gfabre

updated

5 years ago

Closed

G

gfabre

1 Rookie

•

4 Posts

0

3278

July 23rd, 2021 01:00

U3421WE, is RJ45 Ethernet shared to two PC?

Hi,

I plan to acquire a U3421WE display to upgrade my setup. My dream setup is:

- A Dell XPS 13'' 9310 plug to the U3421WE through USB-C (90w) port
- My desktop PC plug with either HDMI or DP to the U3421WE and the USB-B
- Wireless keyboard and mouse (both Logitech MX) shared using the screen hub (dongles plug to the USB-A ports)
- RJ45 plug to the U3421WE

My question is regarding the RJ45 :
- Does the ethernet connection goes through the USB-B as well as the USB-C ?
- When both my laptop and my desktop are connected and turned on, does the ethernet is shared ? (ie if I work on the laptop, does the desktop still have access to the network ?).
- Or does the ethernet works with the USB switch and only one device can have access to the network at a time ? In that case, if I use a external RJ45 switch (one to the screen, the other to the desktop), does my laptop will lose connection while I use my desktop ?

Hope my question is clear

Thx

  • jphughan

    11 Legend

    •

    13985 Posts

    •

    79931 Points

    2313

    0

    Posted July 24th, 2021 10:00

    @gfabre  The Ethernet interface definitely wouldn’t be shared between both PCs simultaneously. The display essentially has a USB Ethernet chipset built into it, which can be “exposed” to a source device just like other USB devices plugged into the display’s USB ports. Sharing Ethernet between multiple sources simultaneously over the USB upstream data paths would require separate USB Ethernet interfaces for each upstream USB data path (so each PC has its own “Ethernet adapter”) and a built-in Ethernet switch.

    But I don’t know if the Ethernet interface is dedicated to the system on the USB-C port or whether it can also be “exposed” to the USB-B upstream data port when you aren’t using the USB-C interface for video too. My expectation is that it would be dedicated to the USB-C input, simply because that is likely to be used by laptops that might not have built-in Ethernet, whereas the USB-B port is relatively more likely to be used by desktops that are more likely to have their own Ethernet interface. But it may in fact switch back and forth. I can see pros and cons to both design decisions depending on each user’s individual use case. And unfortunately when someone else asked about this functionality and I checked the documentation, I didn’t find any information in the user guide that covers whether the Ethernet interface is dedicated to USB-C or if it switches back and forth as part of the built-in KVM feature just like the regular USB ports switch.

  • Kirk_Harris

    1 Message

    2261

    0

    Posted August 2nd, 2021 10:00

    Did you ever get a U3421WE and plug it into your 9310 via USB-c. If so did you use the USB-C or the thunderbolt port? Any issues? 

    thanks. 

  • gfabre

    1 Rookie

    •

    4 Posts

    2259

    0

    Posted August 2nd, 2021 11:00

    Hi,

     

    Not yet. I want to buy this monitor but it's out of stock for now

  • JohnPytt

    5 Posts

    1957

    1

    Posted January 27th, 2022 02:00

    I read a comment on https://www.digitec.ch/en/s1/product/ratings/dell-u3421we-3440-x-1440-pixels-34-monitors-14485326?sortOrder=Newest&loadNextPage=true that the Ethernet actually switches between the two computers as part of the KVM and it seems that DDM does not allow disabling this switch.

    I was about to buy this display but now it's a definitive no-go until Dell fixes this. The referenced comment in the link above is from 1Y ago so maybe this has been enabled in DDM in the meantime.  @DELL-Cares ?

  • gfabre

    1 Rookie

    •

    4 Posts

    1955

    2

    Posted January 27th, 2022 03:00

    I've finally buy the U3821DW monitor that comes with the exact same KVM feature. And yes the ethernet connection switchs. But you can "fix" the KVM to one input even when you switch computer. So in my case, USB-C always keep the KVM (and so the Ethernet) even if I'm working on the Display Port input.

    But to do so I acquire a Logitech mouse + keyboard budle that support Flow so I can still swicth K+M from one input to another.
    The only issue I have now is that the Ethernet through USB isn't stable at all. I experience regular connection loss. And because I use a VPN, it's a real pain because I need to reconnect to the VPN every time.

    I hope Dell wil fix this issue soon

     

  • JohnPytt

    5 Posts

    1947

    1

    Posted January 27th, 2022 04:00

    @gfabre @Thx for the quick reply.

    Logitech Flow is not an option for me as I cannot install it on my work laptop. I’d really need the KVM to switch mouse and keyboard only and have Ethernet stick to usb-c. 
    Hope Dell could provide this option soon.