Complete list of known Problems with the Dell 2407WFP Monitor
This post is intended to compile a complete list of the known problems/issues/limitations of the 2407WFP and to get confirmation as to which:
- (FXD) Have been fixed and by which revision (A00, A01, A02, etc...)
- (TBF) Which are acknowledged and are planning to be fixed
- (WNF) Which are acknowledged and will not be fixed
- (ACK) Acknowledged but unclear if they will be fixed or not
- (UNC) Reported but unconfirmed
I am hoping ChrisM can contribute info to this list so it can be running total. I've traded a few PM's with Chris but due to his responses being very short and no reply history, it is difficult to keep track of what is confirmed and what is not. If anyone has corrections/additions, please add them. Thanks.
FXD Problem 1: Color Banding -- Partially fixed A01, fixed A02
This was one of the original problems with the 2407 and it seems to be mostly cleared up with the later revisions and firmware upgrades. I have an A00 REV with a later firmware and it is only partially noticeable. A01 and A02 seem to have it mostly fixed. For return information see this thread: http://forums.us.dell.com/supportforums/board/message?board.id=dim_monitor&message.id=59991
FXD Problem 2: Text shadow -- Fixed A01
This was another of the original problems with the 2407 and it seems to be mostly cleared up with the later revisions and firmware upgrades. It does not show up on my A00 with the later firmware and I haven't reports past A01 REVs. For return information see this thread: http://forums.us.dell.com/supportforums/board/message?board.id=dim_monitor&message.id=59991
UNC Problem 3: Auto-stretch 1600x1200; 1:1 option greyed out
I need to use this monitor with both my desktop (1920x1200) and my laptop which has a max res of 1600x1200. The 2405 worked fine but the 2407 auto-stretches the image making it blurry and un-usable for daily use. All other resolutions work fine. Other users have reported it but I haven't seen an acknowledgement by Dell staff yet... or comments on if and how it will be resolved.
http://forums.us.dell.com/supportforums/board/message?board.id=dim_monitor&message.id=57633&query.id=158256#M57633
http://forums.us.dell.com/supportforums/board/message?board.id=dim_monitor&message.id=59430&query.id=158256#M59430
ACK Problem 4: No 1080i or 1080p over DVI
This has been acknowledged by Dell staff (ChrisM) in the following post but it is unclear as to whether they are working on a fix or not. After reading elsewhere on the web, I am comfortable to say I'm not the only one who waited for the 2407 specifically because it was supposed to be HDCP compliant and work double duty as future TV. With this problem (and the next related one), it is simply not possible unless it will be fixed.
http://forums.us.dell.com/supportforums/board/message?board.id=dim_monitor&message.id=58437&view=by_date_ascending&page=1
ACK Problem 5: Poor 1080i over component due to faulty deinterlacing
The following posts talk about the fuzzy image issue probably related to the incorrect deinterlacing of 1080i to 540p. I think I have read that there is a Faroujda scaler/deinterlacer in the 2407 so this should be fixable via firmware (along with the above problem). In the post above, ChrisM states 1080i over component is supported but I would disagree if Dell claims it is properly working. Is there a fix in the works for this?
http://forums.us.dell.com/supportforums/board/message?board.id=dim_monitor&message.id=58613&view=by_date_ascending&page=1
http://forums.us.dell.com/supportforums/board/message?board.id=dim_monitor&message.id=59092&query.id=158030#M59092
http://forums.us.dell.com/supportforums/board/message?board.id=dim_monitor&message.id=58437&view=by_date_ascending&page=1
UNC Problem 6: Brightness/Uniformity Issues with Backlight or Dead Pixels
I have seen posts about these but they don’t seem to affect every unit, unlike the above problems. If you have these issues, I’m sure you can arrange a return/replacement.
Any additions?
Thanks, and again, this post isn’t meant to bash Dell by any means, only to get a clear answer as to which problems will or will not be fixed by Dell. I’d like to keep it but in its current state I’m not sure it works for my needs. Also, I have read that there is no slated A03 revision. Does that rule out future firmware fixes which might solve these problems as well?
-Matt
FXD Problem 1: Color Banding -- Partially fixed A01, fixed A02
This was one of the original problems with the 2407 and it seems to be mostly cleared up with the later revisions and firmware upgrades. I have an A00 REV with a later firmware and it is only partially noticeable. A01 and A02 seem to have it mostly fixed. For return information see this thread:
--------
hmm.... i only got to use it for a limited time without gamma software before I had to leave for a week, but
it sure seemed to still have banding, some websites, gfx arts programs, and vertical gradients with that test image from Japan (looked to be starting near the brightest end and going all the way to the darkest end). i also see quite a few others saying the vertical banding (and still some general) is there in A02. i'll check it out more when I get back and see if playing with the special menu gain settings help. considering that this is perhaps the most severly griped about current complaint i see all over the internet, I'm not so sure this belongs under fixed. even if you personally don't find it THAT bad, don't have sensitive eyes, whatever, do we want the 2408 or other manufacturers to make everything from now on like this??
FXD Problem 2: Text shadow -- Fixed A01
This was another of the original problems with the 2407 and it seems to be mostly cleared up with the later revisions and firmware upgrades. It does not show up on my A00 with the later firmware and I haven't reports past A01 REVs.
------------------
yeah, this one definitely has been fixed since A01.
Problem 3: Auto-stretch 1600x1200; 1:1 option greyed out
I need to use this monitor with both my desktop (1920x1200) and my laptop which has a max res of 1600x1200. The 2405 worked fine but the 2407 auto-stretches the image making it blurry and un-usable for daily use. All other resolutions work fine. Other users have reported it but I haven't seen an acknowledgement by Dell staff yet... or comments on if and how it will be resolved.
--------------
not fixed with A01 or A02, but you can get around it if you use latest nvidia drivers and cards, but since not everyone uses nvidia and since apparently not all nvidia cards do it properly not sure why they didn't fix this. takes 30 seconds to change like one line of code. supposedly ATI users have no way around this, but I don't use ATI so not 100% sure.
NOTE: you should add another part to this, in that 16:9 signals that do not have 1920 across get stretched, they should add a 16:9 option for scaling to all modes (supposedly one of the still heavily banded modes does this, not sure though). Currently if you are on desktop setting and plug in a 720p HDTV signal, Xbox or whatever, you get a 16:10 stretched image with no way to force 16:9 (sadly current alternative monitors also seem to fail to have given this option). this kind of stuff i really don't understand, since this part and what you mention would cost ZERO money to impliment in addition to what they already have and furthermore take only about 30 seconds of time to code! and yet monitor after monitor has something to do with aspect ratios left out or bungled in some way or another.
Problem 4: No 1080i or 1080p over DVI
This has been acknowledged by Dell staff (ChrisM) in the following post but it is unclear as to whether they are working on a fix or not. After reading elsewhere on the web, I am comfortable to say I'm not the only one who waited for the 2407 specifically because it was supposed to be HDCP compliant and work double duty as future TV. With this problem (and the next related one), it is simply not possible unless it will be fixed.
-------------------------
I personally find it hard to believe the claim that 1080p won't work over DVI considering that 720p and 1200p display over DVI and moreso now seeing how somebody said they fed it 1080p and it worked, so I think this works. i suggest this being listed as (tentatively) "never broken to begin with". i'll give it a try myself soon.
1080i doesn't work though. it doesn't at all sound to me like they intend to make it work since they chose a 480i chip. so I don't think this is a bug but some design decision probably pushed on the engineering team by some finance department guy doing his typical thing. they would need to redesign the 2407 with new chips to make this work. annoying, but I would still live with it if they just fixed the banding (although if another option with it had been around I would have gone for that, assuming all else equal even if it cost a bit more).
ACK Problem 5: Poor 1080i over component due to faulty deinterlacing
The following posts talk about the fuzzy image issue probably related to the incorrect deinterlacing of 1080i to 540p. I think I have read that there is a Faroujda scaler/deinterlacer in the 2407 so this should be fixable via firmware (along with the above problem). In the post above, ChrisM states 1080i over component is supported but I would disagree if Dell claims it is properly working.
---------------------------
yeah whether this is a bug or another cost cutting design decision I'm not sure, i suspect it was just a design decision so I doubt it will get fixed, although it is technically possible for bugged code to cause it.
UNC Problem 6: Brightness/Uniformity Issues with Backlight or Dead Pixels
I have seen posts about these but they don’t seem to affect every unit, unlike the above problems. If you have these issues, I’m sure you can arrange a return/replacement.
---------------------------------
i think dead pixel issue is just something that will happen to some unlucky few with any LCD and it didn't sound like it was any worse for the 2407 than with anything else.
backlight stuff seemed to hit a fair number of people early on, but I haven't seen too much about this lately. mind seems reasonable enough to me, although perhaps some are more picky or more sensitive, but fine to me.
ok, just read elsewhere that there is a work around for the 1600x1200 issue for ANY user, not just nvidia users.
apparently all you need to do is go to any resolution lower than 1200p, pick the 4:3 setting, then go back to 1600x1200 and it will scale perfectly as 4:3.
so I guess you could sort of move that to fixed, even if it is a bit of a bug. it can be easily gotten around.
so remaining issues i think are:
1. banding still
and also
2. 16:9 material that is not 1920x1080 will stretch to 16:10 and look a little weird with no apparent way to get around it (for external sources, anything driven by your PC you can obviously have the PC scale it for you as needed)
(3.) and perhaps 1080i, although I think this was just a design decision one has to live with or not get this monitor and not a bug.
(4.) nobody has confirmed 1080p HDCP yet. i think it will work, but since some at Dell claim not, I guess we will see. some at Dell also claim no guarantee for 720p HDCP either (i THOUGHT i read that somebody tried it with protected 720p cable and it worked though). i also think it WILL work, but again we will see. if neither works and the monitor has no 1080i, then it has no HDCP and don't think Dell set itself up for a strictly false claim like that, plus it doesn't make a ton of a sense that those modes wouldn't work. but we'll see i guess.
You can't fix color banding in the other two modes.
Well ok, fine, you can fix it, but then there's no point in the other two modes; I'd rather have it the way it is cos it's a quick way to adjust brightness/contrast for games since ATI drivers don't work properly :smileytongue:
wth...i'm knew to this forum and reading all these reviews and comments about dell's new monitors just makes me think about how your all getting ripped off. I see people always say how people should just deal with it, they dont care because they dont use anything but VGA or S-Video and how people will only care if they are into designs of some kind and its a joke. People got ripped off plain and simple...
Thanks for all the replies everyone. I kind of realized that this would turn into a vent thread but, again, I'm most interested a clear list of problems and what is being done about them (if anything).
"ok, just read elsewhere that there is a work around for the 1600x1200 issue for ANY user, not just nvidia users. apparently all you need to do is go to any resolution lower than 1200p, pick the 4:3 setting, then go back to 1600x1200 and it will scale perfectly as 4:3."
Can anyone else confirm the above fix? I tried it with no success. I set my screen resolution to 1280x1024, then to 4:3. This filled the height but stretched the 5:4, 1280x1024 image into the 4:3 space. I then switched the resolution to 1600x1200 without changing anything else and it re-stretched it to fill the whole 16:10 screen. When checking the display settings in the menu, "Wide Mode" and "Zoom" are both greyed out now and Wide Mode shows it is on "Fill". Unless someone can confirm otherwise, I do not consider this problem fixed.
-Matt
Edit: I tried it with 1024x768, a true 4:3 resolution instead of a 5:4, as well... also without success.
"Problem 4: No 1080i or 1080p over DVI
This has been acknowledged by Dell staff (ChrisM) in the following post but it is unclear as to whether they are working on a fix or not. After reading elsewhere on the web, I am comfortable to say I'm not the only one who waited for the 2407 specifically because it was supposed to be HDCP compliant and work double duty as future TV. With this problem (and the next related one), it is simply not possible unless it will be fixed.
-------------------------
I personally find it hard to believe the claim that 1080p won't work over DVI considering that 720p and 1200p display over DVI and moreso now seeing how somebody said they fed it 1080p and it worked, so I think this works. i suggest this being listed as (tentatively) "never broken to begin with". i'll give it a try myself soon."
Thanks skibum5000. While trying the 1600x1200 fix above, I noticed that my ATI card will output 1080p. To my suprise, it worked properly over DVI! It even had thin black bars at the top and bottom so it was displaying it at the proper aspect ratio as well. Granted, the signal is not HDCP protected so it still might not work with HD-DVD or Blu-Ray players if it has problems sync'ing like 1080i does.
i didn't try it extensively, but I did try a few times using that supposed trick's method but it didn't seem to work, so I went back to using NVidia Center Image mode when I need 1600x1200, it's perfect with that, but for ATI users, not sure what to say, that's bad.
SR45
2 Intern
•
12138 Posts
1252
0
Posted June 30th, 2006 19:00
Add this one below to your list :
Color banding was partially fixed in the Desktop Mode, but not in the other two Modes, that you, and other paid for...