UNSOLVED

carlcs

updated

23 years ago

Closed

C

carlcs

1 Message

0

25840

September 17th, 2003 21:00

The mouse buttons on the 8600 stink!

I just received my new 8600 laptop and am really upset with the mouse buttons.  The 8600 comes with two mouse interfaces.  There is the traditional 'stem' interface in the middle of the keyboard, and there is also a finger pad interface on the bottom.  Both interfaces are accompanied by two mouse buttons.  The mouse buttons for the pad interface are fine, but the ones for the stem are horrible.  They are flimsy and you have to press really hard to activate them.  I don't particularly care for the finger pad interface, so I'm finding myself using the stem with my right index finger, and using the finger pad mouse buttons with my left hand.  A two handed mouse interface!!!

I have an IBM T40 that I use for work and I'm very jealous of it.  It has the same two interfaces, but the buttons are excellent.  Not only that, but the stem interface has 3 mouse buttons.  I think Dell could learn a lot from IBM in this area.

I called Dell about this and found to my dismay that there is no interface alternative for the 8600.  I just hope that enough people complain about this that they are forced to fix it.

  • 458

    0

    Posted September 17th, 2003 21:00

    yeah

    those mouse buttons are the same ones on the 8500

    and yep, they were horrible

    you gotta snap down on em to get them to work and they feel like cr$% and don't spring back

    i dunno how anyone can double click with those buttons

  • tsheer

    4 Posts

    458

    0

    Posted September 18th, 2003 02:00

    I agree completely.  The left mouse button next to the space bar is so hard to press properly that it doesn't usually even work when I press it.  I ended up sending the system back.  I really can't use it with a finicky left mouse button.  It's really hard to understand why the pointer stick buttons are so crummy, when the touchpad buttons are fine.
  • mcdavis

    2 Posts

    458

    0

    Posted September 18th, 2003 03:00

    I just rec'd one of two 8600's this evening -- both of which are configured with 7200RPM drives.

    There are two pointing devices -- the trackpoint / thinkpad eraser tip and the touch screen.  Each of them have a set of two buttons.  The buttons and touch pad are both fine.  The keyboard is fine IMO.  The buttons below the trackpoint are absolutely, beyond any kind of doubt, unusable.  They are flimsy and due to the depth they require you to press them, and due to the fact that their initial height is so far below level with the keyboard, they are extremely difficult to use.  I noticed this element of the laptop immediately. 

    Dell, you guys need to come up with a fix for this ASAP.  Someone obviously neglected to comprehend the typical position of the hand why using the trackpoint and the angle which is required to press the buttons from the thumb.

    Solution suggestion:

    Replace the two plastic trackpoint buttons with new ones that are set higher in position and are more sensitive to the touch.  For instance, the button type below the touchpad would be excellent. 

    Question: Does the D800 and M60 have the same problem?  I see these buttons are part of the "blue" plastic stuff that may be part of some Inspiron specific part #.

    I also have to wonder whether the keyboard fix has exacerbated the button problem -- for instance, if the keyboard is now slightly higher in position in order to make it stiffer, the button problem would be more prominent.  I just can't imagine that the original engineer who designed this laptop specified the significant drop in height between the keyboard and trackpoint buttons and then, to compound the problem, would allow for such an inprecise button mechanism. 

     

    Regards, Mark

  • ryri

    2 Intern

    •

    360 Posts

    458

    0

    Posted September 18th, 2003 03:00

    Haha... first they use the alps touchpad and everyone complains about how bad the touchpad feels. Dell listens and switches to the Synaptics, and now everyone complains about the buttons.

    Edit: I guess the 8500/600 use Alps touchpads... that would be the problem.

    Anyway, while it should work better in the first place, you might try removing the mouse and seeing if there is anything you can put underneath to change the resistive feel.

    Message Edited by ryri on 09-17-2003 09:18 PM

  • RandyB

    518 Posts

    458

    0

    Posted September 18th, 2003 15:00

    I believe they were the same buttons on the previous model(s)...before the 8500. Evidently, not everyone learns from their mistakes.
  • ShantiLacy

    14 Posts

    458

    0

    Posted September 18th, 2003 16:00

    Thank you forum members.  You've substantiated a problem I have, among others with my new 8500, and at least I know I'm not alone.  While I would't return the machine due to the buttons although I'm a heavy track pointer user, I will return it if they refuse to replace my keyboard. 

    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Dell Inspiron 8500 with faulty keyboard
    MP4, 2.4GHz, 15.4 WXSGA+
    512MB, 2Dimms
    64MB DDR 4x AGP GeForce4 4200 GO with disappearing mouse under horizontal bar
    40GB ATA hard drive - 4200 RPM - drats!

    DVD/CD-RW combo
    No Dell wireless
    Linksys router & USB wireless adapter

  • 458

    0

    Posted September 18th, 2003 23:00

    I agree entirely! The mouse buttons on the pointer are horrible. You have to press them exactly right, or better, mush them exactly right to do anything. I find I use the trackpad buttons even if I am using the pointer. The trackpad also has a weird lag and I find it very difficult to use properly. I also have a 8100 and the buttons on it are much better. The trackpad on it is perfect. The new Alps trackpad on the 8600 needs to be replaced with the Synaptics, and the buttons for the pointer stick need to be fixed.
  • 458

    0

    Posted September 19th, 2003 02:00

    I just sniffed the buttons and they smell normal to me; like new plastic. 

    But seriously the track pointer buttons truly are unusable in any practical sense.   

    Dell™ Inspiron™ 8600
    Intel® Centrino® Mobile Technology

    Pentium®M Processor,1.4 GHz
    15.4 in WUXGA (Wide Aspect UltraSharp™ Display)
    128MB nVidia® GeForce™ FX Go 5650 4X AGP Graphics
    512MB,DDR,333MHz
    40GB Ultra ATA Hard Drive
    2x CD/DVD Burner (DVD+RW/+R)
    Intel® PRO/Wireless 2100 WLAN
    Dell™ TrueMobile™ 300 Bluetooth

  • tungbach

    2 Posts

    460

    0

    Posted September 19th, 2003 03:00

    Yep!  I was really surprise that Dell quality control let this one go.  I suppose if it works then release it to the customer.  The thing is I find myself using these two buttons a lot and I hope that there's a fix somehow.

     

  • blaxo

    21 Posts

    507

    0

    Posted October 9th, 2003 11:00

    hehe its strange.....

    the trackpoint mouse buttons on my d800 feel fine to me, in both travel distance and sturdiness as well (though i did get used to their SLIGHTLY stiff feel)... and i also have not had the misfortune of getting a keyboard that flexes or deforms like so many other i8500/8600 owners have had (though from what ive heard, dell is offering a free flex-free replacement keyboard unit and installation for those owners that complain about it)....

    i dunno if the d800 is all that different from the i8500/8600, as the hardware is almost identical, with some stylistic and price differences.... i just know that ive heard many complaints from the i8500/8600 crowd and none from the d800/m60 crowd....

    in fact, the only problem ive had with the trackpoint mouse buttons is the fact that the cheap silver coating has almost completely rubbed off on the left side, now exposing the grey plastic button underneath.... probably due to the last 6 months or so of constant usage that ive given this otherwise great machine...

    seeing as the i8500/8600 and the d800/m60 are almost identical, perhaps a keyboard/front unit replacement from the d800/m60 may solve the inspiron mouse problem if one is available - if the new inspiron replacement keyboard units dont do the trick.... :p