UNSOLVED

deepspace

updated

17 years ago

D

deepspace

24 Posts

0

56566

September 3rd, 2009 17:00

Studio 1537 DPC Latency

as suggested by Bill B, here's a thread for all of us having problems with real-time audio, be it fw or usb related.

confirmed both on windows xp pro sp3 and windows 7 (32bit), by disabling acpi.sys in process explorer / process hacker the spikes in dpc latency checker were gone and also was wifi functionality, which was fine because i don't need internet while i'm performing live.

already updated to the latest bios (A09) , the spikes are there even with an integrated sound card.

 

my conf:

studio 1537

core2duo T5800 @ 2.0 ghz

installed ram 2gb

gpu ati mobility radeon hd 3400 series

dvd tsstcorp ts-t633a

fw ricoh 1394

dell wireless 1397 wlan mini-card

  • Happy Dayz

    12 Posts

    1027

    0

    Posted September 4th, 2009 01:00

    I too am extremely frustrated and upset with my Dell Studio 1537 laptop.  I bought it specifically for music production, only to find it was a complete waste of money :emotion-9:

    Model: 1537

    Mem: 4GB

    Net: Intel Wifi 5100

    GFX: ATI Radeon Mobility HD 3450 256MB

    BIOS: A09

    I have tried installing and testing it with Windows XP, Windows Vista Ultimate 32bit and Windows 7 RC 32bit to no avail.

    I experience clicks, pops, skips and crackles when trying to work on audio and it is completely unusable.  I tried going down the Dell support route, seeming as I had purchased 4yr warranty and 4yr accidental cover, only to find that was also a big waste of money, as however well I tried to explain the problem and the situation is was falling on deaf ears.

    I think we could have a case for watchdog - has anyone reported this to them yet?

    A VERY VERY UNHAPPY CUSTOMER

     

  • deepspace

    24 Posts

    1027

    0

    Posted September 4th, 2009 11:00

    no problem, i hope we can have it resolved asap.

  • deepspace

    24 Posts

    1027

    0

    Posted September 15th, 2009 12:00

    any news ?

    i see it's been 6 months since the problem was reported to dell, and i don't see it being resolved..

    bought it a month ago and i really don't have any more time to waste, i need a machine that will work as it is supposed to.

  • saebla

    3 Posts

    1027

    0

    Posted October 14th, 2009 09:00

    Hi All,

    I've been watching the other thread about the other models and I have the same problems, crackling and popping sound when trying to record through any external interface via usb/firewire.

    I've tried WIndows Vista, Windows 7 32bit and 64bit and ubuntu 9.04, all with the same problem. In Ubuntu it was even worse with a short pause instead of a crackle.I had Windows XP installed and suspending acpi.sys did get the problem to go away, but that is not a satisfying solution

    I got the DPC latency checker spikes.They only go up to yellow since the last bios update and the program states the system should work for audio production, but the crackles are still there. Tried disabling various hardware with no improvement.

    I went and bought a TI chipset firewire interface card trying to get the ricoh chipset out of the picture - no improvement.

    Like many other people posting about this issue I bought the laptop specifically for audio production, and didn't think my requirements where that high only wanting to record a track at the time, playing back 8 at most, but obviously it was too much for it, very frustrating indeed.

    My other (work) laptop is an older model and another brand, works fine. green dpc bars all the way and no crackles.

     

    Basically I just wanted to share that I have the same problem with my 1537, and I thought the other thread was enough for you to solve it, but here we are. :)

     

     

    Mathias

     

  • deepspace

    24 Posts

    1030

    0

    Posted October 14th, 2009 12:00

    hi saebla, thanks for joining in.

     

    i hope we'll have a working solution very soon.

  • 1030

    0

    Posted October 20th, 2009 10:00

    I got my studio 1555 yesterday in the afternoon. My girlfriend was home, so she received it on my behalf. I started playing with it at around 8:00 PM, and stopped at 5:00 AM :emotion-3: I slept for an hour, and headed straight to work. I got back home a little while ago, and decided to make my first post

    First, it is a GREAT laptop. Everything is perfect, except for the DPC latency bit.

    Anyhow, I am on Vista 64.This is the first time that I am using Vista on any of my computers. I straightaway disabled/uninstalled all bloat, including Aero. Installed standard software like firefox et al. I can't unbold this section of the text, so excuse me. I hate Vista.

    So, then, I had to try audio. The DPC tool showed all green, but fairly high ones.

    I installed my Presonus FP10 (Firepod) and started recording, and was shattered when I heard all the pops and clicks. To top it all, audio was dropping out. I tried disabling stuff, but nothing worked.

    Did a little more googling and figured that acpi.sys can be suspended using process hacker, in Vista 64. So went ahead and did that, and VOILA! Clean audio, no latency, no dropouts. However, there is an occasional pop (once every 20-60 seconds) , but I can live with that. I can easily overdub it.Besides, my takes in real life are never more than 30 seconds.

    I am so glad that there is a workaround to get audio to work on this (although only to a practical extent). However, I still hope that an official fix comes out

    http://www.2shared.com/file/8558892/7441ccb1/duh.html     (This links to an audio file recorded with acpi.sys on)

    http://www.2shared.com/file/8559301/8863aec6/duh_acp.html (This links to an audio file recorded with acpi.sys suspended)

    Excuse the bad playing, but the difference can be easily heard.

  • saebla

    3 Posts

    1030

    0

    Posted October 22nd, 2009 05:00

    That's cool that there's a workaround for Vista. I couldn't find that process in Win7, I wonder if they removed it or if I just missed it.

    Anyway I've also "solved" this by installing Arch Linux and using ffado svn drivers for my echo audiofire , no idea why it worked with Arch and not with Ubuntu (I also use the irqbalance package, which might be the reason why it works).

    The only issue now is that I can't get the latency below 5ms, I'd really like to get it down to 3ms but atleast the laptop is usable now.

    I got the idea to try Linux again after reading the success story with OSX. I guess Windows handles their interrupts badly.

  • deepspace

    24 Posts

    1030

    0

    Posted October 22nd, 2009 13:00

    That's cool that there's a workaround for Vista. I couldn't find that process in Win7, I wonder if they removed it or if I just missed it.

    i managed to disable acpi.sys in win7 also using process hacker, you probably missed it.

     

  • deepspace

    24 Posts

    718

    0

    Posted November 2nd, 2009 10:00

    I got the idea to try Linux again after reading the success story with OSX

     

    could you send me a pm, i'd like to know which osx distribution works with this model ?

  • saebla

    3 Posts

    727

    0

    Posted November 2nd, 2009 14:00

    I couldn't work out how to send a PM (lol) but that's ok cause I don't know exactly which OSX "distribution" that works, I haven't tried it myself. (OSX on a PC just feels wrong ;) )

    I read it in this post about the same issue on the 1737 model:

    http://en.community.dell.com/forums/p/19279703/19550125.aspx?PageIndex=14

    My guess is if it works with 1737 it probably works with 1537 as well..

     

     

    btw I'm back on Windows 7 (long story) and finally found the thread to suspend.. woop!