  One of my RAID 0 drives is reporting errors.  I've done too much diagnostic work with Dell tech support.  The Diagnostics run indicate two types of errors.  I've been running CHKDSK /r for over 16 hours.  Of course, there I have important data that I have saved since my last backup.  Should CHKDSK take this long?  Any other ideas for recovery - at least long enough to recover important data?
 
My longer version is more like a Soap Opera.   I'd be glad starting by listing the mistakes I've made:  1) Being seduced into the speed benefits of RAID 0.  2) Not backing up every few days, with important information being saved.  3) Listening to the technicians on Dell's chat line....  This is at least my third bad hard drive.  I promise to convert from RAID 0 to RAID 1 as soon as I can (or no RAID at all).  Really, I do.
 
MAXTOR diagnostics don't run through external RAID controllers.  I'm still waiting for a reply from Intel.  Dell is now telling me it is a  microsoft software problem, despite the errors detected in their advanced diagnostics.
 
Can I just rebuild the O/S by copying files that don't read (as detected by a boot in Safe mode)?  I'm not sure how I can save them to the disk, though.
 
Ideas?  I'm tired...
 
TIA,
Michael
 
 
  • 381

    0

    Posted January 13th, 2006 18:00

    I am currently experiencing similar problems.

    My 160GB Raid drive failed before Xmas, but miraculously the drive is still working and readable, but in the systray there is a 'smart' (?) warning that the drive will fail (just doen't say when - shame!). Disk Diagnostics fail as well, chkdsk took days, etc, etc.

    Dell have supplied replacement drive. I want to copy image of original disk onto new disk to save having to reinstall everything.

    I have taken backups of all important data and I am trying Windows Settings and Files transfer Wizard on to an external network drive.

    So why one month later no progress?
    - lots of issues like Michael with diagnostics, plus booting off CD (didnt recognise SATA drive, needed drivers + several other files not suggested by Dell)
    - now Dell support will not advise on how to copy image of original disk to new one -(plus they have asked me to buy my own 2nd data cable to connect new drive)

    So what are my best options:

    - just use backups and reinstall (oh the wasted hours...)
    - buy a third party image s/w suggested on several threads, if so which one?
    - can I use the RAid 1 - rebuild mirror disk to create a copy?

    Any advice welcome.

    Devo
  • shesagordie

    12 Elder

    •

    46017 Posts

    381

    0

    Posted January 13th, 2006 18:00

    mtburn
     
    With RAID-0, when a hard drive fails, you have lost everything and the data cannot be recovered, hence the importance of making regular backups to other media.  A hint, avoid Maxtor hard drives.
     
    When you install the new hard drive, either use RAID-1, or use an imaging utility, to clone the primary hard drive C:/ to the secondary [my favourite].
     
    Acronis True Image 9.0
     
     
    Casper XP version 3.0
     
     
     You can buy the retail version of Acronis 1279691SF True Image 9.0 Downloadable Software  @ $29.99 from here
                                         
     
    Bev.

     
     
  • mtburn

    4 Posts

    381

    0

    Posted January 13th, 2006 19:00

    Devo,

    Well, I guess misery loves company.  Sorry that you are sharing this experience.  I will share that when I was having a previous problem that sounds like yours, with this RAID 0 / Maxtor disk configuration, I tried to use Norton Ghost.  This turned out to be another significant mistake and waste of time.  Be careful about disk image software and its ability to make and restore images of RAID's.  (It seemed to make an image fine - but it wouldn't restore.  Talk about a surprise!)  A waste of $$ and time.

    Still churning with CHKDSK /R for another 3 hours.  After 16 hours it was 3% completed!  Don't know if this is the right approach.  Am I to let this go for one month?

    Michael

  • 381

    0

    Posted January 14th, 2006 12:00

    Michael

    I guess I 've come to same conclusion.
    - I tried to use Windows XP backup last night but failed miserably - could not find certain system settings and files - hence XP is probably messed up so bad - its not worth taking disk image.
    (Thq on input on Ghost - I was looking at Acronis (sp?).

    - I will try to repair XP - using recovery disk, but not sure how.
    - else its restart from beginning - all those s/w apps, + patches :-((
    - unfortunately the replacement drive they have given me is a Maxtor again
    - so big Q - do I go lazy with Raid 0 again or use Raid 1 and give up the disk space???

    - I'll let you know if I find any good answers.

    (PS good news is that the Buffalo Linkstation nework storage I bought - appears to work fine, both on network and direct connect, so all docs etc are safely backed up - so I should be better prepared for next time????)

    Devo
  • mtburn

    4 Posts

    381

    0

    Posted January 14th, 2006 14:00

    Devo,

    Well,  I'm committed to moving to RAID 1.  I've had too many disk failures, which cause too much pain.  Besides I can't invest so much time and stress dealing with Dell tech support.

    I think I'll also add a third, non-RAID, non-MAXTOR drive in the unit, for on-line backup, which I could run every night.  But then I'm back to the questions of:  backup, copy or imagining the disk.

    I've finally given up, and for the first time I've dropped my machine off at a local shop for data recovery.  Over the Christmas holiday's I downloaded all my wife's pictures from her digital camera (to create more space on the camera - over 500 pictures) and haven't backed up since then!!! :(  Ooops.

    Michael

  • BMWBOB

    58 Posts

    381

    0

    Posted January 14th, 2006 14:00

    I used Casper XP to move from RAID 0 to RAID 1 and put in a 3rd drive and copy RAID 1 to 3rd drive using Casper each night. I also backup my documents to a USB HDD using Handy Backup each night. Can't be too careful!
  • shesagordie

    12 Elder

    •

    46017 Posts

    381

    0

    Posted January 14th, 2006 19:00

    BMWBOB wrote:
     
    "I used Casper XP to move from RAID 0 to RAID 1 and put in a 3rd drive and copy RAID 1 to 3rd drive using Casper each night. I also backup my documents to a USB HDD using Handy Backup each night. Can't be too careful!"
     
    Sounds like you have been doing your homework.  That's great.
     
    Bev.
     
     
     
     
  • 381

    0

    Posted January 17th, 2006 07:00

    Michael

    Having read the various notes, I downloaded Casper XP (free trial version from CNET).

    I tried to copy the corrupted drive to the new drive supplied by DELL.
    - first attempt failed as too many errors
    - but I found a setting that stopped copy if too many errors and turned it off, and found that Casper XP copied >99.5% of disk (nb I ran it in Safe mode and switched off Firewalls).

    I swapped drive connections and the system rebooted on the new drive
    - I need to check XP stability etc, but it looks fine

    The bonus is that I found that the replacement drive is the bigger 250gb disk and Casper XP allowed me to set the spare space into another partition - so I should be able to split data from programs
    .... every cloud has a silver lining!

    Martin