UNSOLVED

Geedsen

updated

12 years ago

G

Geedsen

10 Posts

0

34189

June 29th, 2014 05:00

dell precision t7400 PERC 6/i raid 1 problem

I am using this forum as it seems to be the most active and I couldn't find any other related to raid forum for my device. After a boot my raid 1 was degraded, and started syncing but gave an error on device 2 and started all over every time again. So I replaced device 2. After boot it started and finished syncing. And shows a status of 'optimal'. But every time I reboot, the set comes up degraded, starts syncing until it is optimal again. 1) Could it be that disk 1 is bad as well? 2) Can I swap disk1 with disk2 (slots I mean), to see what happens, and will I not lose data? 3)What is the best approach to tackle this problem?
  • theflash1932

    11 Legend

    •

    16255 Posts

    715

    0

    Posted June 30th, 2014 07:00

    1) It is unlikely that disk 1 is bad, unless it is the one failing.  If it were bad, the rebuild of disk 2 would likely fail before it completes.  Run Dell's bootable diagnostics on the disk to be sure.

    2. You can do this, but you MUST do it while the system is off.  It may pick it up automatically, but if not, the controller will ask the drives for a configuration, and when the controller sees that it doesn't match what it thinks should be on them, it will mark them with a foreign configuration, which you must then import in the CTRL-R utility.

    3. As follows:

    1. Make sure that you are not using desktop/laptop/consumer grade drives.  This is a sure way to run into problems.  Which make/model did you replace the failed disk 1 with?

    2. Test disk 1.  If it fails, then replace.

    3. If disk passes and both disks are Dell/enterprise drives, update the controller and drive firmware (controller driver first).

    If number 3 does not resolve it, then it is most likely that you have a damaged array.  You can try running a Consistency Check on the array, but you will most likely need to backup your data, delete the RAID, create and initialize RAID again, restore data.

     

  • theflash1932

    11 Legend

    •

    16255 Posts

    715

    0

    Posted June 30th, 2014 11:00

    By all means, make sure you have a backup, test the disks, run a Consistency Check, and update the firmware, but if you continue to have issues, your disk model is most likely to blame ... although a corrupt array may still be the case.  The Spinrite is not an enterprise disk either, but not all desktop/laptop drives work the same on an enterprise-class controller.  Some models, like the WD Red often don't work at all, while other models seem to work well (like the WD Black).  Some may experience more frequent problems, and others more intermittent.  Some may be critical (not recognized or random offlines), some may be simple annoyances (log entries or showing offline when really online).  Non-enterprise disks are very hit/miss, hence they are also very risk to use.  If you experience issues, I would probably try another Spinrite (of the same model, as newer models may have updated firmware that doesn't play as nicely).

  • Geedsen

    10 Posts

    715

    0

    Posted June 30th, 2014 11:00

    Thanks, I will try these suggestions. The disk is not a Dell/Enterprise disk btw. The new disk is a Seagate Barracuda ST1000DM003, the other one a SAMSUNG HD103UJ. Both SATA disks. The original set were 2 of the SAMSUNG's and were working fine since October 2008. So after almost 6 years, a failure is expectable I guess.