UNSOLVED

pagla

updated

22 years ago

P

pagla

7 Posts

0

29533

August 23rd, 2004 01:00

Dell 16x DVD WRITER ( Phillips DVD8601)

I recently purchased a dimension 8400 with a 16x DVD+R/RW  writer. (It is a Phillips DVD8601 per nero info-tool).

I am interested in burning DVD - R discs also as they are more compatible with 2 panasonic DVD players that I  own. I am aware that Dell and Phillips are in "DVD+R camp" but Phillips had announced in may that all their computer drives would have 8x DVD - R writng ability also  "to avoid confusing the consumer about which type of discs to use". Unfortunately, this latest drive from dell doesn't have DVD-R writing capability as determined using Nero info-tool.

Phillips own identical, retail 16x DVD+R/RW drive (DVDR 1640) has specs to write to DVD-R at 8x as do other DVD drives based on same Phillips design i.e. Ben-Q model 1620.

My question is whether this DVD-R writing capability can be added to this drive by a firmware upgrade etc. I am not clear why DELL would deprive its' customers by removing DVD-R/RW writing capability when all supporters of DVD+R/RW format (Phillips, HP etc. ) are now producing dvd writers capable of writing to both +R/RW and -R/RW formats.

Thanks

Message Edited by pagla on 08-22-2004 10:10 PM

Message Edited by pagla on 08-23-2004 07:26 AM

  • Predator

    2 Intern

    •

    15286 Posts

    828

    0

    Posted August 23rd, 2004 17:00




    Hi Pagla,

    If there is way to convert the drive to a dual format device, then I am fairly sure the Danagerous Brothers over at the Firmware Forum will find one sooner or later but currently if Dell stays true to form, then you will not see a firmware update supplied by Dell. As to the why ?? Standard reply, marketing decision.

    Best Regards




    God, grant me the senility to forget the people I never liked anyway,
    the good fortune to run into the ones I do and the eyesight to tell the
    difference.



    CD/RW Link

  • DocJonty

    10 Posts

    828

    0

    Posted August 23rd, 2004 21:00

    I just discovered this , after spending a large amount of money on a new Dell, and frankly am not a happy bunny.

     

    You would , incorrectly believe that if you upgraded to the best DVD burner on the on line ordering form, it would cope with all formats, given that some pretty low end machines form other "Lesser" manufacturers , cope with both.

    Given that all my home DVD players only read DVD-R , all the precious video i have of my kids, can only be viewed on the PC - a total waste of time.

    To discover that firmware is available that Dell is witholding from customers due to some cosy little corporate arrangement with Phillips, who are pushing their preferred format, makes me very angry.

    This is my 3rd Dell, and unless the firmware is made freely available , it will be my last.

     

  • DocJonty

    10 Posts

    828

    0

    Posted August 23rd, 2004 22:00

    Surely a firmware upgrade is available for download for the 8601 if it is basically the same machine as the 1640??

     

    I am phoning Dell in the morning , and do not intend to let this matter rest.

    I like the computer and am impressed with the speed and accuracy of the burner, but feel it is totally unreasonable to remove DVDR- compatibility for narrow minded corporate reasons , given that Phillips makes the customer version of the same machine available with this.

     

    The silence from Dell on this is deafening.

    The response i got this eveing from the technical helpline was standard corporate nonsense, even suggesting that at my own cost I junk the new drive and replace it!

    After spending £1300 , I would expect more help-- they failed [of course] to inform me that the hardware would support DVDR- , but the software to allow this had been removed by Dell.

     

    I am totally disgusted by the affair, and really feel like demanding a refund and going elsewhere.

  • pagla

    7 Posts

    828

    0

    Posted August 23rd, 2004 22:00

    http://www.press.ce.philips.com/press/documents596.html

    Please see above link re: Phillips' announcement about all its' PC drives to have dual-format capability. Dell's decision to strip this out is capricious, at the least.

  • DocJonty

    10 Posts

    832

    0

    Posted August 24th, 2004 10:00

    Phoned support this am.

    Aparently, the hardware is different to the 1640 , so, new firmware will not work - allegedly.

    My only option is to either return the computer, remove the drive and demand a refund , or , fit a cheap external DVDR- drive , and hope that some clever person comes up with a solution.

    having spent the past week installing all of my software , and setting the machine up to my liking , i really cannot be bothered reformatting the hard drive and sending the bloody thing back.

    The computer otherwise is excellent , and the burner is fast and reliable- just it wont support all formats.

    You may as well scream at God , it would appear.

    One thing for sure, I will not buy another Dell .

     

  • pagla

    7 Posts

    832

    0

    Posted August 24th, 2004 20:00

    DocJonty,

    have you tried burning a DVD-R disc to see if it would work? I havn't tried that yet.

    Also, the 12x drive sold recently by Dell was manufactured by LG and supported DVD-R as well as DVD-RAM. Does anyone know if Dell stripped out these capabilities from LG drives ( the 12x drives just preceded 16x drives for Dimension 8400 series )

  • DocJonty

    10 Posts

    832

    0

    Posted August 24th, 2004 22:00

    Yep

     

    Already tried.

    Funny thing though--my DVD player will play a DVD+RW disc fine, just not the DVD+R

    Bit of a pisser, as i have just started converting all my home video of my kids , using the fantastic Adaptec Videooh system

    PC TV that you can freeze and record /burn - and the only unit with the connectors that work with my archaic VHS-C cam corder.

    No result from Dell, and I am just hoping some of the boffins trained in codec on these Fora , can work out how to update the drivers for this burner to write DVD-

  • pagla

    7 Posts

    832

    0

    Posted August 24th, 2004 22:00

    http://support.dell.com/support/edocs/storage/p72538/en/index.htm

    I did locate this file indicating that LG (now called HLDS) 12x drive did support DVD-R/RW at 8x/4x in addition to DVD+R/RW-- look under specifications section.. Not sure how this slipped thru Dell "marketing" dept.!!!!

    Message Edited by pagla on 08-24-2004 06:43 PM

    Message Edited by pagla on 08-24-2004 06:44 PM

  • bernarr

    1 Message

    832

    0

    Posted September 1st, 2004 14:00

    If this problem can be repaired thru firmware, I'm sure there will be one available at some point, probably thru Philips.  I too have just purchased 2 Dell computers with these drives.  They work fine but I did waste a few DVD-R discs before I became aware that they were of the wrong format. 

     

    I'll keep watching the numerous "firmware" sites and post when one comes available.

    Good Luck.

  • DocJonty

    10 Posts

    402

    0

    Posted October 23rd, 2004 08:00

    I have just turned my Phillips DVD drive into a Benq 1620

     

    It burns + and - formats perfectly.

     

     

     
     
    Tells you how, though I recommend going to the Benq site and downloading the software for the unmarked Benq drive to upgrade from a 1600 [DVDR+ drive] to the 1620 [R+ and -]
     
    No doubt Dell have a Dim view of this, but given that they were not exactly up front re their support for DVDR+ , I think it is reasonable enough for theose who wish to to convert the drive
     
    It will invalidate your support though, however - you pays your money etc , and they make the choice for you