UNSOLVED

Thaddeusp

updated

1 year ago

T

Thaddeusp

1 Rookie

•

3 Posts

0

7191

January 13th, 2022 09:00

S2721QS, dual, Apple MacBook Pro M1 Max (Thunderbolt?)

Initially for around a year or so I had no issues with these S2721QS. I used a pair of them with a OWC Thunderbolt 3 3 docking station. One of them was connected to the dock directly with a Thunderbolt cable and the other one I used a Thunderbolt to USB Type-C dongle. No issues. I could work at any resolution all the way up to the 4K 3840x2160. At that time I have a Intel based i9 2019 Macbook Pro. No issues.

Fast forward to about a month or so again, I trade in the Intel based machine for the new 16" Apple M1 Max machine. I get home verify my machine wasn't missing any updates/patches and plug in to my OWC Thunderbolt 3 3 docking station. The set of Dell S2721QS start blanking on and off in some sort of timed sync. I initially assumed it was a issue with my dock and the fact that the new machine has Thunderbolt 4. OWC says the dock is compatible after 7 trouble shooting sessions and no success. I said let me see if I purchase a Thunderbolt 4 hub will that fix the problem. That came yesterday and it's another high sought after device that got some awards last year. I purchased DisplayPort to USB Type-C cables "IOGEAR USB Type-C to DisplayPort 4K Cable 6.6' 3.1 Gen" to be exact to make the connection between S2721QS and Mac. It is doing the exact same thing. 

I found Dell article = Flickering or Blanking Video Issue with Dell S2721Q, S2721QS, and S3221QS Monitors when Connected to a M1 MacBook or Mini via USB-C to DP Adapter

Do you all plan on a firmware update for this situation as these monitors weren't cheap. I was trying to understand / get to the bottom as to what is causing this issue. I wasn't planning on having to purchase new monitors because of something like this, could you =

1. Offer another solution
2. Explain what the issue really is
3. Do you plan on addressing this with a firmware/ issue / update? I need some details. 

There is for sure something different/special going on with this thing.

  • Thaddeusp

    1 Rookie

    •

    3 Posts

    4958

    0

    Posted January 21st, 2022 13:00

    STILL NO REPLY.

  • Buzzt8

    2 Posts

    4843

    0

    Posted February 16th, 2022 07:00

    Hi THaddeusp,

     

    i Have the exact same problem. My Picture is blanking on and off when I put the Displayport to USB-C Cable in. Sometimes it is "easily fixed by plugging it in and out but then at other times (like now) it just won't stop going on and off... really frustrating because I have to work with this! 

    Please Dell, fix this Issue! 

     

    Thank you. 

     

  • Thaddeusp

    1 Rookie

    •

    3 Posts

    4837

    0

    Posted February 16th, 2022 10:00

    * Dell Support used the fact that the S2721QS Drivers & Downloads page never listed Apple device as a way to dismiss this issue.

    * Apple technical support behind all of these Apple silica / display issues has been terrible

    * Apple seemed to have sort of pulled/magically ran out of any docks that support M1/m1 pro/m1 max computers as of around a few months ago

    * I had a OWC thunderbolt 3 pro dock that worked fine with my 2019 MBP .... (intel based) as soon as I got the new M1 Max is when I started having (your described issues). I was then using a Displayport to usb C cable for one monitor and for the other I was using a hdmi to usb c. I can't remember which brand but it it didn't seem to matter as I had different brands at the time

    * So I move forward to figuring out what needed to be changed, first I figured it was my dock...(https://www.owcdigital.com/products/thunderbolt-3-pro-dock) which is what I had.  OWC says that there hubs/docks support the new m1 macs' MAX and PRO.....Being it was thunderbolt 3 I said I may as well update and see. I ordered https://www.owcdigital.com/products/thunderbolt-hub which is thunderbolt 4. it showed up and I plugged them in and the exact same thing was happening that you described and I experienced. SMH

    * 7 calls to OWC attempting and successfully disabling MAC OS security thinking that was what was causing the issues. Last ditch effort I restored the system to scratch all while deleting my backup just to verify nothing went wrong there..... guess what.... LOL it did the same thing. 

    * I take a trip to microcenter and go directly to the actual apple department to talk to this guy.....first thing I asked was why are some of the same types of cables located in a non-apple area and they supposedly do the say thing///. He said simple these items are supposedly tested with apple products etc. I explain to him and I say let me give one of these apple approved or microcenter tested HDMI to usb c cables. (he mentioned he had heard that the apple silica systems don't seem to like display port stuff). We didn't go in depth what he meant other than he had heard of issues. I buy a pair of these....https://www.microcenter.com/product/504926/satechi-aluminum-type-c-to-hdmi-cable-4k-60hz explicitely this model. They actually come in black as well but I have this white one. I come home and I plug both monitor up and boom no issues.....Full control of resolution....no clock like sync on and off issues of the display. I had one of the exact type of cables from amazon and best buy. 

    * I then went back to my old dock to verify and of course they fixed the problem as well. 

    * on the technical side "all cables aren't equal " is what I experienced. Spec wise the other 2 sets I had were the same specs and everything.....i figured bandwidth was limited or something.....man I have no TECHNICAL clue as to why these of the listed URL worked for me and my M1 Max.  I hope you can grab a pair and give it a shot/

    *New Tech and apple wants you to buy a PRO DISPLAY. no real support and no real direct answers. to what you really need to be successful with these monitors. I can promise you that what I listed above worked for me. Hope that helps.

  • Buzzt8

    2 Posts

    4824

    0

    Posted February 17th, 2022 03:00

    Hi Thaddeusp,

    thank you for your answer! 

    I would love to order the cable, but I life in Germany, so that's not going to work. From the specifications I have a cable just like that, but as you wrote, some will work and some might not (like the one I am using ) 

     

    I will try buy another cable. Hopefully that's going to make a change!

    Thank you again for your feedback on this issue! 

    See ya

  • 4771

    0

    Posted February 21st, 2022 10:00

    Just want to chime in that I am having a very similar issue which is driving me insane. Apple has been useless, CalDigit has actually offered me some cautious optimism and detail, and I expect Dell to do nothing because the S2721QS was not tested/validated for Apple by Dell.

    This was my setup:

    • Dell S2721QS 4K monitor at 60Hz connected with DisplayPort to TS3+
    • Dell S2721QS 4K monitor at 60Hz connected with DisplayPort to USB-C Active Adapter to TS3+
    • CalDigit TS3 Plus dock connected with originally included TB3 cable to MacBook Pro
    • 2020 13" Intel MacBook Pro running Monterey 12.2.1

    I was using DisplayPort since that is what CalDigit said is required for getting 60Hz@4K.

    Everything worked flawlessly, with both monitors and USB devices plugged into the TS3+, giving me a single cable solution.

    The only thing I changed was the computer for a 2021 16" M1 Pro MacBook Pro. The monitors constantly blank out, displaying the screen for 5-10s, then blanking (as if they've been disconnected) for 2-3 seconds, and repeating that cycle continually.

    I got a better response from CalDigit (bless them):

    We’re aware of the issues currently happening with our docks on M1 chipsets especially, and had more customers report the same issue since receiving their products. Our engineers are looking into it as it’s a MacOS 12.2(and 12.2.1) issue. Unfortunately, there have been a lot of issues with Monterey since 12.1 and now also with 12.2 and 12.2.1. A lot of customers have come to us with an array of issues since updating to 12.2 and 12.2.1 and this appears to be an issue with the OS itself and not the dock as the reports are global with different dock manufacturers. Our engineers have confirmed they are looking into this and working with Apple directly to see if they can assist them in fixing the issue on the OS side. They messaged us recently and reckon it’ll be 12.4 or even 12.5 before Apple have sorted out a fix for the issues on Monterey. They’re still working with them to push an update out sooner but we have to wait now as it’s in Apples hands.
    The issues being reported vary from power cycling issues, sleep issues, monitor connectivity problems, charging not working or slow, USB ports stop working randomly and ethernet either not working at all or dropping out sporadically. We spoke with our engineers and they're going to discuss with Apple directly about this as, the Ethernet issues, were due to a newly released ethernet driver and our engineer has found a lot of issues with it which has been a very long discussion and a uphill struggle to get them to look at it and address the issues. Our engineers in the US have some contacts with the Apple engineers over there and can report to them directly.
    For the time being, we’re all having to wait for an update from Apple on all the issues current affecting the latest MacOS versions.

    It sounds like there is nothing to do but wait and hope that Apple recognize this as a serious issue and actually puts resources to resolving it. This is so disappointing after dropping $2500 on a new machine. I have seen some random reports from people who have a similar setup without any issues, but don't have any details on what makes this work and what doesn't.

    I'll happily buy a new cable to try it out. I'll even buy a new dock (though I'd rather not since the TS3 is so pricey) if it works.

    Best,
    David

  • 4658

    0

    Posted March 9th, 2022 13:00

    I'm saddened to report that CalDigit's TS4 exhibits the exact same behavior. It seems like the common denominator is using an M1 MacBook (M1 Pro in my case) with DisplayPort. If I plug the monitor into the MacBook directly with a DP-to-USB-C cable, I still see blanking. I really wish Dell would partner with Apple on debugging this issue, but they basically told me they don't even have the resources to test their monitors on a MacBook, so I won't hold my breath.

  • xylents

    1 Rookie

    •

    1 Message

    •

    2 Points

    0

    0

    Posted June 6th, 2025 16:46

    I have the same problem 2025, but I have another dock, I'm using displayport from the monitor FOR DELL U3223QE,  and it randomly turns off , I have a 11" monitor generic conected also to the hub, and It nevers turns off, is just the dell monitor that have the same behaviour.  I should say that before have the hub, I had the same problem with another monitor VIEWSONIC 28", without using any hub, on my macbook.  I didn't found any solution.  the problem was the same with a core i7 and now with apple m2. 

    SATECHI Dock Thunderbolt 4-12-en-1 - Puerto Host Thunderbolt 4, 3 Puertos Thunderbolt 4 Downstream, 3 Puertos USB-A 3.2, Puerto USB-A 2.0, Lector SD, GbE, 


    (edited)