UNSOLVED

curtis_rick

updated

19 years ago

C

curtis_rick

91 Posts

0

12584

April 1st, 2008 14:00

2408 WFP - Try the lottery or pass?

Hello all 2408 owners and returners!  I guess the subject says it all.  I really want to like this monitor, but it seems like the typical initial Dell panel garbage of late.  I read that some get a perfect one from the start and then read about the horror stories.  I am left wondering if the less discerning eye gets a "perfect" panel and the more discerning eye sees the defects that exist in all.  Not a knock on the less discerning eye, ignorance is bliss I say!!!!  I would be using this for graphic design work at a student level and would calibrate it with good hardware calibration. 

 

 

Why is that Dell QC seems to be falling so far so fast? I have only owned Dell machines and they have eventually resolved any issues to my satisfaction. But back in the day I never had any issues with my Dells to get resolved!  It gets harder and harder to remain loyal.  Maybe I should just get an Eizo, destroy my food budget for the year and have a good monitor!

  • 766

    0

    Posted April 1st, 2008 14:00

    Yes, exactly.

     

    I bought 2408 in the first week it was released in UK.

     

    Love this monitor very much. However, when I got it, i found it has color unbalanaced and pink problem, which means the left 1/3 and the right 1/3 parts are a little bit pink and the middle 1/3 is pure white.

     

    So i called dell to get another new one. unfortuately the 2nd one has similar problem but a bit better.

     

    So I called dell again to get the 3rd one. the problem still exists.

     

    So finally i get my 2408 refunded.

     

    by the way, I have tested all 3 monitors on different computers. I am 100% sure it is the monitor's problem.

     

    I am just waiting for dell to have the current out-of-factory 2408s get replaced. I hope 2408 would solve all those problems in the close future.

     

    Can any admin of this forum talk about currrent 2408 status? I guess Dell is suffering from 2408 too.

  • cacadooo

    7 Posts

    766

    0

    Posted April 3rd, 2008 06:00

    Well I think my left side is slightly brighter than the right edge where I can spot some darker shade. It is not very dark but as you said I can notice this too. Second thing is backlight bleed (not very strong tough) in top left, top right and botton right corner.

    See pictures. I am returning it.

    http://aycu23.webshots.com/image/50662/2002527885039800771_rs.jpg

    http://aycu17.webshots.com/image/48376/2002569373050189942_rs.jpg

    http://aycu18.webshots.com/image/48217/2002580438445237376_rs.jpg

     

    http://aycu15.webshots.com/image/50694/2000128188813799937_rs.jpg 

  • curtis_rick

    91 Posts

    766

    0

    Posted April 3rd, 2008 13:00

    Wow...that is horrible!  Thanks for sharing.  I guess its Eizo, Lacie, or top end NEC and Top Ramen this year!

     

    I guess its true, you get what you pay for.  The sad thing is Dell used to give you so much more than you would pay for.  Now I read they are closing the Austin desktop manufacturing plant to cut costs in the wake of getting a whoopin' by HP.  I think if rather than closing plants and skulking about the planet for the cheapest part to sub in to make the investors happy, Mr. Dell returned to his roots and just gave us great products with great warranties that we rarely need to use, Dell would be on top again.  But finding zillions of forum posts with customers complaining of their horrible experience with faulty equipment, less than decent tech support by less than knowledgeable persons (I lay this at Dell's feet for a lack of training and information dissemination to them), horrible delivery service (DHL), returning panels through 4 revisions to get it kinda right...I could go on...just further pushes people away from the company.

     

    I am a huge Dell fan, I have followed Mr. Dell's story from the begining, every machine I, my family, and our businesses have ever owned are Dells, every employer where I influenced the tech decisions or made them has gotten Dells, I have told everyone that has asked, to buy a Dell...I bought 3 at Christmas this past year...its just getting harder and harder to do so.  Its poor quality control and declining customer support (which includes customer service, tech support, ill informed sales people, and persons I can't understand when I call).  As I said in my original post, every problem I have ever had has been resolved, its just that back in the day I never had a problem to get resolved and that history taints the here and now. Quit worrying about the investors, make the customers happy, the finicky day traders, and other investors will be there when sales and profits are through the roof!

  • 766

    0

    Posted April 4th, 2008 05:00

    Hard to say....

     

    I ordered a 2408WFP early Wednesday morning and had it sent "next day" and got it yesterday. I didn't read this forum until after I ordered my 2408 and started to panic after I read about all the issues people were having.  I have only had a short time with the 2408 since it arrived (about an hour or so) but I can say so far it appears to be working perfectly. No dead/stuck pixels, the brightness/contrast seems to be uniform across the entire panel and no color issues (no pink or red corners like some mentioned). So far so good (knock on wood).

     

    I will report back if I have any issues.

    Message Edited by cifrancgx on 04-04-2008 02:31 AM
  • CrymsonArray

    133 Posts

    766

    0

    Posted April 4th, 2008 13:00


    @cacadooo wrote:

    Well I think my left side is slightly brighter than the right edge where I can spot some darker shade. It is not very dark but as you said I can notice this too. Second thing is backlight bleed (not very strong tough) in top left, top right and botton right corner.

    See pictures. I am returning it.

    http://aycu23.webshots.com/image/50662/2002527885039800771_rs.jpg

    http://aycu17.webshots.com/image/48376/2002569373050189942_rs.jpg

    http://aycu18.webshots.com/image/48217/2002580438445237376_rs.jpg

     

    http://aycu15.webshots.com/image/50694/2000128188813799937_rs.jpg 


    hey cacadooo, in the last pic with the miramax background, what is the program thats showing the small popup window in the bottom right corner? thanks.
  • KoBo

    93 Posts

    766

    0

    Posted April 5th, 2008 06:00

    I have somewhat the same problem as cacadoo displays in this image:

    http://aycu15.webshots.com/image/50694/2000128188813799937_rs.jpg only to a slightly lesser extent.

     

    I don't have any noticable miscoloration or other defects.

     

    I'd like to hear from Dell soon! Please respond to this thread.

     

    What is Dell going to do about these 2408WFP monitors? The error rate for this monitor is sky-high with reports of miscoloration and uneven backlighting are widespread on the internet, everywhere from these forums to specialized flat panel forums. I frequent flatpanels.dk which is a Danish site and the number of people in that small community who report something or other wrong with the 2408WPF is alarmingly high, everything considered.

     

    I like this monitor... if it didn't have issues. Right now I'm fairly happy with my 2408WFP, but I also got one of the "better" ones, which "only" has a slightly brighter left side, which is only very noticable on dark or dark grey backgrounds. It's not typical backlight bleed, as a totally black background, like on BIOS post or a completely black desktop background doesn't show any bright left side. As mentioned, it's worst on very dark, uniform backgrounds. But moving a photo from the center of the screen to the left, will show it brightening slightly as you move towards the left edge.

     

    Now, I could just return it and be sure of a pristine unit... But the risk of getting a new one that is much worse is simply too high, judging from other people's experience, both on flatpanels.dk and elsewhere. (If you need translated threads from this site, I'm sure the local Danish Dell branch will happy to provide them for you).

     

    Then there's also the extreme hassle of getting a monitor swapped out. Dell in Denmark only delivers during normal business hours, using a courier service. This is all good... but I'm obviously at work during those hours... duh. So I'd have to make any exchange at work, and transport monitors back and forth. All this is on top of the huge error rate on the 2408WFP, currently.

     

    By doing it this way, Dell positions private customers, so that they're more inclined to let Dell "win" in a case like mine, where the risk of getting an even worse monitor is high and the effort required for an exchange is rather large on top of that.

     

    Dell, what are you going to do about the 2408WFP issues?

     

    Personally I'd like an exchange at some point, but only when Dell has a new revision that isn't plastered with problems like these first-batch 2408WFP are. Until then it seems futile.

     

    If you'd like my contact details I'll be happy to provide them. Then you can get back to me when you have weeded out all the faulty units and have a revision that isn't hugely error prone, as the current situation stands.

     

    I'll take what customer support experience Dell provides here and share it with other 2408WFP owners on the forums I frequent. A lot of people are appalled by the current quality standards that Dell are showing. You really need to tighten your production quality. The way it goes now, you're driving your solid reputation into the ground.

     

    Thank you. I look forward to hearing from Dell on these issues.

  • cacadooo

    7 Posts

    766

    0

    Posted April 7th, 2008 13:00

    It is a window of cFosSpeed ( http://www.cfos.de/download/download_e.htm), which helps with a network traffic. Very useful while browsing and downloading/uploading at the same time.
  • KoBo

    93 Posts

    766

    0

    Posted April 9th, 2008 16:00

    Any input from Dell on the 2408WFP situation?

     

    Will there be another revision? Have you dealt with the brighter left side, colour tone etc. issues?

     

    How much brightness difference across the screen would Dell consider normal? None? A little? 

  • curtis_rick

    91 Posts

    766

    0

    Posted April 9th, 2008 17:00

    I wouldn't expect any uninitiated contact or information from Dell.  Dang I want this monitor...I just want it to work right without endless hassles and returns, no matter the warranty!  I see it is still on sale for $100 off, me thinks its to get rid of the faulty stock to make way for an A01!