So I received a new 2408WFP last week and have had about 4 days to get used to it. At first I was thrilled to have such a big monitor, but the very thing I noticed is that there is a light band that runs down the left-side of the screen. You don't notice it on black backgrounds, or on light ones, but my desktop which is a charcoal gray, looks noticably lighter in that band. It isn't well-defined but basically looks like extremely uneven backlighting. I'll try and post a picture of it tonight.
I also notice what appears to be the input lag. At the same time I replaced the monitor, I installed a wireless keyboard and mouse which I initially presumed to be the culprit. The mouse felt... well... sluggish. But I swapped it out with my old wired mouse and still have the same problem! :( I don't do gaming but I still notice it when I move the mouse around.
I also can't seem to get the colors set right... even when I turn down the red channel in the custom color settings (and with brightness at about 15 and contrast at about 60), certain reds still seem so pop out while others seem dull. I may just have to buy a Spyder, color-calibrate it, and return it, but that's another story.
So the question is, should I exchange this monitor since each individual one is different? Or if the uneven backlight bothers me, should I just return it and buy something else? Spending $600 on a monitor that can't display a gray evenly across the whole screen seems ridiculous to me. And my 4 year-old 17" Sony flat-panel outperformed this one in backlight even-ness and ease of color calibration from the day I unboxed it. Am I asking too much from a $600 24" monitor? That's a serious question...
Regarding uneven backlighting, that's not present across all units because mine is backlit evenly. You might try for an exchange once the new firmware comes out.
As for color calibration, what you're missing here is that the 2408WFP is a wide-gamut monitor. Your 4 year old Sony, I'd wager, is not. It is nearly impossible to back-calibrate a wide-gamut monitor to the sRGB (smaller) color space w/o the aid of a calibration tool. Even then, it's basically impossible to get them to be the same because the wide-gamut monitor produces colors differently.
I bought a Spyder3Pro to calibrate this monitor, and I love the results. Note that the cheaper Spyder2 does not support wide-gamut monitors (the Spider3 has additional color sensors). Post calibration, reds & greens are no longer blown out, and the picture matches up quite well to my 2007FP, though with generally brighter more vibrant colors.
Are you asking too much? In terms of backlight even-ness, no. In terms of colors, I don't think you're asking too much. You just need to read up on wide gamut monitors a bit. Hardware calibration can help you a great deal. For some opinions around the web, here's a little blog snippet:
I had one that was lighter at the left hand side on grey backgrounds - I had to return it as it was unaceptable for graphics\photo work. I did notice a slight lag on the mouse pointer but it didn't really bother me. The over quality of this monitor is superb, i'd order one tomorrow if I knew it didn't suffer from the light left hand side problem!!!
Does anyone know if this problem is being sorted out ??
Yeah, I saw that thread and when I got home checked and sure enough, my sharpness setting moves in increments of 25 (not 10). Question is how long I wait to exchage my monitor since if they can't get me a good one, I'm buying something else.
Giolon
31 Posts
435
0
Posted July 21st, 2008 20:00
Regarding uneven backlighting, that's not present across all units because mine is backlit evenly. You might try for an exchange once the new firmware comes out.
As for color calibration, what you're missing here is that the 2408WFP is a wide-gamut monitor. Your 4 year old Sony, I'd wager, is not. It is nearly impossible to back-calibrate a wide-gamut monitor to the sRGB (smaller) color space w/o the aid of a calibration tool. Even then, it's basically impossible to get them to be the same because the wide-gamut monitor produces colors differently.
I bought a Spyder3Pro to calibrate this monitor, and I love the results. Note that the cheaper Spyder2 does not support wide-gamut monitors (the Spider3 has additional color sensors). Post calibration, reds & greens are no longer blown out, and the picture matches up quite well to my 2007FP, though with generally brighter more vibrant colors.
Are you asking too much? In terms of backlight even-ness, no. In terms of colors, I don't think you're asking too much. You just need to read up on wide gamut monitors a bit. Hardware calibration can help you a great deal. For some opinions around the web, here's a little blog snippet:
http://www.coyoteblog.com/coyote_blog/2008/06/the-problem-wit.html
and a forum post:
http://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/580308