
UNSOLVED
Closed
Inspiron 8600 fan issue
Here's the story. On Aug 7, I contacted Dell chat support about a problem where the notebook would only power up about 1 in 10 times of hitting the power button. They suspected a motherboard problem and had me send it in. Got it back a 2-3 days later (very fast turnaround!). The power problem was solved. Yeah. The corrective repair action ("CPA") sheet they sent had "Hard Drive" and "Memory" checked. I hadn't sent in the HD, so assumed that just meant I needed to put it back in (duh!). System Board was not checked, so they must have decided that wasn't involved. Anyway, it powered up each and every time.
So, what's the problem? After a few minutes after powering on, the fan started cycling between off/low/high modes. Never in 2.5 years of owning this 8600 had I heard the fan do that. And, get this, every time it kicks on, there's often a serious hit on the CPU usage. This is obvious by watching the performance chart in the Windows Task Manager and by watching the running apps slow to a crawl. And, the mouse locks up for a while.
So, called Dell Support on Aug 11 and talked to Veronica in Thailand over a 2+ hour period. She had me remove pieces of hardware one by one, but nothing was solved. Interesting clue, however, was she said Dell's records showed they replaced the video card, but not 'memory'. Hmmm? Another clue -- after talking with Veronica, I ran the Express Tests. It failed the Sensor Range Test (Other thermistor temp = 238C, vs min / max of 10 / 100C.
I got on chat support on Aug. 15 and went thru the whole story. Again, they suspected a problem with the motherboard, and had me send it in again. Got it back Monday (Aug 21). The CPA sheet says they repaired the fan. But, same problem persists, only fan is even louder and more forceful than before.
Sorry this is sooo long, but I'm hoping someone out there may have some words of wisdom. Has anyone experienced this, or have a good theory?
Thanks!!!
Responses (4)
Solutions (0)
- Thanks, jkibble. This is my first experience with Dell's service people. I'm wondering if all they got out of my long correspondence with Dell chat was "fan problem" so they replaced the fan. Is a "tech support agent" the same as phone support? I called phone support on the 11th, and that was futile. I'm not real techie, so doing a bios update ... I'll have to look that up, unless someone can tell me how.The express test for the fan just showed what I put in the 1st message -- i.e, temp was 238C but acceptable range is 10-100C. Is there something else it should have told me? I told the chat person about the express test results, and he/she said "The error is pointing to something with the motherboard." But I don't have any reason to think the repair depot touched the mb. As I said before, the CPA just had 'fan' checked.Interesting theory about fan drawing too much power, and less for the cpu. Has anyone heard of this before?I'll probably get on with chat again tomorrow, but want to have as many ideas for them as possible. I am frustrated with someone at Dell, or whoever is 'fixing' things, or the process for handing off notes from Dell to their fix-it vendor, or ??? I've got at least 10 hours on this since the first problem started.:smileymad: The good news is I have 3 months left on the warranty.
- The problem is most likely in motherboard a sensor reading of 238degC is impossible and impliesthat the sensor circuitry (most likely on motherboard) is bad. I'm assuming this is temp sensor insideCPU. Typica; is 40 to 60. A reading of 238 is out of range. Room temp is 25C and water boils at 100C,238C translates to 460degF (what are you computing or cooking pizza).Point out to tech/service the invalid temp reading.
- Thanks wraujr. Kind of what I thought. The laptop doesn't seem unusually hot, but I've told Dell all this, but they ignore this other thermistor temp error. So, for all of you reading this, guess what? Dell is replacing the laptop with another. They promise it will be "equal or better than the 8600" (which is out of production).The 8600 is still under warranty for another 3 months (out of 3 years); that warranty carries to the replacement. Gives me some time to discover any problems.Has anyone experienced getting a replacement pc? Worked out ok?

jkibble
44 Posts
198
0
Posted August 23rd, 2006 21:00